Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Posts

Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#1

Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>I hate finishing so much I am about ready to quit this hobby of woodworking. I'm about ready to throw in the towel. For me, finishing just takes all the fun and enjoyment out of ww'ing.

Right before Christmas I completed a table and delivered it to the in laws. After seeing it there for a while, I hated it. Brought it home and last night and I cleaned all the wax off the top, sanded it, and started to apply poly to it. I am re-doing the top. I am not sure where I'm going with it but it looks like crap as it is. I had put poly on it, sanded, rubbed out, blah blah blah. Waxed it and rubbed it more. When the light hit it just right you cold see smudges and so on.

This is typical of all my projects; the finishing step(s) are a pain in the butt. I've tried all the "Best Finishing Technique Ever" articles that appear what seems like every month in the ww'ing mags.

I've even spent one-on-one time with Jeff Jewitt who's shop is a few miles from me.

The only thing technique I think I haven't tried is spraying and gelled poly.

The magazines make it look so simple and easy in 3 or 4 pages. They also always seem to be doing flat objects. I'd like to see them do one of these 'easy finishing technique' type articles on a real world object like a small cabinet with a door that has a raised panel and maybe a small drawer of some type. You know, one of those 'just wipe it on and rub it off' articles. I'd like them to explain how they make inside corners and so on look nice...

Sorry, I'm ranting. I leave now.

Joe

(who hates finishing in Cleveland!)

Maybe I'll go back to my camera and spend more time with wildlife photography...



Yes, there are Bald Eagles in Cleveland...

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#2

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Binen

>Oh wow, here all this time I thought I was the only one who loved woodworking and hated finishing. I admit when I near the end of a project I begin to dread its completion. Once done then I have to finish the project. I watch Norm or David Marks lovingly applying a finish and wonder how.

I have no idea why, I just hate the finishing step. I�m fair at applying most finishes and have never ruined a project with a finish. I just hate to finish and wish I could learn how not to.

Don

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#3

need more information

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The obvious observation is that you hate finishing because you have not been successful at it. If my finishes relied on brushing on urethane varnish I would hate it too. But then you talked about smudges and left me confused. What's smudged; the stain? If staining is the problem then that is very simply to solve.

Now that the rant is off, clearly describe one problem you would like to solve. If we get through one problem successfully we will move on to another.

Finishing takes time. I would like to hear from the professionals, but I'll bet finishing may be 1/3 the cost of a piece. If one isn't prepared to spend the time finishing, then success will not be achieved.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#4

Maybe...

Robert Englebrecht

>it is part of the woodworking process you need help with.

I apprenticed with a gunsmith and he was very meticulous on the sanding process BEFORE a drop of finish was applied.

He compared correct sanding was the foundation of all finishing. Sort of like building a house, poor foundation results in a poorly built building.

Something to think about.

Bob

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#5

Dichotomy

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I HATE to paint (walls & such) but I LIKE wood finishing.

Perhaps it has to do with perceived purpose. For me, finishing is the way I get to show off all my hard work and care in the planning and execution of the piece. When I'm secure in my crafting of the piece, the finishing seems to go much better.

BTW. While I have rubbed out hand-applied poly finishes with reasonable success, I NEVER use wax on them as it never fails to screw up the look. Wax attracts moisture and gets dull and cloudy in spots. Want a great look on poly? Use Meguire's (automotive) #2, #3, and #9 in that order with a power car buffer or RO sander fitted with buffing pads (change bonnets for each). You won't believe the depth you'll get. Then a very little bit of Guardsman polish, yes, but wax, never.

Also, if you're going to rub out any oil film finish, you'd best not be in a hurry to get done. Oil films will continue to shrink down and thin out on the surface for a month or two. What may look like glass when you're done, can look very different in 4 weeks. Of course, I wait several weeks or more to rub out a solvent finish like lacquer or shellac as well.

mm

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#6

Re: Maybe...

Steve Schoene

>Finishing doesn't have to be frustrating. You can develop one or two schedules that can take you a long way. As was mentioned preparation is important. Also important is to work out the problems on scrap not on the project itself.

But, if you tell us some more basic information we can put together a finishing program that will give you excellent results. It will help us to know what kind of wood you are using, and what kind of preparation before applying any finishing product you have done.

Also mention the specifics, brand and color, of any stain and what top coat materials also by brand. Also, how you have been applying the materials will help suggest any modifications if needed. And, above all tell us what look you are trying to achieve. Don't be afraid to give us lots of details.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#7

I am so lucky...

Terry Alexander

>I too absolutely hate finishing. I am pretty good at it, I just hate doing it. It takes time and I would rather use that time constructing instead of finishing.

But...why am I so lucky? Because my wife LOVES doing the finishing and she if very very good at it. So we work on projects together. In the construction phase she is a "hold this, hand me that" type of person. Once completed, she takes over.

However....she does do one thing that drives me nuts. Let's say I put a wood plug in to cover a screw hole. I cut it off as flush as I can so that it can be sanded smooth. She will take my ROS or my palm sander and turn the thing on edge and put tons of pressure on the sanding area and dang near sand a hole in that spot. URGhhhhhhhhhhhh.

But I still love her ;-)

Terry Alexander who hates finishing also.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#8

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Joe,

I admit that finishing is not my favorite passtime. However, I'd druther apply it than have to remove it. I generally fully enjoy designing and fabrication work, and when I get to the finishing stage, I realize that all the fun of the project is about to end. One thing though. I successful finish brings exclamations of admiration. I must admit to enjoying that part of it too.

George

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#9

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Ok. Thanks guys. I took a breath and took my shop off of the 'for sale' forum. :)

I've tried to answer questions and comments below.

------------

Bill Tindall

The obvious observation is that you hate finishing because you have not been successful at it.

In the past I have had success. It's just a real pita getting there I guess. Maybe that is why I hate finsihing; it's a pita.

Bill Tindall

If my finishes relied on brushing on urethane varnish I would hate it too.


Why is that Bill? After the varnish cures, don't you rub it out like any other finish?

Bill Tindall

But then you talked about smudges and left me confused. What's smudged; the stain? If staining is the problem then that is very simply to solve.


No. No Stain. I never use stain. It is the wax that smudges I believe.

This particular project was a small table for a kitchen - light use as well. It has a Walnut top. I applied multiple coats of Minwax gloss with a (Badger) brush. Each coat was tipped-off, allowed to cure a day or two, then lightly sanded/leveled with P400, wiped off, then another coat brushed on. I forget the number of coats. Maybe 5?

The last coat dried/cured for a few days (I know it continues to cure for a period of time and does not 'dry'). Then was sanded with P400. I may have used scotch-brite pads too, don't recall exactly. Then the last thing was to apply dark colored wax with 0000 Liberon steel wool. Applied the wax, allowed it to dry for 30 or so minutes, then struggled like a gorilla trying to so-called 'buff it off'.

The wax was a mistake. Why did I use it? I like the feel of it when first applied. I like the look as well. Why Minwax high gloss? It's pretty clear with no dulling additives. I know I will be rubbing it out to remove any nibs and so on and I'm not after high gloss.

For the base of this table (Cherry with turned legs and m/t construction and 2 drawers), I used shellac. Why mix Cherry with a Walnut top? That's what they wanted. I brushed on the shellac. Using a Badger brush. I was trying to be careful not to get runs and or drips but of course did.

-------------------

Robert Englebrecht

I apprenticed with a gunsmith and he was very meticulous on the sanding process BEFORE a drop of finish was applied.

I try to be careful and not take short cuts when sanding. This particular top was hand planed and scraped. I know finishing will/can magnify imperfections.

-------------

Steve Schoene

Don't be afraid to give us lots of details.

I just tried... :)

-------------------

Mark Mandell

Want a great look on poly? Use Meguire's (automotive) #2, #3, and #9 in that order with a power car buffer or RO sander fitted with buffing pads (change bonnets for each). You won't believe the depth you'll get. Then a very little bit of Guardsman polish, yes, but wax, never.

I've actually been thinking of trying that. I seem to recall reading something similar in FWW. Doesn't that work best with hard finishes though?

Oh, and what do you do about the edges of the table?

-----------

Terry Alexander

But...why am I so lucky? Because my wife LOVES doing the finishing and she if very very good at it.


Cheater. :D

--------------

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown

I realize that all the fun of the project is about to end. One thing though. I successful finish brings exclamations of admiration. I must admit to enjoying that part of it too.

Two good points George.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#10

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Steve Schoene

>Well the wax is easily dealt with. It can all be removed with mineral spirits or naptha and lots of paper towels.

Then I suspect that the rubbing out process can be continued to give a more even look. As was mentioned, the longer you wait the better the rubbing out process will be. Then, I would recommend carrying the sanding process a bit further. If you are going toward a satin look, you can still sand up to about 1000 grit (don't get carried away it doesn't take much), and then shift to something like pumice lubricated in paraffin oil on a felt pad to give an even satin. Others do like the fine steel wool, and rubbing compounds such as the Mequires. If the pores on walnut haven't been fully filled by this time, stay away from the pumice and rubbing compounds since they can edn up as grey spots as they lodge in pores.

For next time, when you need good protection on furniture try a tradional resin varnish such as Behlen Rockhard or Pratt & Lambert 38. These will dry a bit harder and consequently uniform rubbing out is a bit easier.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#11

Too Soft? You Judge

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Walnut. I waited 3 weeks to rub this piece out. Since then, the pores have reappeared and the film thinned, but only slightly. Top is made from 1/4" stick glued to 1/2" MDF. Finish is Minwax gloss poly with 15% naptha added and applied by hand.

Before you start "rubbing", wet sand to at least 800 or 1000 with a hard rubber block moving only in the direction of the grain. Carefull here, especially at the edges and corners, not to cut through the top layer and get witness lines.


img

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#12

Caveat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Naptha does wonders for helping oil poly to self-level when hand-applied. Care must be taken, however, to thin with not more than 15% naptha for horizontal surfaces, and not more than 5% to be applied vertically, and mix only what will actually be applied. Do not return naptha-thinned poly to the original can, as the entire can will be "jello" in about 2 weeks' time. The process was described to me as "auto-polymerization", but the chemistry is, along with lots of things, way beyond me.

mm

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#13

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Second Rockhard varnish, that stuff is a joy to sand out in comparison to poly varnish. I have a Cherry box that's finished with maybe three coats of Rockhard that kicks around with me to my dovetails and coloring classes, that never fails to draw compliments on its finish. :-)

It has become increasingly battered and scratched over the years. Some time I'll clean it off, scuff it a little, and put another coat or two on.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#14

I love finishing

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Finishing is where it all comes together. All the time spent with loving care making each piece just so, and now you get to apply the finish that really brings out the beauty of the wood. All it really has to do is protect the wood. I bet your family is proud of whatever projects you make for them, even if they dont' look like a plastic covering was applied at a science lab.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#15

Re: Smudged wax

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Joe,

I think the smudges are due to your waxing procedure. If I may (and this is my post, so I grant myself permission), below is a post from the late Sam Simpson on January 19, 2005 regarding waxing which I think may help you. The questioner was Carol (I've forgotten which Carol it was):

Q: Finally, gentlemen, if you'll bear with me... could you run down your application process for me? I'm laying on a bit of wax with a cloth, waiting a few minutes - like 5 or so - and then buffing it off. Wax on, wax off, like the karate kid waxing a bunch of cars. When I've taken a buffing pad to it, nothing much more seems to happen.

A: There are several different techniques that can be employed. And your choice might depend on the delicacy of the project. Lets go from soft to harsh. - A light application of wax, then buff lightly with a damp cloth. Remember about the flattening of fatty esters and the melting points. The damp cloth will give better control over heat generated by friction and allow you to tease the surface to a brilliant shine. (this is the method used when blacking army boots - or, spit shine) The point here is that when the esters warm up they go back to being round again. so you need to be aggressive with the surface without overheating it. - When buffing a floor you would mop on the wax as evenly as possible and then take a wooden box that has felt pads attached to the bottom, with a long broom handle on it and bricks inside the box for weight. And move it evenly over the floor for an even shine. - When waxing a very shiny object, like a piano, you need to choose a wax that has the ability to be spread very thinly over the surface. It should feal more like Vaseline than wax. (microcrystalines are appropriate, such as renaissance wax) apply with a soft cloth only and buff with a clean soft cloth. but most furniture will actually benefit from a more aggressive approach. 4/0 steel wool is often used as the applicator pad. (wax will lubricate the pad so that it is not as aggressive as it appears) the wax is applied with an attempt to modify the apperence of the surface. So more wax is used than in the other methods and the surface is rubbed hard. To get a good shine with this method it is best to use a stiff brush to flatten the esters. (like a shoe brush or curry brush) then after the wax has relaxed for a few minutes, buff again, this time using nylon stockings as the fabric. In cases where a rustic appearance is required on bear wood, and rustic carvings, the wax is applied using a paint brush and buffed off with a stiff bristle brush.

You may be too aggressive buffing the wax. You need to avoid heating the wax or smudges will result.

Al

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#16

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

Barry Irby

>I don't like finishing either. On one lucky note, I have a friend who is a professional cabinetmaker. Occasionally I take things to him and he finishes them for me. What a luxury! Somethings, I make two of them and give one to him in return for the finishing.

One thing that might help is to think of finishing in a different light. I tend to think of building the piece and than throwing on a little finish at the last minute and calling it good.

Some people say the finishing is actually about half the "work" in the piece, not just an afterthought. What I see is that Cutting the trees and turning them into lumber is about half the work. Taking the rough lumber and doing the stock prep is about half the work. Making the piece is about half the work and finishing it is the other half. There seems to be about twice as much work here as I thought there should be!

I find the topic of finishing overwhelming. Not only are there things like tung oil, waterlox, lacquer, shellac and on and on, but then there are endless combinations. (Not to mention Varnish and poly) I would like to narrow it down a bit. Develop a system of finishing that works for me. I think if you realize that the finishing is a bigger part of the process than many of us would like for it to be, take that into account as you build and prepare the piece for finishing and then find a fairly simple system of steps and products that works for you, you will be happier. I know I would.

My kids hate one of my "Dad" expressions. "You shouldn't leave until you know where you are going."

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#17

I agree with mark...

Craig in SIlverdale

>Painting sucks. However I love to apply a finish to a project. I have fun playing with dyes and stains. Getting the grain to pop or highlight another part of the piece is great. I sometimes start the finishing process before the whole thing is assembled. Guess, it's just different strokes for different folks.

Re: Speaking of finishing, I hate it.

#18

Re: Smudged wax

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks Al. Interesting.

I miss Sam's posts too.

Joe