Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Another drawer question

Posts

Another drawer question

#1

Another drawer question

John Pappas

>I will soon be making a couple drawers for a console table. The bottoms will be solid wood, tapered at the edges to fit into 1/4 inch grooves in the drawer sides.

My question is about orienting the grain. Would you run the grain front-to-back, leaving room in the drawer sides for expansion/contraction, or would you run the grain from side-to-side and secure the bottom such that it can expand and contract toward the back of the drawer?

Is there a traditional way of doing this?

Always appreciate the local wisdom.

Re: Another drawer question

#2

Re: Another drawer question

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon John,

I don't believe I ever have made drawer bottoms from solid wood because of the movement expected. I use plywood. The face grain parallels the drawer sides, my preference:--for looks. If I were to use solid wood, I would run the grain of the bottoms parallel to the front and back of the drawer. Expansion/wood movement of the bottom would not tend to blow out the dados in the drawer sides. I would make the drawer back a bit shallow to end at the top side of the dado in the adjacent drawer sides. The bottom rear of the drawer would be nailed to the bottom edge of the drawer back, and the bottom would float in the side and front dados. That should cope with wood movement.

George

Re: Another drawer question

#3

Re: Another drawer question

Ron Knapp

>I believe in the very early days (William and Mary) the grain was run front to back. Later it was changed so the grain runs parallel to the front. Put a slot in the back where you screw the bottom in to allow for movement. You shouldn't use any glue as the fit should be tight emough and the screw will keep the bottom in place. In a hundred years or so when the have to replace the drawer bottom they will thank you

Re: Another drawer question

#4

Re: Slightly different approach

Dave Mount

>This is no different from a frame and panel door, so you could orient the grain parallel to the drawer sides as long as you left enough residual depth in the grooves in the sides to accommodate expansion. Using rabbets or a panel raiser that forms a flat tongue will discourage the bottom from wedging into the sides and potentially splitting the bottom shoulder of the groove off.

However, I run the grain the other way, parallel to the drawer front. This sometimes makes for a greater length of cross grain movement (since many drawers are deeper front to back than they are wide), but you account for expansion by changing the way the drawer is put together. The drawer back is cut so that only comes down to the upper surface of the drawer bottom, and the bottom is left long so it sticks under the drawer back. The drawer bottom is not attached at the sides or back, but is glued or tacked to the front of the drawer so it is held in place at the front and can't slide out. Expansion of the drawer bottom just runs out under the drawer back and doesn't hurt anything, no matter how much it expands. If it were to expand so far as to protrude inconveniently behind the drawer, just plane it off.

Easy, it works, and there's no chance of splitting anything.

Dave

Re: Another drawer question

#5

how to make drawers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>see Jeffrey Green, American Furniture of 18th Century for a nice discussion of how successful drawers were made. Several examples are shown. Pick one that suits you. Personally I have become smitten with the English style with it thin sides and sturdy bearing surface.

Successful drawers are made to allow the bottom to expand out the back of the drawer. This arrangement also enables the bottom to be removed for drawer side repair as needed 200 years from now.

Re: Another drawer question

#6

Re: Another drawer question

Jim Dillon

>John,

I've made several small drawers with solid wood bottoms and ran the gain parallel to the front and back. While not absolutely necessary, I also used drawer slips to reinforce the inside bottom edge of the sides (and to provide a larger bearing surface) and to provide a decorative cover on the top inside edge of the bottom. I fastened the bottom with a brass screw in an elongated hole in the bottom at the rear. I also set the back panel in a few inches to prevent the drawer from tipping upon opening. If you use this approach, your back panel must be slightly narrower than the sides to accommodate the bottom and allow the screw to be screwed into the back. Hope this helps and isn't too confusing.

Jim

Re: Another drawer question

#7

Here is what I was...

Jim Dillon

>... trying to say. This pic shows one-piece drawer slips (and grain orientation), but you could also use two-piece slips if you already have your grooves cut.

Jim


img

Re: Another drawer question

#8

One more thing...

Jim Dillon

>... and that is if you really would like to orient the grain parallel to the sides, then use of the drawer slip approach would allow this without compromising the strength of the drawer sides. Just be sure to allow enough room in the slip-groove for expansion of your drawer bottom. And to prevent any vibration, especially if the goove is made accidently too large, some sort of rubber "space-ball" material might help.

Jim

Re: Another drawer question

#9

Thanks for all the good information.

John Pappas

>

Re: Another drawer question

#10

one more one more thing

Mark Rakestraw

>I do my drawers so the bottoms can expand out the back as described by several others. One thing that can happen is that when the bottom contracts it can pull the front edge out of the dado instead of sliding under the rear fastener. Just a spot of glue in the center of the front dado, regular or hot melt, keep the front edge anchored enough that your expansion and contraction remains at the rear of the drawer. Just use a dab and you'll still be able to remove the bottom in the unlikely event you ever need to replace the bottom.

Mark

Re: Another drawer question

#11

Ellis Walentine

Yet another thing

Ellis Walentine

>Ditto the advice to run the grain parallel to the front, John, so it expands out the back. But, I think I would reconsider the plan to put tapered tongues on the bottom. This is certainly historically accurate, but IMO, it leads to two problems. One is that the fit becomes critical if you hope to avoid a rattle between tongue and groove, especially if you orient the grain front to back. The other is that a taper contacts the drawer side only at the surface of the side. This concentrates any load in the drawer on that sharp outer lower edge of the groove. A square, tight fitting tongue will distribute the force all the way to the end of the tongue (hence, all the way to the bottom of the groove) where the groove meets the drawer. It may never be a problem, but it is a distinct engineering consideration, especially if the groove is close to the bottom of the side or if you're using this drawer to house your ball-bearing collection or your barbells -- less so if there is a significant amount of material under it to mitigate the chance of breaking.

Nit picky stuff, to be sure, but I usually try to go for every engineering advantage I can get.

Cheers,

Ellis