Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

Posts

Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#1

Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This post describes what causes the drying defects �case hardening� and �honeycomb� and how to spot it in rough lumber.

What causes it- By understanding some fundamental wood properties it is then easy to understand how these defects occur. First, when wood is hot and wet it is plastic. In this state it will deform(change shape or size) in response to stress. We take advantage of this property in steam bending. When subjected to a hot, wet environment the wood can be bent(deformed). Once dry, wood is rigid. Second, wood shrinks when it is dried from its fresh sawed(green) state to its kiln dried state.

Ideally, when wood is dried it is dried slowly enough that no moisture gradient develops within the boards- the outside portion of the board remains the same moisture content as the interior. If there is no moisture gradient within the board the board shrinks equally across its thickness and no stress is developed. Let us see what happens if a moisture gradient develops across the thickness of a board during drying as a result of drying the board too quickly. As the outside of the board dries the outside dimensions of this board try to shrink. But if the inside is wetter the inside does not shrink as fast as the outside. This situation puts the shrinking outside of the board in compression as it tries to squash the wetter inside. This situation is called case hardening.

Once the outside of the board is dry it is no longer plastic and it can not continue to shrink as the inside of the board continues to dry and shrink. To word it another way, the dry outside of the board has set up at a bigger size than it would have if the inside was dry. As drying progresses the inside continues to dry and shrink and pull on the now rigid outside dimension of the board. This situation puts the inside of the board under tension. This tension can be relieved by the board cracking. This cracking is called honeycomb.

Case hardening is a serious issue for us. This lumber is under stress and therefore not stable. When we saw case hardened lumber this stress is relived and the sawed pieces will change shape. Saw kerfs can pinch together or spread apart. Resawed pieces will instantly bow and cup.

Honey comb is a fatal flaw. This lumber is internally fractured and worthless except for sheep pens.

How to spot it- Case hardening will only show up when the lumber is planed or sawed. Honeycomb is hard to spot in rough lumber but it can be done. Usually the internal cracks don�t propagate to the outside of the piece but the internal stress will usually distort the outside shape of the piece. Note in the picture the cross section of this honeycombed piece is not the regular rectangle one would expect. The outside surface of the board is rippled and distorted. Once the board is planed the internal cracks are revealed as seen in the planed board.

Case hardening can occur in any species. It is a drying defect and you may be able to get your supplier to refund or exchange the lumber. I have only seen honeycomb in oak, as illustrated in the white oak in the picture. You should expect your supplier to exchange any lumber that you discover is honeycombed.

As an aside I will mention why these problems show up. The kiln may be mismanaged and they are drying lumber too fast. This situation is not unknown, but it is rare. The air flow within the kiln may be not uniform as a result of improper stacking, or a fan or baffle failure. More commonly, the lumber going into the kiln may not be uniform moisture content. This situation was more common when lumber was pre-dried outside before going into a kiln. In small kilns it is distressingly common for the operator to load lumber of different thickness to get the kiln full. Large operations that may have 200,000 bdft of lumber at risk in a kiln usually don�t have these problems because they manage their kilns properly.


img

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Is it just me...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...or does the end cut, in addition to the honeycomb, show the "hardened case" by the lighter 1/16" of wood around the perimeter?

Thanks for the post, Bill.

Jason

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#3

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeyc

Steve Schoene

>Go through the lumber at Home Depot or the like. These defects are not nearly so rare as at a respectable yard.

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#4

Re: Another educational article, Bill.

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Bill,

Can one find case hardening or honeycombing in air-dried lumber? I ask because I found similar splits in some oak I used last summer and I know the wood never saw a kiln. At the time, I assumed that the internal cracks were caused by the tree cutter. Now, after reading your post and seeing the photo, I'm not so sure.

al

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#5

answers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There are lots of causes of cracks in lumber and too fast air drying is but one of them. When oak gets honeycombed in a kiln, when viewed from the end the cracks are typically lens shaped voids rather than simple line cracks. Wind shake is another cause of cracking. In this case the cracks follow the growth rings.

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#6

interesting point.

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't know.

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#7

Re: Another educational article, Bill. *LINK*

John K Jordan

>>...I found similar splits in some oak

Everything I've read indicated that honeycombing is caused by too rapid drying with too much heat, not from air drying.

In the absence of other weaknesses in the wood, honeycombing generally presents itself in a radial direction along the rays. (examples below) There are other, better photos in Hoadley's book "Understanding Wood" which is highly recommended to anyone interested in, well, understanding wood.

You said you found "similar" splits in air-dried wood. If the splits you saw were along the rings as some of those in Bill's picture, perhaps they were from "ring shake" or "ring checking" instead of honeycombing. I've had log sections literally fall apart even when soaking wet green, separating along the rings. I understand ring separation and even honeycombing can be caused or worsened by bacterial infection weakening the wood, especially if it is only present or worse near the ground end of the log.

I suspect that Bill's example had some pre-existing weakness along the rings which opened during the same compression/tension stress cycle that led to the honeycombing.

BTW, Hoadley's recipe for creating casehardened and honeycombed examples: coat the ends of a freshly flatsawn oak board with thermosetting sealer and place it in an oven heated to at least 212F for a day or two.

The link below is to some honeycombing info on WoodWeb. Search their Knowledgebase for more on honeycombing.

JKJ


img

http://www.woodweb.com/knowledge_base/True_honeyco

Re: Reading Your Boards- case hardening and honeycomb

#8

Interesting Picture

Barry Irby

>The cracks appears lens shaped as Bill suggests and just about exactly perpencular tothe growth rings. Hmm?