Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Posts

Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#1

Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

My 2 yr old Porter Cable ROS just gave up the ghost. It quit spinning and then the pad fell off! Never saw one do that before.

Anyway, now I'm looking for a new sander and I see that a couple of different makers offer variable speed. Is there any advantage to paying the extra bucks for this feature?

Thanks,

Gary

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#2

Yes, certainly........

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I like variable speed on alot of tools, but especially on a RO sander. I can turn it down just a tad and get the vibrations to sync up with my natural rhythm and then all is right with the universe :)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#3

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Dave's Not Here

>I have a total of 4 ROS's, all single speed. Honestly, I can't recall ever wishing I had one with a variable speed setting. To me, variable speed control on a hand held sander is in the same league as lasers on other tools but, that's just me.

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#4

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>I have it. I don't know what its set on. I don't remember ever changing it.

So what else could you get with the extra money? No point in saving money if you can't get an extra treat or two. :)

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#5

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Ed Wozniak, Buffalo, NY

>I run mine real slow to sand drywall. Other than that it is wide open.

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#6

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Gary, I do use mine. Depending on the grit, the wood, I change the setting. When I use a polishing pad (just held on by sandpaper) I use the slowest speed. My palm held ROS is single speed.I use it only for light sanding.

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#7

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Never used it on my old PC. On my Festool, I use it often as the sander (ETS150/5) is way more aggressive from the start. It is especially useful when I'm using it for flattening a finish or trying not to overdo a light corner rounding.

Jay

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#8

Re: Yes, certainly........

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Mark,

I hadn't thought about using it for vibrational attunement with the rest of the universe. Usually I use meditation for that. Perhaps you've discovered something important here. 8^]

Thanks all,

I think I'll probably save a buck or two and go with the single speed. There always seem to be budgetary constraints on whatever I purchase.

Gary

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#9

Absolutely

David Yoho

>Both of my Festool ROS are variable speed and I find myself using it more and more. Most recently I was using my Rotex with 80-grit to rough-sand some maple. The paper didn't seem to be cutting as well at full speed and it was harder to control. I cut the speed to 4 and it made all the difference in how it sanded and being able to control its movement.

Up until I bought these Festools, I'd always used single speed ROS. I didn't think I'd ever change the speed on the new sanders but I've found I do more all the time. I also find that it does make a difference in the end result.

David

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#10

Yes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I use a 6" PC 7336 that has VS. Wouldn't trade it. I use the slower speeds for heavier grits and (big surprise) increase the speed along with the grit size. Helps to reduce heating and glazing the paper, gives better control, and the courser disks seem to last longer at lower speeds. Higher speeds give more even scratch pattern on the finer grits.

Second reason is that I also use my PC as a buffer for rubbing out finishes; slow speed to spread the compound, higher for polishing.

mm

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

#11

Re: Variable speed on a random orbit sander?

Barry Irby

>You did not ask, but why don't you fix the one you had? I have and older PC333 and it died. I bought a newer one and found several differences. The old one a round dust discharge and I have a small shop vac hose that fits right on it so snugly I can use it for a hand on the ROS. The new one had an elongated cartouche or oval port, meaning I would have to start all over with the dust collection. Beyond all that, the newer one was made in China and looked like crap compared to the older one. So, I did two things. I talked the local guy at Home Depot into selling the display at a discount because it was an older model and I repaired the broken one.

My bet it the main bearing in it went bad and fell apart. The new brain was about $9 from the Porter Cable site. I bought and additional piece and with shipping it was about twenty bucks. It seems to be good as new. Its a variable speed and I occasionally use the feature, but the other one is not and it gets lots of use.