OT Can some body Explain "Green" and Carbon.....
Barry Irby
>Footprint?
Or tell me where I can read up on it without too much BS?
I don't mean as in green lumber, I understand that.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT Can some body Explain "Green" and Carbon.....
Barry Irby
>Footprint?
Or tell me where I can read up on it without too much BS?
I don't mean as in green lumber, I understand that.
Re: OT Can some body Explain "Green" and Carbon...
Chuck W
>In my opinion its just another way to be politically correct.
Re: OT Can some body Explain "Green" and Carbon...
wilbur
>Hi Barry,
The term "green" refers to objects or activities where a concern for environmental impact was accounted for in the production of the object or in carrying out the activity. For example, looking for a higher MPG when buying a car is being "green" in the sense that by using such a car, you use less gas, and are conserving energy.
The term "carbon footprint" refers to the amount of carbon dioxide that one's activities generate. For example, if you decide to go to the store, and you walk there, that generates less CO2 than if you drove there in a car. By walking, you reduce your carbon footprint.
If your house has a big hole in the roof which lets hot air out during winter, you'll need more energy to maintain the temperature in your house, which ultimately means more production of CO2. If you patch the roof and insulate it well, you'll reduce your carbon footprint.
The problem is that for many things, it is very hard to measure the carbon footprint. Consider an apple. If you have two apples, one grown in upstate New York, and another that came from New Zealand, one would think that the apple from New York would have a smaller carbon footprint than the one from New Zealand, since it doesn't have to travel as far to get to a U.S. grocery store. However, it may be that the opposite is true, since in terms of energy efficiency, New Zealand is better than upstate New York, and the New Zealand apple probably got to the U.S. by boat, which is far more energy efficient than distribution by truck from upstate New York to your local grocery store. The bottom line is, for many things we don't have the data on the carbon footprint that we need to make an informed decision.
[Factual content ends here. The following is opinion.]
However, the fact that we have incomplete data doesn't mean that we should not try to do our part to engage in energy conservation when we can.
Re: OT Can some body Explain "Green" and Carbon...
Joe Pack
>"Green" = theoretically good for the environment; effects or byproducts not as harmful to the environment; a car getting 40 mpg is "green" while my Chevy TrailBlazer and its 16 mpg is not; walking to the gym is "green" while driving there is not.
"Carbon footprint" = generalized expression of the amount of carbon byproducts (mainly carbon dioxide - CO2) given off when using a type of fuel or in the production of materials; burning coal to produce electricity causes a larger "carbon footprint" (produces more carbon dioxide and carbon based particulates - smoke) than producing the same amount of electricity using hydroelectric or wind powered generators; "green" is also relative...newer coal-fired generating plants are "green" (more efficient) compared to 50 year old models that are not
As Kermit the Frog sang, "It ain't easy being green..." I'm too fat for a Prius, and too lazy to walk to the gym. But if I did walk there, I wouldn't NEED the gym!
Carbon Credits for sale on the Hand Tool Board.
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>
Do You Take PayPal?
Joe Pack
>
And speaking of Green....
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
>Ralph Nader is back in the race.
No
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>No plastic, non renewable fossil fuel, electrons burned. No paper money, trees wasted, but cotton is renewable, still no.
Certified Fair Trade Gold or Silver only, delivered by the lowest impact method of transportation.
Wait, If you order within the next 24 hours we will include a free Carbon Debit Card (made from old potato chips) for your future Global Hydrocarbon fiduciary needs.
Stephen
Thank you ! . . .
steve mackay
>While I don't, personaly, buy the idea that climate change is all my fault, you bring up the most important point of all. Whether its my fault or simply natural occurance ANYTHING we do to conserve, preserve and waste less has a benificial effect on our planet.
Re: OT Can some body Explain "Green" and Carbon...
Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA
>Something I didn't see mentioned in any of the explanations is the concept of carbon gain. As wood workers we have some excellent examples of this in the materials we use.
Most people are somewhat familiar with the term Volatile organic compounds or VOC and that the VOC's in the finishes we use are bad for the environment. But what many are not taking into account is the net carbon gain. If one uses shellac it has a higher VOC content than most water based finishes, and this should come as no surprise. but the VOC's in shellac are from wood alcohol and anyone who has ever taken chemistry knows that you cant get more out of reaction then was put into it, therefore the wood alcohol has no more carbon then the tree/plant removed from the environment. now if you look at the ingredients on the water based can it has a few petro based chemicals and so even though it has les VOC's they are now new to the planets overall carbon count.
In discussions about carbon gain it is generally agreed that below ground oil and coal are out of the carbon cycle, while the carbon in plants is part of the carbon cycle.
Now back to our example of finishes. As someone explained about apples it can be difficult to determine how much embodied carbon a product has. boiled linseed oil is a popular finish and has a very low VOC content when compared to many of the tung oil finishes (note I said tung oil finishes and not tung oil) the part that can make it difficult to tell which is more harmful for the environment is that Argentina is the biggest producer of flax, the raw ingredient used to make linseed oil. In contrast much of the tung oil is made from tung nuts grown in Missouri. A question I have not been able to find an answer to is which product actually has more embedded carbon by the time I buy it in my local store and how do those numbers change for different regions of the country.
As wood workers the easiest thing we can do for the environment is to choose sustainable harvested wood or to use recycled/reclaimed woods. As far as finishes go I think there is room for a good discussion on this and I am sure there would never be a consensus, we are wood workers after all.
Robin
Hes still around ?
steve mackay
>
Utter buncombe, bother, & downright silly... *LINK*
David Barnett - SW Florida
>Oh... not always, of course. There've been some lucid and thoughtful answers in this thread. But when marketing seizes it as something to, well... market, whether it's Ben & Jerry's awareness-building ice cream concepts or the fashion industry recommending cooler colors to "offset global warming", I'm pretty sure I'm being Gore-d by the bull, and the bull's spreading.
One of the trades I read headlined it this winter: "...with the sound of imminent peril ringing mightily in our ears." And that's from the Fragrance Foundation*. Don't get me wrong. I'm all for conservation. I'll not unnecessarily frighten a civet when I can get some East African to profitably scrape Hyrax dookie off a rock for a polite alternative.
Just wish the alarmist rhetoric could be less hysterical, I guess. But that's just me. Others will differ.
*http://fragrance.org/PDFs/fforum.pdf
Cute animals alert: rock hyrax family
RE; carbon foot print
Dave Anderson (PacNW)
>The Smithsonion Instute web site has a comprehensive article on green house gases. This artiicle explains in great detail each gas and its effects, as well as the amount in the atmosfer (sp). MIT has one on the composition of the atmosfer. After reading you realize that carbon is nothing but a red herring. CO2 total weight is less than 4% and yearly manmade CO2 contributes .00003% Water vapor is te #1 greenhouse gas and makes up 95% of all greenhouses. Find out fr yourself. Don't believe the media.
Dave Anderson
Re: Utter buncombe, bother, & downright silly...
Robert Henderson
>Amen. But if the alarmists became reasonable, they couldn't rationalize increasing government intevention and control (which is what this is all about).
Re: RE; carbon foot print
wilbur
>Um, I'm not sure how you reached the conclusion that CO2 is not important as a greenhouse gas or global warming from the Smithsonian and MIT websites. I understand that some people may think that there isn't a link between CO2, greenhouse gas, and global warming, but I don't see support for that hypothesis coming from the Smithsonian or MIT.
From the Smithsonian website:
http://www.si.edu/ripley/eap/poster.htm
"The Problem: The Greenhouse Effect. Carbon dioxide and water vapor in the Earth's atmosphere act like a greenhouse, trapping some of the heat the Earth emits and reflecting it back toward the planet. Natural levels of greenhouse warming benefit the Earth, but the degree of warming is increasing. Scientists predict that greenhouse warming could heat up the Earth's climate between 2 and 8 degrees F over the next century....
The Cause: Human activity has caused an increase in the levels of carbon dioxide and other heat-trapping gases -- including chlorofluocarbons, methane, ground-level ozone and nitrous oxides -- which has magnified the greenhouse effect. Global levels of carbon dioxide alone have increased by 25% since the start of the Industrial Revolution. The United States contributes over one billion tons of carbon to the atmosphere each year. Most of this comes from burning fossil fuels -- coal, oil and gas -- in our electric utilities, transportation, industries and buildings. Nearly half of residential energy consumption is used to heat and cool our homes. At one-sixth of residential energy use, water heating is the second-largest source of home energy demand. Refrigerators and freezers account for over one-eighth of our residential energy demand, and about one-fourth is used in lighting, cooking and other appliances combined."
http://nationalzoo.si.edu/Publications/ZooGoer/2005/4/polarbears.cfm
"Average air temperatures on Earth are increasing. Since the start of the Industrial Revolution in the mid-1800s, global temperatures have risen an average of 0.6�C (1.1�F), according to the report of the Arctic Climate Impact Assessment published in 2004. This report was the result of the work of hundreds of scientists from all over the world.
The overwhelming consensus among scientists is that these temperature increases are due primarily to man-made emissions of certain "greenhouse" gases, such as carbon dioxide. Greenhouse gases trap the heat of the sun in our atmosphere. Burning fossil fuels is the main way humans add greenhouse gases to the environment. Before the Industrial Revolution, the concentration of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere was about 280 parts per million. Today it's between 360 and 380 parts per million. That's a 35 percent increase in about 150 years."
http://www.si.edu/research/spotlight/05_04.html
"Ancient Global Warming Led to Ecologic Instability
Findings
Melting of polar ice at the end of a global ice age 300 million years ago was driven by a rise in atmospheric carbon dioxide similar to that occurring today. The changes resulted in severe climatic fluctuations and triggered marked changes in tropical plant communities.
Why It Matters
Carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere are today higher than at any time in the past 650,000 years and will continue to rise this century. "
From MIT:
http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/nr/2003/co2.html
"Although carbon dioxide (CO2), a byproduct of fossil fuel combustion, is the principal greenhouse gas contributing to global warming, methane, nitrous oxide and man-made, industrial-process gases such as hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons and sulfur hexafluoride also are important contributors to climate change.
From an environmental and an economic standpoint, effective climate strategies should address both CO2 and these other greenhouse gases..."
The problems with all that...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>They're running on the assumption that rising CO2 levels cause global warming based on their estimations of what time periods higher temperatures occurred and what time periods higher CO2 levels occurred. Higher temperatures can also cause higher CO2 levels (there's a lot of dissolved CO2 in the oceans, so that when warmed, the oceans let more of it go). Not to mention, we've only had the technology to determine a global average temperature for relatively few years (30, maybe?) with infrared scanning from satellites. Prior to that it was a collection of data from individual thermometers sparsely scattered around the globe (and missing very large portions of it). And even that only goes back at most 150 years. At any rate, if their supposed time frames for rises in CO2 levels causing global warming are even a little off (<10 years), suddenly the cause and effect switch places.
It's kind of like picking up a string. Pick it up high enough by one end and you pick up the whole string--same is true for either end. At one end is global temperature and at the other is CO2 levels.
I also find it interesting that in the '70s we were heading for an Ice Age. Then Mt. St. Helens erupted, spewing more pollution and greenhouse gases into the air than humans have ever generated. And there have been others since...
Jason
Re: The problems with all that...
wilbur
>I don't think this is a venue to argue the science, which I am not doing.
What I am interested in are attributions that are done in an accurate manner.
As I said:
"I understand that some people may think that there isn't a link between CO2, greenhouse gas, and global warming, but I don't see support for that hypothesis coming from the Smithsonian or MIT."
This was to address the suggestion that information on the Smithsonian and MIT websites weaken the links between CO2, greenhouse gases, and global warming. However, the overwhelming message from the information on those websites is that they are linked. Both the Smithsonian and MIT websites have a search function. If you search on those websites for "carbon dioxide" or "greenhouse gas" or "global warming, you'll find many pages that support the link between the three.
This goes against the suggestion that those websites say otherwise.
Again, you may think that there is not a link between CO2 and global warming, which is fine. But you can't say that the Smithsonian or MIT supports this hypothesis, based on the content of their websites.
Fair enough.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>I'm just (like Dave) tired of hearing all the hype in the mass media. I'd be interested to see a poll of the scientists/climatologists involved in terms of their stance on global warming vs. their general politics. Heck, such a poll would probably be enlightening with regards to any issue under dispute in the scientific community.
Jason
Money and science don't always mix well
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>It's funny how money doesn't mix well with certain things sometimes.
Science is one. Health is another. Honesty is another. Mix money into anything and it's likely to sour.
So when I start seeing rethoric about rich countries being required to pay poor countries to not pollute, or not cut down the rain forest, or to compensate other countries because of global warming.... well, I just start to wonder what's really going on.
Science can say something is detrimental to your health, but when health insurnace companies look at the cost of treating it, suddenly some things aren't so bad anymore, or so it seems. I'm particuly amused at how an ice cream company can say that their ice cream is made from cows that have not had a steriod/hormone enhanced diet, and then be banned from such labels because it might sound like steriod/hormone diets for livestock may somehow be unsafe. And who pushes for this ban? The steroid/hormone manufacturers.
Hmmmmm.... put a little money into the equation and science, honesty and free speech become a little clouded.
Money may not be evil, but it sure taints alot of things :(
Happy Woodworking!
Oops!!
Barry Irby
>I did not state my question very well. I did not want to start a discussion about whether global warming and all that is related were a fact or not. I wanted to know how "Carbon Foot print" are being used and maybe some info on how it's being calculated. And perhaps how to reduce mine if it is possible.
And the Same for "Green". I seems like being green in this case could be a good thing. But, how can I tell if I am being green? Things like buying one apple over another seem almost impossible to tell.
I am still holding all the debate about these topics at arm's length and watching. I have questions. If you favor "man causes global warming" you are a "Leading scientist". If you are scheptical, you are a skeptic or a whistle blower or a disgruntled former.... or worse. Yet we have evidence that there were events of global warming before man emerged on the planet. Therefore, man did not cause those events. Major shifts in the climate took place without man's influence, why do we think we are causing this one?
One of the factors is the collapse of the Soviet Union. They failed for many years to maintain the weather stations in Siberia. No weather reports from a big cold area equals and increase in the average temperature.
I really don't want to argue it. It's surpasses my understanding. What does make sense to me is to do things that do not contribute to global warming. Perhaps we can attenuate it or lessen the impact even if we have nothing to do with the cause.