Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Shellac on top of Poly?

Posts

Shellac on top of Poly?

#1

Shellac on top of Poly?

Cody Lewis in LV

>Yesterday I posted a question about shallac vs poly, and I really appreciate all the help and good advice provided.

So now I'm nearly finished with a project and I've applied a couple coats of poly, but I think I'd like to do a coat or two with shellac as well to prevent the odor issues of the poly. Can that be done? I would think it would work fine but don't know for sure.

Also, will the shellac actually keep the poly odor sealed in, or will the poly odor find a way out?

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#2

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

Steve Schoene

>Shellac is a good odor sealer, but can't be guaranteed to be 100% effective, I don't think.

Putting the harder finish (shellac) over the softer finish (polyurethane varnish) isn't a receipe for longevity, but there is usually excess of "durability" in all the the most extreme situations. I assume you are contemplating this for inside locations where wear and liquids won't be a problem.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#3

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

Cody Lewis in LV

>Yes, this piece will remain indoors at all times, which is why the odor needs to be low to none. It does have to withstand 2 kids though (and one on the way - so 3 soon).

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#4

odor issue over-fretted

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Somehow this issue of temporary finish odor was not a problem until relatively recently. It strikes me as undue fretting.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#5

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

Bill Howatt

>IMO, the odor will disappear when the poly is cured not just dry. This also makes me wonder about sealing up an uncured finish. Presumably, it will just take longer to cure but I am no finish chemistry wizard by any stretch of the imagination.

Bill

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#6

Re: odor issue over-fretted

jerry mayfield

>Unless its inside a closed cabinet or drawer its a short lived problem. If it is then it becomes major.

Regard

Jerry

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#7

Agree, Bill

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Cody,

I've learned that once the poly is cured, it really doesn't smell. Granted, my sence of smell is poor, but SWMBO's is sure keen enough.

I'd forget the shellac as an overcoat at this point. The poly will be all the protection you need.

George

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#8

How long to cure?

Cody Lewis in LV

>My experience has been that after a week or two, the smell is gone, so I'm guessing that's when it's completely cured. Does that make sense?

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#9

Up to you

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not Quite.

The smell is mostly the solvents evaporating. Drying-oil finishes "cure" through a chemical reaction called polymerization which can actually take months depending on conditions and the finish's formula. Putting shellac over your poly will just slow down this chemical process because it will cut off much of the oxygen the oil finish needs to cure and become stable and order free.

Let your piece sit open for a while and be patient.

Just don't store food in the drawer |;-}}

mm

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#10

Lee Grindinger

kinda/sorta

Lee Grindinger

>On surfaces that are exposed to free air I agree, in a month's time the odor is largely unnoticeable.

However, inside cabinets the odor can hang around for a year. Solvent based varnishes can taint socks, china and linens for years.

Lee

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#11

these young'uns!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I suspect there is a significant generation gap here. Odors that I cherished because I associated them with good things- turpentine, moth balls, varnish, freshly painted rooms- do not seem to be as appreciated now days. Once someone complained that a chest smelled like moth balls. Moth balls= skating, ice fishing, deer camp, sledding, snow men. For me the smell of varnish means a project nearly completed- pleasure receptors tingling. What has happened?!?

There is a chemical basis for residual odor in some kinds of varnish, beyond the temporary solvent odor. When certain oils in some kinds of varnish react with oxygen some organic acids can be generated and slowly escape from the finish. These are the same chemicals that give baking bread and cheese its DESIRABLE odor. However, when a molecule shows up in a chest of drawers some people find this event to be a problem. Some of these molecules showed up in my steel cut oatmeal this AM.

It is easy for someone that does not find these odors objectionable to be unsympathetic to these young'un's concerns.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#12

Shellac or Poly for cradle?

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>Any recommendation as to the best coating(s) for a cherry baby cradle? The cradle should be fully assembled this weekend and the child is expected some time in April.

Respectfully,

Dave

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#13

Re: Shellac or Poly for cradle?

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>Poly lasts forever, and doesn't repair easily.

Shellac is less durable, looks wonderful on cherry, repairs easily by wiping on new 'layers'*, and is non-toxic to humans.

I'd use shellac. And let it cure for a month before the baby gets there. YMMV.

Congratulations on the new arrival!

* shellac doesn't so much layer as meld in with previous coats...

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#14

Well now Bill....

Jesse Cloud

>I haven't been able to claim membership in the 'younger generation' for a few decades and I appreciate some of the old smells, but I stop short of wanting my underwear drawer to smell like cheese. ;^)

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#15

Shellac Do-over

Jesse Cloud

>Only do over I ever had came from a shellac finish. My sense of smell isn't what it used to be and I never thought twice about mixing my shellac in a old pickle jar (well washed and aired out). Well, after about a week, the customer called and said, you may think I'm crazy, but that cabinet smells like pickles. :^)

Ooops.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#16

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

Tony - Memphis

>One thing I would be concerned about is whether or not the poly is fully cured. It takes a long time. I finsh most all of my projects with a gel poly (Rockler) and I have never had any issues with odor. I don't finish my interior surfaces.

Tony

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#17

sounds like shellac then

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>If it were my child I would go with shellac then. Unfortunately, though, it's "my best friend's girl", actually wife. Just liked the song reference. He and I are building the cradle together. I'm the wood guy and he's the future father, for the first time. I'll be the proud 'uncle' and, of course, spoil the kid rotten with fun wood gadgets and stuff.

YMMV? Is this 'You Mean Minnesota is Victorious'? or You May Mean Varnish? 8-) I've really only ever used poly. I did use tongue oil on one cabinet. I really liked the results. Used three coats. Maybe needs more? How many coats of 'varnish' or shellac are suggested?

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#18

Re: Your Mileage May Vary

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#19

Re: sounds like shellac then

Steve Schoene

>Poly is just polyurethane VARNISH just as much a varnish as alkyd varnish or phenolic varnish. (In fact, single part consumer grade poly is really a varnish with a alkyd resin modified with polyurethane. (2-part varnishes may be 100% polyurethane varnishes with the mixture of the two parts consumating the chemical reaction that creates the polyurethane But these are specialty products for marine, aviation and industrial use.) Tradional resin (alkyd or phenolic) varnishes tend to be more foregiving in applicaiton, adhering to a wider range of substrates without special preparation, are often a little clearer--noticable if films on the thicker end are built, and a bit harder to rub out to an even sheen. (The rubbing out challenge for poly is related to the superior abrasion resistance of poly. Rubbing out is, after all, an abrasive process. In use, poly and other varnishes are very similar, brusing consistency is the same, and all can be thinned for wiping, or mixed with oil for oil/varnish mixes. The number of coats needed are similar, though aesthetically, one might find a little thicker traditional resin film acceptable due to the lack of haze. (For example, marine brightwork calls for 6-8 coats of full stength brushed on varnish.)

Shellac can be applied in a wide range of thicknesses (pound cut is the measure of how much dry shellac is added to a gallon of alcohol--higher poundage is thicker) Shellac all melds together when applied rather than forming specific layers or "coats" How many applications you make is very heavily an aesthetic choice. Sanding between coats, which is needed on varnish that has cured overnight, isn't needed for shellac--except to remove defects. Shellac rubs out extremely well, and can be applied in a process where abrasive is part of the process, both filling grain and smoothing the finish at the same time as material is added (this is French polish, a high gloss, very deep looking shellac finish with no apparent thickness.

In short there are lots of ways to skin the cat.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#20

Re: sounds like shellac then

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>Shellac really doesn't layer on. It sort of melts into the previous coat. I keep padding it on until it doesn't really dry quickly any more, maybe three passes over the project, then wait a day or two, and do that again. It gets a quick rubdown w/600 or 800 grit wet/dry, lubed with mineral spirits, if I want it to, then another padded coat. In a couple of days, or maybe a week, or when I get to it, I rub it gently with a good furniture wax and white synthetic steel wool/abrasive pad, to cut the gloss somewhat. Smells great, and kills the bright shine of 'brand new'.

I use shellac from Jeff Jewitt these days, but for this, a fresh can of Zinsser Sealcoat (dewaxed blonde) would work pretty well, and be available at most good paint or hardware stores. The waxy stuff would work, too, but should be thinned somewhat with denatured alcohol (20%).

It's really hard to screw up. That's one reason I like it so much.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#21

Re: Shellac Do-over

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>You're supposed to use a peanut butter jar...

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#22

shellac on tenons? collapsible cradle

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>Thanks Steve, You talk my language buddy. You got my foot taping in excitement as I read your msg. Yesterday I read the history of shellac and how it's made from bug resin. Found the very fascinating article by exploring more of the WC site. What a wealth of knowledge we have here.

This cradle I'm making is collapsible and can be stored in an optional carrying case. Henceforth the sides have tenons which protrude through the ends and are held in place by pins. Should I be concerned about the finish wearing off the tenons as they are inserted through the mortises? Granted this will not be happening frequently, but it could (should?) possibly be a factor in my finish selection.

I like the idea of being able to touch up the shellac and having it meld into the previous 'layer', which I understand isn't really a layer. I feel like I need to spend more time with my hands in the finish than on this keyboard.

Thanks for sharing all the great info. Time to use some of it.

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#23

Re: Pins

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>We are sure to have the pegs well out of reach of the inhabitant, right? True, any cradle will be outgrown in rather short order, but the hand-to-mouth reflex comes out early-on so there's no use to a potential choking hazzard in the vacinity.

mm

Re: Shellac on top of Poly?

#24

cradle inhabitant

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>Thanks Mark,

I am guessing that by the time this newborn critter can climb around to where the pegs are, that (s)he will have been promoted to crib occupancy. You sound experienced with newborns. I hope to be some day also.

DWD