Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

finish

Posts

finish

#1

finish

GarryF

>I do all of my finishing by hand ( no sprayer) looking for a finish which provides good durability & good quality look. It seems I have better results with wipe-ons. Any one have a good finish or combinations?

Re: finish

#2

Re: finish

Steve Schoene

>There is no one finish for all purposes. When I have made reproductions of 18th. c. pieces shellac was most appropriate. It's more durable than many seem to credit, and dramatically easier to repair if there were to be damage.

I like Waterlox Original/Sealer as my go-to wipe on varnish finish, for lots of things.

On the teak brightwork on my sail boat I use Epifanes spar varnish.

I'm doing interior trim with Sherwin-Willions Pro-Classic oil based enamel. The pro's who did some of the trim got good results with the waterborne version, but I have to use the oil-based to get similar quality.

Re: finish

#3

Adding to Steve's....

David Yoho

>I, too, am a big fan of wipe-on finishes and use them almost exclusively. There are times I will brush or spray because that's either the best choice or only choice. Otherwise, I wipe them and like to use several of those that Steve mentioned.

I wipe on (Zinsser SealCoat) whenever I need shellac. If I think I need some color from the SealCoat, I simple tone it with liquid Transtint dye.

I use the Waterlox Original Sealer/Finish probably more than anything else. I'll tell you the best trick I found for getting great looking results from wiping on Waterlox. I always heard and read the directions were to apply it and wipe it off. I never really did that but after seeing it done properly - apply it, wipe it off - I quickly realized why I hadn't been getting the quality finish I thought I was. I found applying it easier with a foam brush or stand bristle brush. Then I come back and wipe away ALL the excess in the beginning coats. Toward the end, the last few coats, I'm simply wiping on a very thin coat and leave it to dry.

I recently completed a tiger maple blanket chest using the Waterlox and I'll include a photo below for your inspection.

The one finish I use often that Steve didn't mention is Watco Danish Oil. This one is just too easy to apply and maintain and looks right in many situations.

If you're interested in more information on finishing in general and specifically wipe-on and Waterlox, I highly recommend the new DVD series by Charles Neil - Finishing A to Z - Beyond the Books. Just the first one on Oil Finishes is worth the price of the complete set!

David


img

Re: finish

#4

Wow David! Did the Waterlox pop that grain?

Don in Northern Arizona

>That is beautiful. I can't find Waterlox locally where I am in Arizona. I guess I'm gonna have to mail order some.

Don

Re: finish

#5

Ellis Walentine

Nice piece, David!

Ellis Walentine

>I just wanted to jump in here with a variation on your Waterlox technique. The idea of wiping off all excess is important for the oil-varnish mixtures (including "Danish" oils) because the oils don't dry if left in any appreciable thickness on the surface. But Waterlox, being an actual varnish, will dry in any thickness. At $20 a quart or whatever they charge nowadays, Waterlox is just too expensive to wipe off and throw away, for this old cheapskate at least. What I do is to wipe it on incrementally, flooding the surface and continuing to wipe and rub it on until it starts tacking up slightly. I don't wipe any off. Instead, I extend it with my rag (or sometimes my hand, although this is definitely not an OSHA approved technique), so it forms a uniformly thin coat. If I want a satin sheen, I dull the last coat with some 0000 steel wool and then rub just a tiny amount of Waterlox over the entire surface, just to saturate the haze produced by the steel wool.

If I want to build a thicker finish, I will wipe the Waterlox on and leave a thicker wet coat on the surface of the wood. When it dries, I flatten it if necessary before building another coat on.

Diff'rent strokes. Your method has a closer to the wood look and is a fine way to do it.

Ellis

Re: finish

#6

Not Entirely

David Yoho

>The Waterlox just brought out what the dye regimen set up. I began with a trace coat of one color of Lockwood water-based dye. This coat set the base color into the figure. After sanding off the trace coat from the surface, I followed up with a mixture of Lockwood dyes. I applied eight coats of Waterlox, waited a week, waxed and buffed.

David

Re: finish

#7

Alan Young

Carry me back to ol' Virginia

Alan Young

>and to your shop where I can fully admire that beautiful hope chest.

WOW. A beautiful execution of style- wood and finish.

Shop Shot pics coming up on this one?

Alan

Re: finish

#8

Same approach

David Barnett - SW Florida

>I've always used it as a Wipe-On Wipe-Off finish. I simply don't like gloss and although I've always heard I do it 'wrong' (that Waterlox is a 'wipe on' but NOT a 'wipe off' varnish), I've persisted to use it otherwise, giving me that lustrous glowing finish you've demonstrated. For woods such as oak, I sand it in, then wipe off, letting it dry, then I wipe with either maroon or grey 3M pads until I get a soft lustre.

Re: finish

#9

Re: Carry me back to ol' Virginia

David Yoho

>Thank you, Alan. I'm very proud of this project. I'd like to try and put together something for Shop Shots when time permits. The first order of business I need to carry out is getting my son to take much better pictures with his camera very soon. He's been sick the past two weeks and finally ready to go back to school. He's got a lot of catching up to do and his time will be limited again. Sooner or later....!

Believe it or not, I really didn't take too many photos of this project in the early going. It wasn't until almost half way that I took the time to fire off some shots. My camera is a relic by today's standards but takes pretty good pictures. Jereme's Canon is much better and so is his photographer's ability! He needs the shots for a project he's doing at school and I need them for the first item to be featured on my upcoming new Website. We've already registered a domain name and I've got all the space I'd ever need for the new site. All I need now is time, photos, and to do a little HTML.

David

Here's another shot of the chest -


img

Re: finish

#10

On a relative basis

Dan Donaldson

>To me, the cost of the finishing material, glue, or other "stuff" for a hobbyist is almost immaterial. Considering the amount of work and materials in most projects relative to the cost of doing it over if it doesn't work out in the finishing stage.....

If I have any doubt at all of the finish or glue being used (too old etc.), I throw it out and use new. Even at $20 per quart or even more, if I have 20 or 30 hours and several hundred dollars worth of material in the project, I am not going to cut corners on the incidentals. Just me, but it ain't worth the risk to save a couple of dollars.

Re: finish

#11

Re: finish

pecker

>I don't have the experience of using Waterlox that the other respondents have. But I've used several wipe on finishes, and my favorite is General Finishes Gel Topcoat, available at Woodcraft stores. It even smells good...better than Bartley's similar product.


img

Re: finish

#12

Re: finish

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>One I particularly like, if the piece doesn't require too much hard protection (like a dining room table), is Minwax Antique Oil finish. It's a wipe-on/wipe-off finish. Two coats, an I rub the second one in with 600 wet or dry sandpaper. Very little gloss, nice feel, and just the right glow.

Bruce