Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Respirator Advice Needed

Posts

Respirator Advice Needed

#1

Respirator Advice Needed

Cody Lewis in LV

>Most of my projects have been small in the past, so even though I should have been using a respirator of some kind even for the short exposures to the fumes, I've never really felt the need. Well now, I'm finishing a large project with several coats of poly, and I can feel the brain cells dying. In fact, the last 3 days I've had a couple nose bleeds and dull headaches, so I know I've pushed it way too far.

I've looked around a bit, but I've noticed that most respirators claim to protect from fumes "except urethane paints" which I'm assuming means that they wouldn't protect against the polyurethane fumes. Is that correct?

Also, I'd love to tap into the knowledge of the message-boarders about what might fit my needs. What do you use/like/dislike? I don't think I need the top-of-the-line product, but I'm also willing to pay for good quality because I love my brain cells and need every one I have.

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#2

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Cody,

All you need is a filter mask rated for "organic vapors"; not a "respirator." You can get one in most any good paint store or in a myriad places on-line.

Then you also need to be ventilating your finishing area to exhaust the vapor outside.

The cure is cheap and easy, unless you're in cold country; then you have to either figure on the heating cost or wait 'till Summer to do your finishing.

|;-}}

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#3

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

Barry Irby

>I have a North 7700 (I think.) Its a half mask and I like it because it is comfortable and it fits under my face shield I wear (or should wear) while turning at the lathe. I usually have combination cartridges on it that are combined HEPA particle filters and activated charcoal. I don't use much poly. Mostly Deft lacquer. Can't even smell it through the mask. I am a believer. I used to cough all winter and just thought it was the dry air. If I am persistent about the mask, I am convinced I cough less/very little.

Whatever you buy, buy spare filters. They don't last forever. 8 hours maybe. Worth it. Like most REAL MEN I did not read no stinking instructions, so if it does not work on poly, I would not know, but they make numerous cartridges.

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#4

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

Cody Lewis in LV

>Thanks for the help, Mark. I'm in Vegas, so I don't have to worry about the cold very often. I think your solution will work perfectly. Thanks again.

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#5

Polyurethane vs. polyurethane

Michael Dresdner

>Cody wrote: "I've noticed that most respirators claim to protect from fumes "except urethane paints" which I'm assuming means that they wouldn't protect against the polyurethane fumes. Is that correct?"

At the risk of sounding like Bill Clinton, I will say that it depends on what you mean by polyurethane.

Some two part urethanes, such as the sort used as automotive clear coats, contain a rather nasty reactant called TDI. The reaction of TDI or one of its kin with a polyol creates the urethane right there on the surface. Like many small molecules, some respirators don't block them.

That material bears almost no resemblance to oil based or waterbased polyurethane furniture finish -- things like Varathane, Bartley, and so on. They are actually just oil based varnishes or waterbased coatings which happen to contain already formed polyurethane molecules. The worst thing in them is usally the thinning solvent, and it is nothing like urethane reactants. In short, most respirators will block those fumes, but not necessarily the ones from two part urethanes.

Either way, the other advice here is right -- you MUST ventilate when you finish and you should also wear a respirator made for the solvents or monomers you are likely to encounter, and change the filters often. The MSDS for the finish you are using will give you enough information to ascertain which respirator you need.

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#6

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Just to amplify a point Barry made, organic vapor filters have a limited life because when exposed to the air, they continue to absorb ambient vapors, even when not being used, until they're "full". You can extend a set of filters' use by 2 or 3 times by placing the mask in a zip-loc freezer-weight bag when it's not in use. That way you can plan in replacing the filters (not the whole mask) after about 12 hours of actual use. Use this type of mask only for finishing. A simpler dust mask is sufficient for other workworking.

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#7

PPS *LINK*

wilbur

>The thing to look for on a label when you go shopping for a respirator or a replacement filter is a "P100" rating.

P means that it blocks oil based particles.

100 means that it blocks >99.97% of particles.

The CDC and NIOSH have all the information you need.


CDC/NIOSH guide to dust filter ratings

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

#8

JL

Re: Respirator Advice Needed

JL

>I have 3-M respirators (1/2 face and full face) with organic vapor cartridges for when I really need them. They are fairly comfortable.