Re: sounds like shellac then
Steve Schoene
>Poly is just polyurethane VARNISH just as much a varnish as alkyd varnish or phenolic varnish. (In fact, single part consumer grade poly is really a varnish with a alkyd resin modified with polyurethane. (2-part varnishes may be 100% polyurethane varnishes with the mixture of the two parts consumating the chemical reaction that creates the polyurethane But these are specialty products for marine, aviation and industrial use.) Tradional resin (alkyd or phenolic) varnishes tend to be more foregiving in applicaiton, adhering to a wider range of substrates without special preparation, are often a little clearer--noticable if films on the thicker end are built, and a bit harder to rub out to an even sheen. (The rubbing out challenge for poly is related to the superior abrasion resistance of poly. Rubbing out is, after all, an abrasive process. In use, poly and other varnishes are very similar, brusing consistency is the same, and all can be thinned for wiping, or mixed with oil for oil/varnish mixes. The number of coats needed are similar, though aesthetically, one might find a little thicker traditional resin film acceptable due to the lack of haze. (For example, marine brightwork calls for 6-8 coats of full stength brushed on varnish.)
Shellac can be applied in a wide range of thicknesses (pound cut is the measure of how much dry shellac is added to a gallon of alcohol--higher poundage is thicker) Shellac all melds together when applied rather than forming specific layers or "coats" How many applications you make is very heavily an aesthetic choice. Sanding between coats, which is needed on varnish that has cured overnight, isn't needed for shellac--except to remove defects. Shellac rubs out extremely well, and can be applied in a process where abrasive is part of the process, both filling grain and smoothing the finish at the same time as material is added (this is French polish, a high gloss, very deep looking shellac finish with no apparent thickness.
In short there are lots of ways to skin the cat.