Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

Posts

Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#1

JL

Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

JL

>I want to make a couple of rolling chairs. I was planning on five "feet" with casters.

I was thinking gluing up a center out of 8/4 (to make it about 5 or 6" in diameter) and rounding it and then cutting five flats with my jointer. I would then attach the "feet". The "feet" would be 8/4.

I was thinking about cutting large sliding dovetails in the flats and on the "feet" to join the feet to the center. Stephen suggested using a mortise & tenon joint instead.

Either way works fine by me - in some ways the M&T joint would be easier as I wouldn't have to worry about cutting a dovetail on the center portion or on the ends of the "feet". The mortises and the tenons would be easier to cut. The joints should be similar in strength.

So - what does the collective wisdom say?

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#2

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

Richard Jones

>I would go with the sliding dovetails. Stronger joint in this application, as you are not depending solely on glue as with a M&T. We've all seen those old dining room table and coffee table legs pull apart, even with a M&T. A sliding dovetail would break first.

My $.02.............

rich in va

Matthew 8:26

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#3

M&T

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'd construct the colume as a staved pentagone, then cut the mortices centered on the flats leaving at least an inch+ of solid colume underneath the joints, then turn the colume round. Final construction would be to peg the tenons.

Sliding DT's must be cut all the way from the bottom and would sacrifice too much structural value of the colume since the bottom of the joint will be taking all of the stress.

Issue I see will be getting a good liiking joint on the leg cheeks and shoulders, but that you'll have with either of these joints.

JMV, YMMV |;-}}

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#4

mortise & tenon

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>The mortise and tenon will have far more glue area. I've repaired tripod tables with sliding dovetails on the leg-pedestal joint. The pedestal wood blows out, i.e. cracks and splits.

With either method, I'd put a thick steel spider on the underside of the pedestal to reinforce the joint.

Ed

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#5

Re: M&T

richard jones

>Mark,

Wouldn't the top of the joint be taking the stress? My thought would be to have a stopped dovetail, couple of inches from the top of the center column. Unless you peg the M&T (which I believe was mentioned), you are still relying solely on glue, correct?

Am I thinking backwards?

rich (where's that picture that's worth a thousand words when you need it?) in va

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#6

Re: M&T

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rich,

The weight is channeled down the column and then turns 90* out to the contact points of the 5 feet. That puts the most shear stress at the lowest point of the tenon unless there is a center foot as well. A sliding dt is relying on the mechanical strength of the joint, but with the cut all the way to the bottom of the column, the force is concentrated at the botton point making the wood likely to start a split and then "zip" on up the joint.

In addition, if the glue in the M&T fails, the joint can be repaired by regluing. If the dove tail spits, you got nice firewood on your hands.

I use sliding DT's in two situations. 1. for mounting cabinete top to allow the top of seasonally expand and contract along the joint line and 2. on drawer fronts.

Sorry no pics.

mm

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#7

JL

Re: M&T it is....

JL

>It will be easier to do. Mark, I know what you mean by staved construction, but I don't really see where that would be an advantage. I can get some nice threaded large stock (1 1/4" and 1 1/2") at a very reasonable price (free). I was thinking about drilling out the center hole, turning the central pedestal and then putting the flats on the pedestal.

I find it a bit harder to drill out the center hole with staved construction.

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#8

Center

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Build it in.

With a 6" diameter you have the ability if rip your stock with the 54* bevel on each side, but leave a flat of say 1/4" on the narrow end. You then glue up your 5 rips to get only side grain showing, but with the full width of the glue joints oriented from the center outwards and you have a hole down the middle (BTW,for what?). This provides maximum strength to your column and to your M&T joints because they're made in a single piece of wood (the staved pieces). You can leave the column a pentagon or round it on the lathe to leave flats only at your leg connection points. If you're careful in grain selection, your 5 glue joints will be invisable.

Sure, it's a bit more work ripping the bevels (you can also do it on a planer sled), but (I would think) worth it.

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#9

JL

Re: Center

JL

>So the seat height can be adjusted. As I said, I can get some nice threaded stock in large diameters.

Re: Sliding dovetail or mortise & tenon?

#10

Gotcha

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>So I would still do the staves but cut a notch in the top end which will give you a space to epoxy in a pair of threaded coupler nuts to take your elevator rod.