Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

I thought the project was simple. . .

Posts

I thought the project was simple. . .

#1

I thought the project was simple. . .

stephanie

>I am remodeling a living room and went to IKEA for ideas (and yes I know this was my first mistake :) ) I saw some very simple floating wood "cabinets" that were roughly 18"Hx18"Dx36"W, they were just rectangular with simple no trim front panels, I of course hate all of the stains they had available and I know the price was outrageous. Now I am not the most savvy woodworking individual but I have managed to create several pieces I am happy with....my question is why can't I find any plans for something like this anywhere? Have I lost my mind or am I just not looking in the right place? Any ideas and or tips on how to find plans or just tips on how to construct would be much appreciated.

Thank you,

Stephanie

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#2

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

Dick Coers

>Plans on making a 5 sided box? Shouldn't need plans for that. What type of equipment do you have? How about edgebanded and biscuits, V bit in a router/table saw for miter corners, solid wood and dovetails, baltic birch plywood and no edgebanding with biscuits, etc..........You may be the first person that I have heard say that IKEA had high prices. Have you priced any hardwood plywood lately? When my son asks about me making something he saw at IKEA, I tell him that the cost of my material will just about be the same as IKEA's final price. Good luck!

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#3

Just do what most of us did when we started,

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>We go in and measure the heck out of something we like and then go home and make it. I'd have to echo Dick's remark to your comment of IKEA items being pricey. It may cost you more and take longer.

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#4

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

John K Jordan

>If you can take a post some pictures of the piece, some here might be able to give advice. It might also help to know what kinds of tools you have access to and experience with, e.g., a tablesaw, router? Also, do you want to use solid wood, plywood, cover with veneer, etc.? You said "simple no trim front panels" - does this mean doors with hinges? If so, were the hinges hidden or visible?

JKJ

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#5

Re: Just do ...yeah, Eddie, but...

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>won't she have something better built and won't it last longer and won't she have far more enjoyment of it? :) Just tugging your chain a bit, my friend. LOL

Stephanie,

You go, girl. It's just a box without a face frame. Sounds like European cabinetry to me. And Eddie has a point. Got a camera on your cell phone? Go into stealth mode. Measure AND photograph! Post a picture or two here and let us have at it! :)

Money ain't everything.

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#6

Re: Just do ...yeah, Eddie, but...

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Got a camera on your cell phone? Go into stealth mode.

At the IKEA here, she wouldn't even need to go in stealth mode, I've seen several people take photographs of the room mockups. I assume they were all woodworkers, probably just wanted to remember the arrangement or something. ;-)

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#7

Re: Just do ...yeah, Eddie, but...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>You don't even need a tape measure.

When I was first starting in the furniture copying business, there was a couch my wife and I liked at the local store. I had no tape measure, so I did the next best thing and measure it with an envelope - laid it end to end and counted the number of times it took for each dimension.

Bruce (whose son is still sitting on that couch 30 years later)

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#8

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

John McGaw

>This may get me boos and hisses from the regulars but I have to ask: the project you describe is a box; you know how big the box needs to be; why is a "plan" necessary? If you can visualize a simple project (and many of them fall into this category) as a box or a series of boxes and there is no need to achieve a match some pre-existing piece with millimeter accuracy or precisely create some fiddly bits of ornamentation, why not just wing it? At most I could see a quick jotting on a piece of scratch paper to figure out dimensions of the main pieces and to get the proportions right.

Working out a piece of furniture this way is good mental exercise. Sometimes you will make a mistake but most of them are not serious and can be ignored in the overall scheme of things. Sometimes you will make a more serious mistake and not realize it at the time. These are all parts of learning. It took me a while to realize the big error in my drop-front desk: in my desire to give myself a large working surface I made the top so deep that nobody of lesser stature than an NBA center could easily reach the storage compartments from a seated position. Life goes on and I've learned to think about such critical distances a bit more carefully.

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#9

There is help

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Many of my first pieces I was afraid to do without plans. Even with plans they never seemed to work out just right. However, I've been moving away from plans lately (for one I'm selling pieces and I don't want the infringement headaches) and I'm finding it's not that hard to do.

A good bit of advice is to look up some books and furniture design and fundamentals of woodworking. Fine Woodworking has some good books, as is the big set that I think Lie-Nielsen puts out. Fundamentals will tell you that ways you can make a box, table, chair, cabinet, etc. They'll tell you how to do butt joints, rabbet & dadoe, dovetails, sliding dovetails, etc and where each can be used well. The design books will go into some aesthetics, principals, build for usage, looks, etc.

I think that between these two you can come up with very good things on your own. Really, the best advice I can give is "don't be afraid to try". Once you start doing some pieces and learning methods of joinery and construction you'll be walking around furniture stores saying "Yeah, but I can do that better".

If you are doing some case work and want free standing strength, housed sliding dovetails are a great joint. Not the easiest to create, but not the hardest either. Pop Woodworking had an article on them a couple of issues back.

And I second the ideas to attach a picture or sketch drawing, plus let us know what tools you work with.

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Just do ...Measurements...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>1. Just look at the description tag on the item. Ikea generally has all the measurements listed there. Makes it easy; or,

2. Ikea provides measuring tapes all over their stores. Just pick one up and go for it.

3. Cell phone pictures, or any pictures would probably be helpful in keeping the goal in mine.

Jim D.

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#11

Ha, ha, ha...

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Hey, Carol, I just got back from a week long Greene & Greene furniture class will Darrell Peart and I found out that only last year did he put a piece of his own crafted furniture in his house. I got the same reply from William Ng who said he couldn't afford himself. There went my vision of Chico Sakman's house all full of his lovely furniture. I wanted to make a Green & Greene style coffee table, but now I second guessing it. I'm sure Nancy wouldn't want to see my feet on it or a can of beer and a plate of chicken wings on it during a football game. Sigh.

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

#12

Re: I thought the project was simple. . .

ScottS

>Unlike the other people here, I'm not going to tell you "it's just a box".

It sounds like what you want is a wall-hung cabinet without a face frame. It wasn't too long ago that I'd never built a cabinet of any sort and I had a bunch of questions, too: Does the top rest on the sides or fit between them? How do you hang the cabinet on the wall and not have it fall off when it's loaded with stuff? What material won't sag over time? Which hinges should I buy?

As it turns out, building a cabinet isn't that difficult but there is some stuff you need to know. I'd suggest you look for books, articles, and videos on building kitchen cabinets and/or bookshelves. Here are some specific resources:

1) "Building Frameless Kitchen Cabinets" by Danny Proulx. There are two main styles of cabinets: face-frame and frameless. The majority of cabinets built in the U.S. are of the face-frame variety. Frameless cabinets originated in Europe, but are becoming more popular in the U.S. Almost all of the Ikea cabinets and bookshelves that I've seen are of the frameless variety. Danny Proulx has one of the best step-by-step guides to building frameless cabinets. His book won't include specific plans for the cabinets you want to build, but he will show you all of the necessary techniques.

2) "Build Your Own Kitchen Cabinets" by Danny Proulx. This book is very similar to Danny's other book, but specifically covers face frame cabinets. Decide on the look you want and buy one book or the other.

3) "Building Kitchen Cabinets" by Udo Schmidt. I don't like this book as well as either of Danny Proulx's books, but it might be more readily available. Mostly focuses on face-frame cabinets, but there are a few pages devoted to frameless cabinets. IIRC, this book may spend more time on installing cabinets than Danny Proulx's book.

4) The New Yankee Workshop. This public television show hosted by Norm Abram is currently doing a mini-series on kitchen cabinet construction. Norm is building face-frame cabinets but you may find some good information in these shows. Look specifically for the "Kitchen Cabinet Basics" episodes.

5) Read woodworking magazines. Specifically, I'd recommend "Wood" and "Popular Woodworking". These magazines are project-oriented and focus on tools and techniques that might be available to your average hobbyist woodworker. You might be able to use online indexes to locate back-issues that would help with your current project. I think that both of these sites also have articles and plans available, which might be helpful.

These should get you pointed in the right direction and allow you to narrow down your questions.

FYI, as others have pointed out: you're unlikely to be able to build anything as cheaply as you can buy it from Ikea. As someone else already suggested, you'll be lucky to buy the raw materials for the same price that Ikea charges for the finished product!