>Here I come with another rookie question: If I'm doing a project that has hidden places (like inside a bed-side table where the drawer slides in and out) should I apply polyurethane finish to those areas? I didn't stain those areas because there was no need - they'll never be seen - but I'm wondering if the finish coat is good because it seals things off and perhaps minimizes swelling/flexing over time???
>A good sealer coat doesn't hurt - and it keeps down "dust collection" and soiling. A nice spray or wipe-on lacquer coat is what I have used rather than poly.
Not a rookie question at all. To me, it depends how much "extra" work you want to put in. Once assembled, the insides are often difficult to get to, difficult to apply an even coat of whatever, and difficult to wipe up any excess finish if necessary. Nevertheless, a wipe-on coat of 1# pale shellac or wipe-on poly is easy to apply and will protect the interior and give it a more finished look IMHO, even if it will be only you who will know. My 2 cents.
>I've had several people tell me they prefer shellac to poly. Since I've always used poly, I gravitate to it, but I'd be curious to know why so many prefer shellac.
When an oil base finish is applied to an enclosed area like the inside of a chest, it emits a foul odor for a long time (years). Anything stored in the space absorbs the foul odor.
If you intend to finish the inside of your project, use something that is not oil-based to avoid the odor problem. Shellac is a good choice. Solvent or water base lacquer is good. Haven't heard anything about water-base poly for enclosed spaces but I'd avoid it until a definitive answer emerges.
>Personally, I don't think you need to finish the inside of a carcase. Historically, I suspect the majority of case pieces were left unfinished inside. The shrink/swell/movement factor is not likely to be an issue on a small piece like a bedside table, whereas it might be if this were a large case piece with solid wood sides.
If you do decide to put a light finish in there, use something that won't keep outgassing rancid oil smells forever. Shellac is the most time-honored alternative, but lacquer and waterborne coatings are also relatively odor-free after they have fully cured. And, regardless of whether you finish the inside, I'd finish the underside of the top before assembly to keep the moisture transfer rate similar on both sides. This will reduce the tendency to cup with changes in relative humidity.