Is it just me or does it appear......
Scott in Eastern Iowa
>.....it's kinda obvious a finishing forum is needed here?
Look at the last 15 threads.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Is it just me or does it appear......
Scott in Eastern Iowa
>.....it's kinda obvious a finishing forum is needed here?
Look at the last 15 threads.
But . . .
steve mackay
>I hope the questions / advise get posted here also. I'd get lost " makeing the rounds " of forums. Lucky if this old beast of a machine makes it through two ( messages and handtools ).
Open to suggestions
Ellis Walentine
>Traditionally, we've resisted variety because it tends to confuse people. But finishing is definitely an endeavor that stands apart from most other topic groupings. Lathe-specific finishing techniques are the exception, and those threads are likely to stay on the turning board.
I still prefer to keep general woodworking and finishing topics here, since they are of general interest to most of us.
Input is welcome.
Ellis
Re: Open to suggestions
Carlos Clarke
>You probably don't have this level of control over the software but would be nice if the software let us pick which forums we are interested in and then merge reading messages into one list with each message indicating the forum that it came from. Then you could have a separate finishing forum or an off topic forum(and end the every 6 month discussion on separating off topics) and just select the forums you are interested in. Posting a response would go back to the forum that the message you are replying to came from. Posting a new message would ask which forum you want to place the message in.
Big room or lotsa smaller rooms?
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>Guess it's what you prefer. When I go to a woodworking, car, motorcycle, or whatever, convention/show, I like to go into one huge building with everything in one place. Sure it's noisier, and sometimes more crowded, but I prefer that so I get the sense that I can see everything and will miss less. A show that is spread out in multiple buildings, or has a bunch of auxilary smaller rooms to house different specialities makes me feel like it's more work to see everything.
Guess it's personal preference and I can see how people like one way more than another. Guess it's the same with online forums too, in a way.
Happy Woodworking!
I kinda like things in one forum
Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA
>I think I'd probably miss some good posts if they were on another board. I guess if we got an inordinate number of posts about finishing them maybe it could have it's own room, but I don't know if small spike is enough.
I read/post on this board and handtools, and I think that's enough for me for now.
But, if we do start seeing an aweful lot of posts about finishing, then I could see making a new room. I don't think we're there yet, though.
Me too
Mike Farinella
>
Re: Is it just me or does it appear......
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>How one uses the forum is under one's control. The message subject line usually implies the subject. If it suggests finishing and that isn't your interest, don't click on it.
Clint
Re: Is it just me or does it appear......
Paul Leuba
>My personal preference is to keep the finishing topics on the same forum with the general woodworking topics. Every project requires finishing of some type.
Paul in Hunt Valley
How about sub-categories?
Craig Daymon
>When posting a message to a board, allow selection from a set of sub-categories. On the main board, Finishing, (Power)tool opinions (reviews), shops, etc. Maybe on the handtools board, planes, saws chisels? By default the boards would show all messages, but if you wanted a sub-category, you could select that, there by filtering out the bulk of the messages you are not interested in.
That way you can effectively create multiple, special interest, boards without having to maintain them separately or resulting in people posting to multiple boards.
Creating separate boards really is just a way to search/filter the messages without the user having to do anything. Sub-categories could be done in a way that results in maybe only one additional click and could allow the user to return to the full list again with a single click.
It also might be able to offer the option to filter those things the user might never want to read. Just as an example, I'm not a big scrollsaw fan and if scrollsaw topics were a sub-category, it might be as easy to let me see all the messages not pertaining to scrollsaws instead of those pertaining only to scrollsaws.
-Craig
Re: Open to suggestions
Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH
>Ellis,
I am with you. Too many places to look for info and people will get confused. I have used different recipes people have recommended for others when finishing some pieces I have done. Never would have thought to try something different if it hadn't been for that input even when I wasn't really looking for it.
Regards,
Bill
Me three!
Mike Schwing from Maryland
>
Me 4 or 5 I lost count
Dustmaker Mike
>
What number am I in favor of one forum?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>
KISS
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
>
Ditto
henthorn
>
I resemble that Tom ..... 8^ ) .....
Scott in Eastern Iowa
>
This was merely a quick observation Ellis.....
Scott in Eastern Iowa
>......I like this place as is.....though it seemed obvious at the moment that maybe a Fin forum was in order.
Re: Open to suggestions
ScottS
>I'd suggest keeping finishing questions in the main Messages forum. That said, there does seem to be a fair amount of duplication when it comes to finishing questions. Rather than a special message board, how about trying to collect some of the more useful discussions and turn them into Articles or something? Every time I go looking for info on the best non-blotching finish for cherry or the right way to use Waterlox, I always have a devil of a time tracking the information down. I know it's there, but I just can't find it. Some more links from the articles area might help with this problem.
Not that the finishing articles aren't good. In fact, they're almost too good! Many of them given in-depth information on why a particular technique works or how it compares to other techniques. Which, don't get me wrong, it great. But I have to admit to being lazy: usually when I have a question about finishing, I want the answer right NOW. I'd love to see a "cookbook" where each page began with a picture and then gave short, but detailed instructions for how to get the same look. Sanding schedule, finishing products used, type of applicator, number of coats, drying time and sanding between coats, etc. I think there's a lot of info that could be mined from various Shop Shots and re-purposed for this sort of thing.
I plead the fifth! Or, I'm the fifth to plead, uh
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>...whatever. I like 'em mixed in here. I don't think there's an overabundance of traffic on the main messages board to warrant splitting off the finishing topics.
Jason
T'would be nice
Ellis Walentine
>...but, as you supposed, that isn't an option unless we abandon our threaded boards and opt for one of the newer PHP boards like everyone else uses. So far, we've resisted that move, but nothing is forever.
Thanks for the interesting suggestion.
Ellis
I like this idea, Scott
Ellis Walentine
>The cookbook idea, with indexed recipes taken from memorable posts of the past ten years, would be a great idea. Duly noted. Thanks.
Ellis
My simple minded input,,,
DougJ in Crawfordsville, IN
>I like how this forum is easily navigated. I personally would rather not see an addition of a "finishing" forum. To take my simple minded attitude one step further, I would request the "looking for", "classifieds", and "auction" forums be combined all into a single forum.