>I just had a big tree taken down which I am having milled on site. My tree cutter cautioned me about metal being in the tree and causing blue stain. I know the sawyer will wand for metal, but once removed, I thought it will either create character in the board, or I will have to cut it out once the boards are ready. I didn't think this would cause blue stain????? What do you think before I spend $1,000 on milling. Thanks for the help.
>I'm pretty sure blue stain is confined to pine and is more moisture related. Not an expert but we do a lot with oak and recycled oak and typically the metal causes a pocket of brown rust stain. We use bandmiills because blades are cheaper and can be changed ina moments notice. We typically use a metal detector.
I think you are not getting the most informed advice from this person.
There is blue stain which is caused by fungi which primarily is seen in softwoods and there is blue stain caused by metal in wood with high levels of tannic acid, like oak. Sometimes the stain is brown, sometimes it is blue, but my understanding is that it is always localized, just as you envisioned.
I'm surprised at how much the milling is going to cost. Last I had sawed cost me $200/thousand bd.ft. onsite.
>Gary is Right-ON, just some additional info. There is blue stain, at least that what I call it in oak, it's a drying defect of drying to slow, sapwood is a pale bluish-gray. The black-blueish stain from metal can be attractive if handled correctly in the designing process. I once had several iron chains used for holding some tin down that I was using as roofing material on top of some oak. The roof leaked due to my haphazard of laying the tin over the lumber, the iron water from the chains cause some staining, worked good for me. Made a negative a positive. As in any occupation there are several meanings that can be confusing, if your not educated on matters.
>....if there is metal in any oak tree, the area arond the metal recats with the tannins in the oak wood to create a bluish/ black staining of the wood. This can leach for several inches up to a foot or more. If you see this staining while milling, the sawyer can turn the cant and keep milling, but be advised, you may hit that metal at any given time, so its your call whether to proceed or scrap the cant.
Not sure how big or how many logs you have, but a grand for a coupla logs is NOT worth pursuing IMHO....unless you havbe money to burn that is! You can buy alotta kiln dried lumber for that amount.
>I have some thick walnut slabs with metal in them. This left a narrow dark purple streak leading away from the metal for a couple of feet. I hacked into them and dug out some pieces of a file.
But consider - the tree may not have any metal in it and if it does, it will probably be in one small area. Most metal is in the butt log from ground level to about 5 feet. If the tree was growing in a fence line, it has a good chance of having embedded barbed wire. If the tree was a yard tree near a house, it is more likely to have nails or clothesline hooks. However, I've sawed many logs from yards and I've never hit metal on my sawmill. (I did find one "treehouse" maple tree that had hundreds of nails pounded into the first 20' by two generation of boys! The inside was hollow and looked like an inverted porcupine.)
If the sawyer does find metal with a detector, he will probably not saw that part of the log unless you are willing to pay for the likely ruined blade (about $30) so you may not have any stained wood to deal with. BTW, most sawyers have a policy that lets you pay for ruined blades even if he does not detect any metal - metal-detecting wands will only penetrate a few inches into the wood, and embedded ceramic, glass and rocks can't be detected anyway. Some sawmills will not even saw a log if they know it came out of a yard.
>I milled some oak that had metal (hit it on the second cut). We stopped, changed blades, popped the metal out and kept on cutting. I had some blackish/brownish stain around the metal, but nothing too serious. The rest was fine.
Now, a $1000 to mill up a tree. Wow, that's outrageous. I had 11 8' logs milled for about $250. A guy closer to me with a mill is more expensive at $90/hr, and I don't think it takes more than 10 hours to mill a tree. When I did the 11 logs, we finished in about 4 hours.