>I used to subscribe to WOOD, but let it lapse and switched to Popular Woodworking about three years ago, which I like much better. Now I get an offer in the mail for 3 years of WOOD for $24. on the face of it, that seems like a pretty good deal, but I haven't looked at WOOD in a while. I could get one off the newstand, but I hate to decide based on one issue. Anyone here taking it now, and would you do so again? Right now Popular Woodworking is my only one, so I'm not exactly covered up. And $24 for 3 years is not a big investment.
>I subscribe to both "Wood" and "Popular Woodworking". I find that the magazines are somewhat similar. They're both project-oriented and I think they both have decent tool reviews. Construction techniques for the projects usually tend toward the practical end of the spectrum. Popular Woodworking seems to have more hand tool-related coverage, presumably thanks to Christopher Schwarz.
Editorially, I feel like Wood is somewhat repetitive. Seems like once a year there's a "table saw tune-up" article. And once a year there's a "how to use polyurethane" article. And once a year there's a "router tips and tricks" article. And once a year there's the "how to setup your shop" article. The content of these articles isn't a complete repeat... but there is a lot of overlap. Content that appears in the magazine is also frequently repeated in their special issues. And not just one special issue, either! It'll show up anywhere that it might be relevant. Which is a good thing if all you buy are the special issues. Not so good if you subscribe to the magazine and grab an occasional special issue; you'll see quite a few repeats.
>I recently re-subscribed to Wood. I dropped it a couple of years ago for many of the same reasons above - it is much more elementary then the other mags I subscribe to (PWW, WWJ. FWW, WW, Shop Notes). However I think it has improved a bit and hope I may keep it for a bit.
>I have received the 3 year offer and will not be reuping the renwel when it comes due. It seems that the projects are very plain lately and there magazine lately has a two or three page ad for a major tools company, that is sopposed to be a atricle on new tools.
>Frankly, most of the woodworking magazines out there vary in quality (which is in the eye of the beholder anyway) between issues. For $24 (which you can't much even one decent tool), I don't think you can go much wrong taking up the offer of a three year deal. If you can learn just a couple new tips or techniques from your $24 subscription, or complete one or two projects, I think you have made a deal from it. Even FW has its share of critics.
>Wood may not be the best of it's ilk, but it is a good read. Yes, there are some repeats on topics, but how many topics of a general enough nature to attract a wide range of readers are there? Like most woodworking mags, I use Wood for ideas, to keep up on what is new (even if that means looking at the advertisements) and, sometimes, a new twist on an old project or technique.
At $8 a year, you can't go wrong, even if you use it for "reading in the throne room" material. My subscription goes for another couple of years, but if I get the offer and can use it to renew like I did last time they had a promo like this, I will do it. I get tired of looking at just fishing magazines in the "library."
>I subscribed to most of the woodworking magazine at one time or the other. At first they interested me. I had favorites ,but WOOD wasn't one of them. I liked Fine Woodworking and The American Woodworker. Then Readers Digest purchased AW and the whole editorial staff, who knew woodworking, were replaced by number crunchers. Ellis, had been the editor so when I heard he started a website, I came here and now this is where I read and learn more then I ever got from all the magazines. I try to contribute here both monetarily and with whatever wisdom I have aquired in 50+ years of woodworking and learn something new almost everytime I come to this site. But unless I get a laptop, my reading material on the throne is limited to whatever material my wife has left from her last visit
>I got the same offer. I thought long and hard about accepting it, but I just couldn't do it. It is a great price, but when I thought about how much actual content there was in it, I decided to pass.I usually look at each current issue at the newsstand, and decide if there is anything I can use in each issue. I haven't bought an issue in several years.
As others have said, it is on a more elemantary level than the other woodworking magazines. It also takes a patronizing tone when answering reader's questions. i love a bargain, but this is not a good deal for me.
It all depends on your level of woodworking. For guys like me, who are still in the "birdhouse" stage of woodworking, it is an excellent magazine. The projects are just my speed and the tips are sometimes real eye openers. Not to mention the jigs. I just love making jigs! I make jigs I don't even use. They are so cool!
So if you haven't outgrown Wood yet by all means subscribe at that great price.
BTW- you don't have to buy a copy to get a look at the latest issue. Just check the website.
Like some of the other members here at WC I too have let my subscription to WOOD lapse. I was also receiving American Woodworker. I let that lapse too. As with most magazines, it seems there is lot space devoted to advertising and too much of the same thing in most of them.
I'm not an idiot, I understand that the ads pay for a lot of the production costs etc. of the "mags". I just found that there was too little woodworking "stuff" for me to justify the costs any longer.
I was also a little annoyed that I was constantly getting the "RENEW" now ads in our mailbox almost every 6 months.
I now receive WOODSMITH which I enjoy very much. It too has some of the same features and articles as most "mags" but it's my latest favorite. Maybe in time I'll go back to WOOD or AWW.
Personally, I do subscribe to Wood. I have to say If you think you might be missing out on much you should go to a well equipped magazine rack (which is were I usually hang out while my wife does her shopping)in a convenience store. You'll come to relise most all the woodworking magazines at one time or another will pretty much come full circle and build the same types of projects or test the same types of tools. "Why"??Becouse they poll us, As woodworkers on websites.