Going cordless
Jeff
>Good day,
I could use some advice. I'm looking at a Rigid and Dewalt cordless 18 Volt combo pack. Which one is the strongest and best quality?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Going cordless
Jeff
>Good day,
I could use some advice. I'm looking at a Rigid and Dewalt cordless 18 Volt combo pack. Which one is the strongest and best quality?
Re: Going cordless
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Why a combo pack; and why 18v? Almost anything you'll need to do can be handled by the little Makita LiON impact driver.
Clint
Re: Going cordless
Jeff
>It just seams like you get much bang for the buck in a combo. Is Makita going to be better than the other two?
Re: Going cordless
Kevin Mac Luskie
>I've never used the Rigid, so I can't comment on them. I've had the Dewalt 18v Drill and Skill saw combo since 2000. Yup just over 7 years. I'm not a contractor, but a heavy use do-it-yourselfer. My Drill has been left out in the rain, dropped off ladders onto all surfaces including concrete, and it's still working great. I've since added the Sawzall, Right angle drill and flash light. They've all been great, and durable.
My only complaint, is the cost of the batteries. They are more expensive than almost any other 18volt system. The best bang for the buck are the 2 packs online for $89-99. But that's still $45-50 each. Compared to the $15-20 of the Ryobi on the cheapest end. All the others falling between the two.
My batteries seem to last 2-3 years if I use them regularly. Less than two years for the set I bought and didn't use much.
Hope that's useful.
-Kevin
Re: Going cordless
Barry Irby
>Jeff, I don't have a combo pack or even and 18 volt system. I have an old 12 volt Makita drill and a Makita Impact driver. I bought the impact driver to get two new batteries, so the drill and driver use the same batteries. Since then I have had all four batters rebuilt.
In all of these systems, the batteries are the weak link. If you look around, you will find they nearly give you the tools to get you to buy the batteries.
Rigid had a deal going that guaranteed the batteries for life. If they still honor that, that's a really good reason to buy the system and be sure you send in the warranty. Check and double check.
Bosch had a deal where they gave a no hassle three year guarantee. If you go that way, you should send the batteries back at the end of two years and eleven months.
I find my 12 volt stuff to be "just right". Fairly small and compact and not to heavy, yet powerful enough to do what I need. I do not see any advantage to the bigger heavier batteries. If I had to let all my tools go, those two would be the last ones out the door.
Re: Going cordless *LINK*
Grant Smith
>Jeff,
For years folks have been debating about the quality of Makita, Milwaukee, and DeWalt cordless tools. I don't think one brand rates consistently above the others. I can give you some advice, given that I have owned and used all three brands. ( can't give advice on Rigid since I haven't owned them, though their battery guarantee is intriguing).
I have owned a DeWalt 12V drill for 7+ years, good tool but the batteries failed at about 5 years. Replaced batteries by buying a DeWalt 12V impact driver. Most impressive tool I had owned to date when I bought it! AWESOME for driving screws, etc. and the batteries interchanged with the old 12V DW drill. One of those rare new tools that changes a persons preferred methods of work.
Then I saw a Milwaukee 18V LI-ION drill at a local tool supplier with a special deal in which you get a FREE cordless sawzall if you bought the drill. I bought it and it is indeed a great drill, great sawzall. The sawzall compares closely to the corded sawzall in terms of capability and build quality (And, I think a bit better built than other brands of recip saws). The drill is a well built monster and really too big for driving screws, and too heavy for regular shop use. It is nice to have for hammer drilling or for large hole drilling. This is not a reflection on Milwaukee, just that an 18V tool is really more than I needed (and I spent the summer building a home). These are Mikwaukees newer Li-Ion tools.
Then, again at a tool sale I picked up a Makita 14V combo kit with a drill, impact driver and flashlight. I gotta say these are the "go to" drill and driver. I think they are the right balance between weight and performance. The impact driver will sink 3.5" screws over and over again into construction lumber, and it is light, well balanced, and has a nifty light. The 14.4V drill is more than enough to shoot a 1" hole through hardwoods. Light, refined, quiet, and fits the hand nicely.
If I had to recommend something to someone based on my experience, I'd say find a Makita combo kit in the 14.4V range. Make sure you get an impact driver in the kit if you drive any fasteners, they are "tool of the year" for the last five years in my book. Look for a 2-4 tool combo, then when your batteries die, you can buy one new tool of the same voltage and get new batteries that interchange.
Note that my makita set is 14.4V NiMH, which has now been mostly replaced with Li-Ion. You may be able to get an 18V tool kit that weighs little or no more than my 14.4V....assuming you have the $$$. I think Makita has taken a lighter weight approach to the Li-Ion while Milwaukee seems to have taken a longer run-time approach.
Here's an 18V set at Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Makita-LCT300W-Compact-Lithium-Ion-Cordless/dp/B000V2BRM2/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=hi&qid=1202326422&sr=1-3
Here's a link to my set:
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa
Makita 14.4V kit
Re: Going cordless
dave schaefer
>I've had Mikita 9.6 drills since the 80's now have 6 total seldom need to change a bit. for a drill these have been all I need. remodled lots of homesw,built lots of kitchen cabinets,furnature. the larger are too heavy to use all day in my opinion. mikita has been a quality tool for many moons...good luck ds
Re: Going cordless
John K Jordan
>I can't compare for you, but I can give you my experience. Based on good experience with other Dewalt cordless drills, I bought a Dewalt 18v combo pack a few years ago (drill, redcip saw, circular saw) and I consider it excellent. I did buy extra batteries so I can rotate between six and never run out of power. (Caught on sale, it's cheaper to buy an extra drill with two batteries than it is to buy two batteries - this is why I've ended up with four Dewalt 12 and 18v cordless drills!)
I bought the combo to get the recip saw and an extra drill at a good price. I didn't think I would use the circular saw much, but I've since found it invaluable around the shop, house, and farm.
JKJ
Get the Ridgid with the lifetime warranty
Kelby
>that covers ordinary wear-and-tear. I don't know if they're offering it now, but they offer it periodically. It covers battery replacement, even the bulbs on the flashlight. I've had my set for several years and put it through some abuse, and I've gotten one replacement battery from them so far without problem. I've been very happy with it. I've also picked up their 18V jigsaw and some other stuff with the lifetime wear-and-tear warranty as well. Hard to beat.
Re: Going cordless
robert davis
>someone told me rigid has a lifetime warranty including batteries. worth checking out