Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Strength of steel angle for mobile base

Posts

Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#1

Strength of steel angle for mobile base

jeff

>Hi all

In my workshop revamp, I want to rebuild the mobile base under my old jointer.

This is a 3 legged 12" all iron monster. Weighs between 1000 and 2000 lbs.

My current mobile base is made from 4x4 pressure treated timbers.

The timbers have finally sagged to the point of needing replacement.

Anyone know if I could use 3" angle iron steel for the 5' sides instead of the timbers? Are they strong enough? Or do I need to go larger (4") or to tubular.

I tried to find a chart of the strength of the steel and also asked the supplier. No luck.

Seems to need alot more info on steel type, specs, etc.

I know some of the manufactured mobile bases are rated well over 1000 lbs, and seem to be made of pretty thin steel.

Also, Can I bolt it or will it need welding (I don't weld and would need to have it done for me.)?

I usually build my mobile bases from plywood and casters, but this is way to big and heavy.

Any help is appreciated.

Jeff

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#2

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

Stuart Hough

>Jeff, I have used angle steel for a mobile base I built, but not for anything near 1,000 lbs. Without going to an industrial supply house I don't think you can find much that would carry that weight that would be considered affordable anyway. A thought that popped into my brain while reading your post was this...why not try new pressure-treat, or maybe some suitable hardwood and run the angle on the corners above and below, basically folding the inside corner around the edges of the wood (top and bottom). Then fasten it with 1/4-20 bolts along the sides, and 1 1/2" machine screws along the bottom and top. This should allow the vertical sections of the angle to act almost like an I-beam, where the verticals provide provide resistance to the weight and help prevent the sagging you experienced with the old base. Seems like it would work...

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#3

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Jeff,

I am certainly no expert on this, so take it for what it's worth. I assume your jointer has adjustable leveling feet on it. If so, I would think the bulk of the weight of the jointer would be on them which would place the weight of the machine over the casters. Therefore, the 3" angle would be more than sufficient. The commercial units I've seen use angle much smaller than 3" and they don't seem to have a problem.

My 2 cents

Ray Binnicker

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#4

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

John K Jordan

>>would place the weight of the machine over the casters...the 3" angle would be more than sufficient.

That was my gut feeling as well - the long sides might do no more than keep the corners aligned. 3" angle iron is pretty hefty stuff. I have a trailer made from 3" angle iron that I've used for 4-wheelers. Note that angle iron comes in different thicknesses - what I have is about 1/4" in thickness.

Angle iron is pretty cheap as well if you don't try to get it at the borg. I sometimes buy from a local steel fabrication shop. They often have offcuts that will fit my needs but if I have to buy a whole length (20ft) they cut it in half for no extra charge.

That said, I prefer to use square or rectangular tubing rather than angle iron. It's stronger, looks better, and I think it's easier to fit and fabricate with. However, it is difficult to bolt up so welding would be better. For casters, I like to weld square or triangular plates in the corners.

As for welding vs bolting in general, my choice would be welding since it takes up far less space than bolts with nuts so the frame could be made to fit closer to the equipment (if needed). Might be a good time to go get one of those inexpensive wire welders! If you need to get it welded, it should be pretty cheap to get done at a weld shop if you already have the pieces cut to size and ready to weld up.

JKJ

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#5

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base *LINK*

ScottS

>Unfortunately, there's no simple chart for this situation. If you really want to know the answer to this question, you'll need a copy of Machinery's Handbook or perhaps some other physics or engineering text. There's a great little program called BeamBoy that will do all of the necessary calculations for you. It's a bit rough around the edges, but basically you can define a beam, supports (= casters), and loads (= jointer) and it will compute the deflection. IIRC, it has built-in tables containing the modulus of elasticity and moment of inertia for various steel forms (angles, I-beams, U-beams, etc) though you may have to poke around the program to find them.

As far as assembling the steel to create a mobile base, I think you're going to have to weld. Of course, I own two welders and think that welding is more fun than woodworking... Welding would give you the cleanest design, in my opinion. If you don't weld, then you'll have to add additional metal to reinforce the corner joint. When you butt two L-shaped pieces of metal together at 90-degrees, only two of the faces will overlap. You'll need to add a 90-degree bracket to tie the other two faces together. And I would think you'd need some fairly substantial bolts.

Someone suggested buying a cheap wire welder. I would caution you against this. The problem is that the welding capacity of a cheap, 120V wire-feed welder is limited. A 220V wire-feed welder (a.k.a. MIG, a.k.a. GMAW) is really a much more versatile tool. Think of the 120V welder as a benchtop table saw and the 220V as a contractor or hybrid saw. Miller and Lincoln are the only two brands to consider and they'll set you back around $600-700 for a new 220V machine. Also, keep in mind that MIG welding and woodworking don't mix. MIG welding creates lots of sparks, which don't mix well with sawdust, finishing materials, or raw materials!

Probably cheaper to have the work done by a local shop. You might also look into having a mobile welder come to your place. If you prepare the metal, it shouldn't take that long to get it all welded together. See if you can find someone who works in your area that will stop at your place on their way home or between one job and the next. Or use classified ads like Craig's List to find a hobbyist welder that can do the work for you.


BeamBoy

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#6

Hi all

jeff

>All Good Ideas.

Now I wish I'd taken a few more engineering classes in collage.

The metal supplier up here has a fellow who also fabricates stuff to order. Cheaper for me to have him weld it then for me to buy and learn the tricks needed.

I think I'll ponder all the ideas (and anything extra that comes in) and work up a solution.

I'll probably end up being smart and have it welded.

I did think of one more option. The local trade school has a welding class. I might talk to the teacher and see if one of the students wants a class project.

Jeff

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#7

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Heavy iron monster? Is there not some way in your shop remodel to make this beast be a stationary tool and let the smaller tools move around IT? My 3-toed jointer is a little bigger at 16", but I can't imagine putting him on wheels even if he was 12". Besides, "Frank" likes being right in front of the door to welcome people and show off when then come in.


img

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#8

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

jeff

>Hi Joanne

Mine looks exactly the same.

It sits mostly in front of the large overhead door of my shop.

But I sometimes need to move it to gain workroom or use the door.

Jeff

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#9

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

>Joanne, that looks like an aircraft carrier!

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#10

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

John K Jordan

>>...The problem is that the welding capacity of a cheap, 120V wire-feed welder is limited.

This is true, but it is surprising what you can weld with a cheap wire welder. Before I got a 220 welder I used the wire welder (with flux core wire) for thicknesses up to 1/4" around the house and farm. For heavier steel I would run several passes. It is even more important in this case to properly prepare and bevel the edges. I did some weld bend tests at one time and the results were entirely acceptable. (I spent years in the structural and nuclear weld inspection business.) Welds with flux core wire are pretty messy with spatter but that is all cosmetic. You admittedly do not get the penetration as with a hotter welder, but I no longer work with nuclear specs. :) Another nice thing about the 110 welder for "casual use" is the ability to use it in the shed or barn where there is no 220.

But a 220 mig welder would be an excellent choice if in the budget.

JKJ

Re: Strength of steel angle for mobile base

#11

BeamBoy software

John K Jordan

>I downloaded and tried out the BeamBoy software. I can use this, thanks.

JKJ