is file sharp?
Jerry Gibbs
>How do I tell if a metal file is sharp or should be replaced? Jerry Gibbs
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
is file sharp?
Jerry Gibbs
>How do I tell if a metal file is sharp or should be replaced? Jerry Gibbs
One way to get a feel for sharpeness...
David Barnett - SW Florida
>...is to take a 6061 aluminum bar (available ubiquitously in big box and mom'n'pop stores) and give it one perpendicular stroke across a corner with light but even pressure. It should smoothly remove between 1/100" and 1/64" inch in a single pass for a resharpened (meaning sharper than new) mill bastard. A new file should accomplish this with more moderate (but still on the light side rather than heavy) pressure. The advantage of testing with a standard (6061) is easy comparison and repeatability. Next, test other materials and write down any info on the sample with a Sharpie, or at least jot a number and key it to your shop log (What? You don't keep a shop journal?). If you keep a benchmark piece of wood or metal handy, you'll always be able to compare in a meaningful and knowledgeable manner. A magnifying glass can help, too.
While file sharpness is important, it isn't everything. I prefer files with a smoother 'broken-in' cut. Maybe a tad sharper than 'new' but less sharp than acid sharpened. Depends on what you're cutting and how you tend to cut it.
Grrr... 'sharpness'
David Barnett - SW Florida
>
Buy a new one and compare them
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
Nt all are created equal
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>When I worked at Channellock many years ago, we used one particular brand of files, Nicolson, becuase they would cut better and last longer than other brands we tried. Our tests showed that this particular brand of file that even though it cost more than some would last longer than all others regardless of price. It has been over 14 years since we did that particular test so I have no idea if that manufacturer is still making he same quality product. In our case we were utting hard steel everyday. I doubt you would ever wear out most files working on wood.
Lee