Very long diatribe and advice
Grant Smith
>JL,
One of my non-woodworking hobbies has been lawn and garden machinery. First off, lets work on some definitions:
Lawn Tractor= lightly built machine made only to mow and tow a light cart. Heavier versions can move light snow with a blade attachment, though blade lift is usually manual. Expect an 8-10 year lifespan from the drivetrain and chassis. The chassis of these is usually shaped sheet metal, and will fatigue after several years. The fancy engine they use as a selling point will likely be going strong when the sheet metal is fatiguing and failing.
Garden Tractor= Heavier built machine made to mow, till, move snow and dirt, and accept many useful attachments. Often can be equipped with hydraulic implement lift and power steering. Much more reliable and usually more comfortable to use. Expect better brands of these to last indefinately with proper maintenance. These units usually have heavier duty rear ends, and a steel frame.
I have been mowing about 2/3 of an acre for about 7 years, and have now moved to a house on an acre lot. We have about 4500 square feet of concrete drive and apron to move snow off of in the winter. My wife and I enjoy gardening and yard projects. I am somewhat anal about my lawn...
If you think you have snow to move from a large drive, or would like a garden, or just want the reliability and quality of a heavier duty machine, go for a garden tractor. If all you want to do is mow, and tow a light cart, then I suggest a light commercial grade zero turn machine. These can tow a cart, dethatcher, etc. and will mow circles around the best lawn tractors. Also, if you have lots of trees or obstructions, a zero turn machine is more efficient.
As far as brands go, I suggest you look at the machinery on the local pro lawn care guys trailers. Also important is which brands the closest dealer carries. You want to be able to stop on the way home from work to pick up a belt or blade or that lost clip.
I also suggest with an acre yard, you avoid the big box stores and go to the real dealers. Come june, when the dealership has 120 machines in for repairs, you want to be in the "I bought it here" category, and not in the "big box we'll get to it when we can" category.
As I said, I prefer the garden tractor class of machine. I bought an old 1977 Wheel Horse C-160 with a tiller, dozer blade, cart, mower deck, and snow blower for $1200 back ten years ago. They built them to last forever back then. To be sure, it needs regular maintenance, and I have cursed a few design flaws, but since the only plastic on the machine is the dash panel, I have always been able to repair whatever fails. The machine is a pleasure to use, it does what you expect and much more. If you like cast iron, old garden tractors are the way to go.
So, to summarize, consider what you might want to do with the machine and buy accordingly. Don't be afraid to look at the used inventory at local dealerships or in the local classifieds.
I'd go lawn tractor if you:
-just need to mow and maybe tow a cart and have a wide open lawn. Don't expect to be able to move over a 4" snow fall effectively with one of these...maybe go walk behind snowblower.
I'd go zero turn if you:
-want speed, turning ability, and have a fairly level lawn. Little or now snow removal ability...go walk behind snowblower.
I'd go garden tractor if you:
-want do it all capability, sturdy construction, ground engaging capability, and unlimited snow removal capability.
A note on snow removal: A snowblown driveway doesn't drift back in nearly as bad as a plowed drive. Suggest a walkbehind snowblower over a tractor mounted blade.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa