Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Posts

OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#1

OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Joe Pack

>A good friend just took his 2001 motor home (Chevy 454 engine) out of storage. The battery was dead, but started with a jump start. With the original battery being 6-7 years old, I convinced him to buy a new one, which he did.

With the new battery installed, the engine fired up instantly...until the next day. He tried to start the engine, but got only 3 clicks, then nothing. Thinking the new battery was dead (very unlikely), he jump started the engine and it fired right up. He let it run only a few seconds, not nearly long enough to charge it up, then shut it off and fired it up again. The engine started immediately. He repeated he off/on cycle an estimated 12-15 times with no problem. Even a few hours later, the engine started immediately.

The next day, the entire story repeated itself...only a click (a single one, he says), then a quick jump, then no problem starting/stopping repeatedly. He called me again and I told him it sounded like a ground/bad contact problem. I went over to help (complete with wire brush, terminal cleaner and corrosion spray. We took off the battery terminals, cleaned them shiny (the positive had quite a bit of corrosion, the negative was fairly clean), applied sprays and reinstalled the terminals. The engine fired up immediately.

I did suggest that he also take apart and clean the ground at the engine block. He crawled under the motor home and found the block ground, but was a bit uncomfortable laying in 2" of snow, and with fingers pretty much numb from the 20 degree temps, working barehanded and having wet sprays all over his hands. He said he would do it tomorrow (today).

He called about 20 minutes ago with exactly the same problem...a click, a quick jump then repeated ability to start the engine. He was on his way out to clean the block ground after we hung up.

Based on my own experience driving junkers for so many years, I think I'm on the right track thinking it is a ground or connection problem. My friend, on the other hand, is ready to start replacing selenoids, starters, etc. I really doubt the problem is starter related; I don't see how jumping from a little Pontiac Sunbird would negate a bad starter. I hate to see him spend money if he doesn't have to. Am I on the right track here? Is there something else I should be considering? This problem is new; no problems like this before storage.

Any ideas would be appreciated.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#2

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Chuck W

>My guess is once all potential(no pun intended) grounding issues have been resolved then the started solenoid is next on the list.

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#3

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Thomas S Stockton

>My old ford truck did the same thing once, I could get under it and tap the solinoid with a hammer and it would start right up, ended up replacing the starter and it was good to go.

Tom

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#4

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Howard Norman

>Starter solenoid is a possibility. Another possibility is something in the electrical circuits that is leaking and running the batter down in a few hours. An ammeter inserted at the battery connections would be needed to determine if something is drawing current when the motor home is just setting there.

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#5

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Bart Leetch

>My 1978 Ford did the same thing I tightened the lugs on the starter relay & the truck started every time.

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Good advice here.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>With everything turned off in the motor home, take off the negative battery cable and insert an ammeter between the terminal and the cable (in series--one lead on each, not in parallel). If there is a current leak due to a short somewhere, there will be a reading. To find out what circuit is the problem, start pulling/re-inserting fuses one by one. This takes two people--one to watch the meter and hold the ammeter leads in place, the other to pull fuses. When the offending circuit's fuse is pulled, the ammeter reading should drop to zero (or just drop if there's more than one offender). Then you've at least narrowed down where the problem short might be.

It could also be a sticky solenoid such that the little extra juice from the jump vehicle is enough to get it to close.

Be careful here. With dead battery situations, it's easy to burn up an alternator. Alternators are generally not made to be charging dead batteries, so if you run the battery down, put it on a charger, don't jump the vehicle and let the alternator charge it.

Jason

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#7

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>GM's have those side mounted battery cables and the connecting bolt has a small head that is sandwiched at the end of the cable with some washers in the red plastic cable end. My Chevy Tahoe had the same problem and I even changed the starter trying to correct it. Turned out I just wasnt getting a good connection at the positive terminal. After I took the washers out of the cable end and replaced the small headed bolt with a normal size one I never had a problem after that.

Try it and see if that helps, its a cheap fix.

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

#8

Re: OT-Engine won't start all of the time

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have a couple of ideas - first I have had the battery cables corrode on some older vehicles. This is often not apparent as the wires corrode inside the vinyl sheath and visually look ok. Try flexing the cables where they attach to the battery. Also look for any corrosion right near the battery connector. I have also had the battery connection look tight but not seat properly onto the battery. The other issue is with the starter solenoid - I have had more than one GM vehicle with a sticky solenoid. You can usually "jump" the solenoid with a wire (used to be able to use a screwdriver, but don't know if they are still built the same. If it rolls over jumping - then I would replace the solenoid - as I recall they aren't too expensive.