Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT - Lawn tractor ?

Posts

OT - Lawn tractor ?

#1

JL

OT - Lawn tractor ?

JL

>I'll be in the market for a small lawn tractor whenever spring comes.

The lot has a slope to it (5-10 degrees) and is a bit large to mow by hand. I'll only be mowing a bit more than an acre.

Having never bought (or driven even) a lawn tractor, I thought I would solicit some opinions. How much HP would be good? Brands to look at (and brands to avoid)? We have both a Home Depot and a Lowes relatively close as well as a large Ace Hardware affiliate.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#2

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Love our 17.5 HP, 42" John Deere. It makes the MTD look like a toy, the body and deck literly fell off after three seasons. Not good for $1200 in 1998.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I like my John Deere - 17.5 hp, L110, a 2004 model. I mow 1� acres in the Summer and plow a 200 foot driveway in the Winter. It's all pretty much level, though.

Bit of unsolicited advice - DON'T buy from HD or Lowes. Get your power equipment from a real dealer - one that stocks accessories and repair parts, and that has a service department. You probably won't need repairs often with a Deere or a Cub Cadet, but having a dealer handy is always a good thing.

My Deere came froma local dealer. My neighbor's came from HD. When the neighbor had a problem, HD wanted $300 to ship it to Cleveland - 75 miles away - for warranty work.

My dealer would have fixed mine for free (under warranty) if I brought it to him, or $50 if he came to me and picked it up & delivered it back. I've never needed repairs on mine yet, though (at 150 hours on the meter).

Jim D.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#4

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

John K Jordan

>My experience: I bought a used lawn tractor when we moved to the farm and I used it for a while to mow about an acre around the house. It had a pretty good slope to it. (You can see part of the hill in the photo below to get an idea of the slope.) It was the first riding lawnmower I ever had, always using a self-propelled lawnmower in the past.

I'll tell you this - that thing wore me out on the hills! It was slow, bounced enough to jar my bones, and felt very unstable with the slightest tilt. I mowed straight up an down and it was frightening to even turn at the bottom of the hill. It had a 14hp engine which was enough power, but perhaps one with bigger tires and wider stance would have been a lot better.

I bought a Toro zero-turn mower with an 18hp engine, 52" cut. There is no comparison. Due to the lower center of gravity and the wider separation between the tires, the Toro feels much more stable so I can cut sideways with comfort. The tires are bigger and the ride is much smoother. It is so much easier to maneuver around bushes and trees. The real kicker is I can mow literally in 1/4th the time of the riding lawnmower! As a result, I ended up mowing more area - around the fields, etc. The only down side is it will slide a little when turning on a hill when the grass is wet. I used it for a couple of seasons.

BTW, I still have the Toro but don't use it much now - I moved up to a 25HP diesel powered Kubota zero turn mower with a 60" cut, hydraulic deck lift, cup holder, the works. :) It puts the Toro to shame in speed and comfort and the terrain it can handle. (I even use it to mow under the trees in the woods!) I can mow in 1/2 the time as with the Toro zero turn, EIGHT times faster than with the lawn tractor!

For your situation, perhaps try the mowers before buying - that might help get the best thing the first time. The better equipment dealers will let you take one home and test drive. Lacking that, I'd go for one with the widest distance between the tires, the widest tires possible (for more traction and less abuse to the grass), and the lowest center of gravity. I think these things are more important than the engine horsepower.

JKJ


img

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#5

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Brian Aust - Nevada, IA

>I compared the John Deere's at Lowes and at the Dealer, they are not the same tractor. Borg machines use cheaper engines and other components to keep the price down. My dad has had 2 JD's in 20+ years with very little problems. I just couldn't afford one at the time I needed one so I bought a Troy-bilt, have had numerous problems, one of which was pulling the engine to change the drive belt because the pulley was corroded onto the shaft. I've had to replace other various parts in 5 years. I'll get a JD next time!

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#6

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Honda makes some well built lawn tractors. I have a 14HP with a two cylinder water cooled engine. Yes, it has a radiator. It sounds like a little car engine. I have mulching blades on it. It works so well, there is no sign of any cut grass or weeds anywhere. No shifting, just push a lever forward and back for speed. Only problem is, it's a bit on the pricey side.

Good luck

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#7

Hey, Jim

Johanna

>Do you have a snowplow blade for yours? I have tried using my front-end loader bucket for a snowplow, but since it is perpendicular to the tractor, it is not very easy to use.

If yours is actually a snowplow blade, did you get it from John Deere?

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#8

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Sonny Asburry

>I bought a 42" cut Troy Bilt Pony from Lowe's (it will be 3 years next month), and bought the 3 year extended warranty ($120.00). I was mowing my daughter's yard 2 years ago and the "peg" or whatever you call it that keeps the drive belt from coming off the engine pully came loose and broke the belt.

We loaded the lawn mower onto my truck and I brought it home, left it on the truck and called the home office of Lowes. They gave me the nearest dealer that did warranty work which was 30 miles away.

I decided since I already had it on the truck and since I'm retired, that I would just drive there and maybe could get it repaired faster.

They told me that they would have to check to see what needed to be repaired, call Lowes and get approval.

He called back and told me that none of this was covered under the warranty.

Now get this: If he had picked it up at my house he would have charged me $75.00, plus the cost of repair, then $75.00 to return it to me.

When I told this to the salesman what had happened, he was surprised that none of it was covered.

Beware of the warranty and what you are told about the warranty.

(It's a good mower, but this kind of put a sour taste in my mouth!

Sonny

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#9

Watch your rear end...literally!

Joe Pack

>First of all, check who makes what. I think (may be wrong, but don't think so) that at least some Cub Cadet and Troy-Bilt l/g tractors are made by MTD. Not that that is bad, because there are differences in quality of components, but don't buy based on name alone.

For my purposes (about 1/2 acre, suburban lawn, too lazy to walk), I narrowed my search down to a 46" cut, low end Cub Cadet and the equivelent John Deere. Either way, I would have purchased from a dealer instead of the big boxes for exactly the reasons mentioned earlier - service and parts. The prices were within a few dollars of each other, dealer or box store. The dealer who carried both brands called me by name the second time I came in. HD and Lowe's had to find somebody to answer my questions.

The point of my post, though, is the deciding point (no pun intended) that caused me to go with the Cub Cadet over the John Deere...the mowing height control lever on the John Deere stabbed me in the butt every time I tried to get onto the seat! I have short legs in the first place. In the second place, the height adjustment on the Deere models I could afford was mounted on the same side as the "enter here" side of the mower. When I tried to get on or off the mower on the proper side, I had to either do a gigantic stretch to get on, or stand up all the way to get off (hard with a big belly and bad knees). I could not simply slide onto the seat without risking singing soprano for a couple of days.

A little thing, I know, but the single largest factor that me go with white and yellow over green...I don't like being green!

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#10

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I have an MTD from HD. It's the worst piece of power equipment I've ever had. The deck metal is so thin the blade guard mounts warped it and would break 3-4 belts a summer at $35 each. Bought it 7 years ago and the deck is rusted out.

Talking to the mower repair guy (I'm getting to know him real well) he told me that most of the lower end tractors are now made by MTD. I'll probably have to replace this one this year and will go with a Deer. I'd like to get one with PTO for post holes and stuf but it would run $9K minimum.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#11

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Jim Runchey

>I bought a John Deere 345 about 10 years ago with a 54" deck, and have been very satisfied, no problems at all. It's all hydraulic with power steering, really a great machine.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Hey, Jim

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Yeah, mine is an actual JD Snow Blade. Shifts about 30� left/right as well as straight on. The shift is done by manually hauling on a lever (which also raises & lowers the blade), but since it's just a 46" blade, it's not hard to move it.

As for installation, I leave the brackets (frame mounted) on the tractor all the time, so installing the actual blade is just two clevis pins. Takes about two minutes to do.

For snow plowing with the small tractors you definitely need tire chains, and either a fat guy like me in the seat or else some auxiliary weight on the draw bar.

The blade wasn't too expensive. About $125, as I recall. That was three years ago, so it's probably more than that now.

Jim D.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#13

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Watch your rear end...literally!

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>That deck lever on the Deere would be my biggest complaint , too. It really is (was) my biggest dislike, until I decided to remove it, heat the middle of it a nice cherry red, and then bend it about 75� to the rear. Now it's out of the way of my butt, and still allows enough leverage to easily move the deck up and down.

Jim D.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#14

Odd man out

Andy Halterman: Bulbs comin' up

>I have an MTD that I bought used about 7 yrs ago. I paid $400 for this thing. It sill runs fine, cuts good and it has paid for it self about 5 times over. I cut the rental property across the street for $25 a pop. I also cut a 90+ year old ladies (she's the aunt of the guy who owns the rental house) 2+ acres sometimes for $50 a pop. This little tractor has made me lots of grocery money over the years. I've had to fix a few things on it but overall, I have no cause for complaint. Oh, all these lawns are pretty flat. I wouldn't use this thing on a steep slope. Way to narrow of a footprint.

YMMV.

Andy Halterman

Thankful that work is back in force in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#15

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Ron Hildreth

>JL,

I, myself, have never owned a lawn tractor or even a riding lawn mower, but have for years mowed my father's yard with his, mowing a large acreage in the country, and now a full lot here in town. Dad always insisted on a lawn tractor with nothing less than a 10 horse engine and a 40-42" cut path. This always worked great on the acreage where we were mowing about three and a half acres, but it's really overkill here in town. In fact, trade-in this spring for a smaller rider is in the works. One thing to consider is gas or diesel. You'll get better power with the diesel, and longer run time per tank fill-up, but a higher cost per gallon, as diesel fuel is a lot higher than gas. Are you going to use it for other things besides mowing?

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#16

Re: OT - Lawn tractor -- Pressurized Oil System

Binen

>Regardless of what type of tractor you choose be sure it has a pressurized oil system. The splash oilier type does not work well when used on slopes.

Binen

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#17

Very long diatribe and advice

Grant Smith

>JL,

One of my non-woodworking hobbies has been lawn and garden machinery. First off, lets work on some definitions:

Lawn Tractor= lightly built machine made only to mow and tow a light cart. Heavier versions can move light snow with a blade attachment, though blade lift is usually manual. Expect an 8-10 year lifespan from the drivetrain and chassis. The chassis of these is usually shaped sheet metal, and will fatigue after several years. The fancy engine they use as a selling point will likely be going strong when the sheet metal is fatiguing and failing.

Garden Tractor= Heavier built machine made to mow, till, move snow and dirt, and accept many useful attachments. Often can be equipped with hydraulic implement lift and power steering. Much more reliable and usually more comfortable to use. Expect better brands of these to last indefinately with proper maintenance. These units usually have heavier duty rear ends, and a steel frame.

I have been mowing about 2/3 of an acre for about 7 years, and have now moved to a house on an acre lot. We have about 4500 square feet of concrete drive and apron to move snow off of in the winter. My wife and I enjoy gardening and yard projects. I am somewhat anal about my lawn...

If you think you have snow to move from a large drive, or would like a garden, or just want the reliability and quality of a heavier duty machine, go for a garden tractor. If all you want to do is mow, and tow a light cart, then I suggest a light commercial grade zero turn machine. These can tow a cart, dethatcher, etc. and will mow circles around the best lawn tractors. Also, if you have lots of trees or obstructions, a zero turn machine is more efficient.

As far as brands go, I suggest you look at the machinery on the local pro lawn care guys trailers. Also important is which brands the closest dealer carries. You want to be able to stop on the way home from work to pick up a belt or blade or that lost clip.

I also suggest with an acre yard, you avoid the big box stores and go to the real dealers. Come june, when the dealership has 120 machines in for repairs, you want to be in the "I bought it here" category, and not in the "big box we'll get to it when we can" category.

As I said, I prefer the garden tractor class of machine. I bought an old 1977 Wheel Horse C-160 with a tiller, dozer blade, cart, mower deck, and snow blower for $1200 back ten years ago. They built them to last forever back then. To be sure, it needs regular maintenance, and I have cursed a few design flaws, but since the only plastic on the machine is the dash panel, I have always been able to repair whatever fails. The machine is a pleasure to use, it does what you expect and much more. If you like cast iron, old garden tractors are the way to go.

So, to summarize, consider what you might want to do with the machine and buy accordingly. Don't be afraid to look at the used inventory at local dealerships or in the local classifieds.

I'd go lawn tractor if you:

-just need to mow and maybe tow a cart and have a wide open lawn. Don't expect to be able to move over a 4" snow fall effectively with one of these...maybe go walk behind snowblower.

I'd go zero turn if you:

-want speed, turning ability, and have a fairly level lawn. Little or now snow removal ability...go walk behind snowblower.

I'd go garden tractor if you:

-want do it all capability, sturdy construction, ground engaging capability, and unlimited snow removal capability.

A note on snow removal: A snowblown driveway doesn't drift back in nearly as bad as a plowed drive. Suggest a walkbehind snowblower over a tractor mounted blade.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#18

JL

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

JL

>I suppose I could put a small scraper blade on the front to plow the street on the rare occasions when it snows - but the snow usually doesn't amount to much. The lot we bought is right next to our house and I do have a wheelbarrow, so I wasn't planning on hauling things.

I usually rent a rototiller when needed. I don't know what attachments I should even consider.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#19

JL

Re: Thanks all! *LINK*

JL

>We have a local dealer, with a reputable service department - so I'll head over there. They carry a variety of products and are a John Deere Dealer.


Nelson Tractor

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#20

Simply get a Simplicity

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We wore out our Crafts man after nearly 20 years and two decks. After looking at the various MTD clone machines and John Deere, we decided to get a Simplicity. We mow just over an acre and LOML loves the machine

. She wouldn't approve the purchase until she test drove one at the local dealer. One ride and she was sold. It cuts very even and rolls the lawn at the same time so you can get the stripe effect you often see on the professional baseball fields. They have various sizes and price ranges to suit your needs. Ours is a Regent and cost just under $1900. They currently have 12 months same as cash and a 2 year warranty that actually works. (No I don't get a commission, just a very satisfied owner) Ours has hydrostatic drive and an electric clutch for the mower deck. You can slip the deck out in less than a minute it takes about 2 minutes to put it back in place.

Best of all they are made in the USA and well built. Good solid metal frame. The gas level is easy to see in the tank.

Lee


img

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#21

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Paul Blackwell

>I've had an 18 hp Cub Cadet for twenty years now, has a 50" mower deck and a 48" snow blower. Both are great units. I mow almost three acres, and other than replacing blades and belts, have had no problems. Part of the lawn is on an incline, and the tractor is very stable. The snow blower is very efficient. It will blow almost any snow, even wet heavy stuff. If it isn't pure slush, it won't clog.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#22

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>The little trailers come in pretty handy. Last Spring, I had eighteen yards of mulch delivered, and used the heck out of the trailer for moving it around. The trailer holds about four wheelbarrows full, and it dumps, sot it was a real labor saver when some of the trees and beds were a couple hundred feet away from where the mulch was dumped.

Jim D.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#23

Re: Simply get a Simplicity

John K Jordan

>I can vouch for Simplicity in general. I've had one of their walk-behind brush mowers for a few years (it's like the DR Mower but much heavier duty) and that thing is built like a tank, quality throughout, nice attention to detail.

JKJ

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#24

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

Ray, SW OHIO

>I have a Troy-Bilt GARDEN tractor for the past 3 years. Have a little over a 1/2 acre. Bought a snow plow for it and have plowed my drive and 5 of my neighbors drives with it (no charge of course). It has 21 hp B&S engine with cruise. Haven't had any trouble with it. If was to buy another one, it would be a JD.

Re: OT - Lawn tractor ?

#25

JL

Re: There is a dealer, I'll give them a look.

JL

>