Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Posts

Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#1

Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....Ok, you've got a 40" wide panel to build, using (4) 10" wide pieces that need glue in between to make the top.

How do YOU do it?

Ive seen 2 schools of thought on this.....Is there a right or wrong?

#1 - pour the glue on one side of each board, but not its mate, then lay the pieces together in the clamp setup and tighten. No spreading of the glue at all.

#2 - pour the glue on both sides of each board, spread the glue out with an acid brush, roller spreader or plastic credit like card (whatever your preference is), lay the pieces together in the clamp setup and tighten.

FWIW, I use # 2.....I just have seen # 1 done alot here lately and was curious if this a moot point or is there any debate?

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#2

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Scott,

My personal preference is to evenly coat with an acid brush, a thin and even coat of glue over both edges, and clamp at moderate pressure. I tighten the clamps so there is squeeze out, and not much more. I generally begin at one end, keeping register in mind, and insuring the boards are kept flush to one another as I add clamps, working towards the other end. AQdd cawls as necessary to maintain the flatness. For a 40" wide panel, I would glue up two sub-assemblies and glue those up together once they were dried. I also wipe with a moist towel once the clamps are applied and the glue is squeezed out.

George

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#3

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

paul in AZ

>FWIW I use #2. I think it was Taag Frid who used to say that the best glue spreader is the index finger. I don't think it matters what you use to evenly spread the glue.

Whichever you use, the wet rag on squeese out is key to preventing discoloration and finish problems later.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#4

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Steve Schoene

>Spreading on both surfaces is insurance that nothing is missed, and worth doing. In practical terms, you can't put too much pressure on the joints with your clamps pretty much short of an hydraulic clamping mechanism. While moderate pressure works OK, increasing the pressure actually makes the joint stronger.

But the most important thing is to be sure that the joint is well fitted. If you can see light between the two boards stacked on edge and held together with light hand pressure, you have more work to do.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#5

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Barry Irby

>I have done both.

First, let me say that neither is a substitute for preparation. Stock prep and preparation in general.

Get you stock ready and lay it up dry. Look at the joints and the grain. The joints must fit nicely with nearly 100% surface contact in the joint, without clamp pressure. Also arrange the pieces in an attractive pattern taking into account the grain and color, Etc. Mark them so that you can keep them in the proper arrangement. Chalk is great for this.

The other type of preparation is to have your clamps setup and adjusted to the correct size. Have the glue ready and have plenty of it. Make sure you have room to work.

I agree with the Colonel. On large pieces, I often glue them up in stages. My planer is only twelve inches wide, but my Performax is a 16/32 so I might sand each half.

I sometimes use a few biscuits to help keep the surfaces lined up, but fairly often I don't bother to glue them, they add very little to the strength of a long grain joint.

If you glue up in stages, check the fit of the middle joint before applying the glue. Sometimes the fit is different after you glue up the subpanels.

The important thing about the spreading of the glue is that it be enough to wet both surfaces thoroughly. So wetting both pieces with glue is a good idea. But, if you glue one side only, apply plenty of glue and then rub the pieces back and forth to get the other piece wet.

On the subject of cleaning up the glue, be careful with that wet rag. You must be thorough. I find that I often smear the glue around and make it more difficult to clean it up once it is dry. My approach is to let it dry for a while until it reached the leathery stage and the lift it off with an old chisel. Once the clamps are off, I use a card scraper. Joints that are hard to clean later, like inside corners, I try to tape off with the blue tape. I find it is good to remove that before the glue fully cures or you will end up with the edges of the tape glued to the work. If you are using steel clamps, keep them out of the glue. They may leave black stains. Tape, waxed paper, plastic bags, most anything will do.

I have wondered about the glow in the dark glue or the additive you can get that makes it glow. Best use I ever heard of for a black light.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#6

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Jesse Cloud

>Hey Scott,

I take classes in Fine Woodworking at a local college and see lots of highly skilled woodworkers. They all swear by #2, but many practice #1 or some variation of it, especially when you have several pieces in a glueup.

Another item not yet mentioned is to ensure that your clamps are aligned carefully. The pressure points (screw on one side, head on the other) should be at the same height. If not the clamping pressure will induce twisting pressure on the workpiece. Cauls are good. Many use blocks between the pipe clamps and the workpiece to force the workpiece down to ensure alignment.

Bottom line is that each woodworker does it a little differently and they all produce great work!

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#7

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

McKay

>If you are working in a hot and dry climate, gluing both surfaces is not possible. You have to spread the glue very quickly and be done with it. As long as the glue is coating one surface completely, the second surface need not be glued. Sliding the two surfaces together will certainly work, and is absolutely necessary when using hide glue. Here at the school, we glue approximately 200 bd. ft. of lumber a day and have not had much problem as long as the joints are prepared properly. That said, I make sure that the annular rings are cut to never be wider than 3" in flat sawn lumber. Quarter sawn or rift sawn lumber can be left wider. 10" flat sawn will cup.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: #2

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#9

Re: #1 plus

les winter

>I spread glue on one face, lay the two boards together, rub them back and forth and up and down, seperate them, check for even coat both faces, and then together again, a quick rub and clamp. With well fitting surfaces, this rub joint grabs very very quickly, so alignment needs to be done immediately.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#10

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Bob Lang

>I think method #2 is one of those things that some well meaning fool published 25 or 30 years ago, and has been repeated enough that it is now taken as good practice. I can't think of any advantage to method #2, but several disadvantages immediately come to mind.

If the edges are straight and square (which they need to be to get a good joint)what purpose does spreading the glue on the second edge serve? The bead of glue that comes from a typical yellow glue bottle, placed down the middle of edge #1 is all the glue you need, assuming you have two boards 3/4" to 1" thick. When you put the boards together and either rub or clamp them two things happen:

1) the glue is spread evenly covering the entire edge of #1 and

2) edge #2 is evenly coated at the same time

Think about it. Glue is a sticky liquid. I doesn't have anywhere to go except out to the edges. The two edges are being forced together with the glue in between. How could the second, non-glued edge not be thoroughly covered?

With method #2 you are:

1) wasting time

2) wasting glue

3) more than likely making a bigger squeeze-out mess to be cleaned up

4) putting your work up against the limits of the glue's open time.

In the example from the original poster, I would place 3 of the boards on edge, run a bead of glue along all three edges and flip the boards down on some narrow boards placed across the bench. Clamp them together, scrape off any squeeze out and walk away.

Try it and see for yourself. Prepare two edges, run a bead of glue on one edge and bring the boards together. Rub back and forth the long way once or twice and then take the two apart. You will see a thin even coat across both surfaces. That's the goal-why work harder than you need to and complicate one of the simplest things in woodworking?

my $.02

Bob Lang

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#11

It doesn't matter...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The joint won't fail with either approach; they're both overkill. I just run a thin bead down one edge and clamp 'em together. The pressure spreads the glue and there's not much squeezeout. I've never had a joint come apart. Whether or not they're worth anything, I also use biscuits.

Clint

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#12

my technique

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. For the exact task you described I would be gluing up one piece at a time. I can usually get one joint in perfect alignment, never 3 at a time. I have stiff bar clamps so I never use cauls. I do occasionally add a clamp or two to the top as well as the supporting clamps underneath, especially if the piece is long enough to require several clamps.

2. I apply (not pour) glue to one edge and then rub this edge on its mating edge and look to see that I got near 100% transfer. Glue must wet both surfaces and this operation ensures proper wetting. When both edges are wet with glue I set the clamps. You will never exceed the maximum recommended clamping pressure (300 psi) with hand tightened clamps so ignore the myth about over tightening and "starving" the joint.

The problem with diddling with the glue application (brushing and the like) is that the glue begins to dry quickly at low humidity. When it begins to dry 1. it does not wet mating srufaces as well and 2. excess doesn't squeeze out as well.

For big surfaces I make a spreader. It can be closely spaced band sawed grooves in a thin piece of wood or closely spaced vee grooves filed in the edge of a "credit" card (preferably wife's). Old hotel room "keys" work great.

And if you had never done edge gluing before I would not be practicing on this expensive wood. Glue up some 2 x4 's or whatever for practice.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#13

removing squeeze out

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I let it drip out the bottom and squeeze out the top. when it is mostly dry scrape it off with a putty knife. Or usually I don't get back to do the scrapping and then I just knock off the hardened lumps with a chisel or block plane. I would rather have the glue confined to drips and drops than spread around the surface with a wet rag. I have never had Titebond yellow glue stain anything.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#14

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

Jim Dillon

>Scott,

Sure can't improve on all the good advice you've gotten. One thing I do, that I don't think I saw mentioned (my apologies if it was), is to clamp small blocks of wood on the top and bottom ends of each seam to help keep the boards aligned. I have a box of roughly 1 x 3 x 3/4 inch plywood blocks, each wrapped in cellophane tape. Clamping these on, especially during the initial phase of glue-up, helps me maintain some sense of calm. After everything is glued up and clamped, I remove each pair of pads - one pair at a time - to clean up any glue squeeze-out. If things look really good, I remove the pads entirely.

And, as been mentioned, be sure to keep all boards flush to the clamp surface and work on a flat surface. Also watch for any lifting of the boards from the surface of the clamp due to poorly jointed edges.

Oh yes, those small blocks of plywood are also handy for spreading out the clamping pressure to avoid denting the wood. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#15

Another Method

Hank Knight

>I took a hand tool workshop from Garrett Hack last Fall at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in Maine. One of the demonstrations Hack did was to make a coopered door for a cabinet. He hand planed the angled edges of the panel sections and glued them together using method #1, I.E., he spread yellow glue (not hide glue) on one edge with his finger and rubbed the two edges of the joint together. Here's the intesting part: he held them together with his hands for a minute or so until the glue tacked. After it tacked and held together on it's own, he set it aside for 10 or 15 minutes. Then he added the next section using the same process until he had several glued together. When he added the last piece, he set it aside for several hours WITHOUT ANY clamps. By the afternoon (about 4 hours later) he was able to hand plane the curved surface of the door. I asked about the strength of the glue joints and he said clamps were unnecessary. I've thought a lot about that, and I've made several glued-up panels since; but I can't bring myself to just set them aside with no clamps.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#16

Re: Another Method

Barry Irby

>I have read about leaning a couple of sticks against the wall so that they are in the same plane and slightly off vertical. Then you rub the glue into each joint and let the entire panel lean against the sticks/wall until the glue cures. Not sure, but I believe this is a time honored procedure with hide glue. Like you, I have not had the nerve to try it.

If I had the room in my shop I would make a rack with a clamp about every twelve inches and leaning as I described above. Then you could just lay up the pieces and snug up the clamps.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#17

not what the manufacturer recommends

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When it comes to using a product I look to the technical literature of the manufacturer for advice on how to use the product. The company had spent loads of effort researching the applications to find out what works best.

The Titebond technical literature recommends 100-300 psi for edge gluing. The proof is in wood failure. If one wants to invent a process different from what the manufacturer recommends then test this new procedure. Make the joint, cure it and make it fail. A good joint will show 90+ % wood failure.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#18

Clamping pressure??

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>You can use a thermometer to tell if you have 100 degree water. How do you know if you have applied 100-300psi with your hand tightened clamps?

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#19

Re: Clamping pressure??

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The point is that max is well beyond what most mortals can achieve with hand tightened clamps. So tighten the suckers down as best you can, not the least you can.

Re: Edge to Edge Glue Ups......

#20

a means of increasing pressure?

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>Thank you Bill. I will continue tightening my clamps completely.

You sound like one of my well educated, Mechanical Engineer, eagle scout friends. Actually three of my five groomsmen fit this description. I mean it as a compliment. My wife accused me of being a goofball, always asking strange questions. I like to think of it as thinking outside the box.

Let's say I edge clamp my boards together real tight by hand right now, or yesterday, when it's 0 degrees outside and then bring it inside where the temp changes to 70 degrees. If I were able to increase the temp of the boards rapidly enough to have them expand before the glue got tacky and set up, how much more pressure do you think would be applied to the clamped joint? If this was performed in a vacuum? On the equator? (sorry, I'm just messing around)

I feel like I'm one of my backpacking partners writing a question for a high school physics final exam. This year she's teaching HS chemistry. Makes for interesting conversations in the back country while I'm building rustic furniture and my other buddy is napping.