>We bought a house last April which needs a fair amount of updating. So far I've removed a hot tub from a sun room area, and run some minor wiring in the 3.5 car garage for a shop (3 way wiring to a light switch on the far wall to go with the one by the side door, a 220 volt outlet). I've removed the hot tub wiring from the sun room (replacing the 50 amp breakers with 30 amp for the 10/3 w/ground I ran to the new 220 outlet) and I'm planning to put up insulation & new paneling in the sun room, and maybe install a window. My plans are still developing at this stage. I'm guessing that technically, the wiring should have had a permit, but that something like replacing insulation & paneling in an existing structure, probably not. I'm sure it varies by area, but what are some general/practical/real world guidelines for work which should really have a permit? I know insurance/resale need to be considered, but due to the cost/PITA factor of the process, many people don't bother for relatively minor jobs which by a "letter of the law" test should be permitted.
I'm a building inspector. That said, general rule of thumb is that if you replace like with like, no permit. For example, if you replace a ceiling light with a new light fixture, no permit. If you want to install a ceiling fan where there was just a light fixture before, permit. Insulation (when adding, etc.), siding, roofing, etc., require no permit here in VA on a SFD or accessory building. The window would be a toss up, as long as it's not on a bearing wall, I'd probably let it go without a permit, as long as there wasn't a lot of other work going on at the same time. If you called me and asked if you needed a permit to remove a hot tub and blank/cap off the wiring, plumbing, etc., I would probably say, good luck, go ahead. You've already proved you're sharp by yanking out that 50 amp breaker.............:) If you were a homeowner and said you were getting a contractor to do it, permit required, for sure.
While it's true that insurance companies look for ways out if things really go south, it's also very difficult for them to prove that a particular piece of wiring wasn't already there.
So.............letter of the law, probably "yes" for any new wiring, etc. Real world, I don't get a permit when I want to add a receptacle in my shop either. I'd be broke shortly and unable to buy any good wood.......:)
If you're interested, here's a good example of why permits are required: Old gentleman calls the other day with a complaint. He's had a guy (not a licensed contractor) add on a 10 x 12 room on the back of his S/W trailer. My 3-year old grandaughter could have done better. Really pitiful, can't be occupied, must be torn down. No permit. He has no records of payments, all of which are in cash. I go to Commonwealth Attorney, but with no records of payment, hard to prove. No case. This would have been the third strike on the "contractor" of contracting without a license, so this time it would be a felony, bye bye for a while. Now the old gentleman is out the money, plus money to pay for the demo. If he'd gotten a permit, I would have been involved and known the "contractor" and been able to help him recover his money, plus prosecute the builder. So, we're not always the bad guy................
I know there's a good home inspector that frequents these boards, maybe he can give you some insight as well.
Good luck with your project and let me know if I can help. As always, just my $.02...........
>Three things: Rich, where in VA are you? Just curious, I'm in VA also, (Chester, near Richmond). I think I am the Home Inspector you spoke of. At least, I aspire to the "good" part you mentioned.
Dan, on a side note, your check is in the mail. I've had it for a while, but I had to ride it around in the car for a few days....Thanks again.
As to your permit, its local. Rich and I both are in VA and we have a "Statewide Uniform Building Code). I think Rich and I can agree that it might be statewide, but its not very uniform. The requirements for permits and the depth of enforcement vary from county to county. Let alone the fact that you are in the other end of the country.
As an example; I was recently on the other end of the process, working on a friends house. I did not think we needed a permit. We were replacing some damaged siding, porch floor boards, damaged underlayment under carpet, Carpet and vinyl, patching Sheetrock, painting, replacing the windows etc.
The rental agent insisted we needed some permits, co I checked with the local Building Official. Some Interesting things came out of it. He did not require a permit for repairing siding, replacing the floor boards on the porch or deck, replacing the windows (with the type that insert into the existing frames), patching drywall or painting, or carpet and vinyl.
He did require a permit for replacing the underlayment. That struck me as odd, because I thought it was none structural. We did not replace the subfloor. We replaced the front door and he required a permit for that because we use one of the door/frame units and since we replaced the frame it had to be inspected.
When he came to inspect, he noticed I had decided to replace the entire wooden front steps rather than just the treads. (there were only three steps) Because I replaced the stringers for the steps, I should have gotten a permit and I had evolved the new code, requiring the risers be closed in to not allow the passage of a four inch diameter object. I thought it was "funny" that because I only replaced the treads on the back steps, they were fine and did not have to be closed in. So some things get "grandfathered" and others get upgraded.
I would suggest you call the local codes people "under an assumed name" and discuss this with them. The reason for the anonymity is that you are free to fully discuss what you want to do without creating a situation that causes the cost and complexity of the permit to go up. You might decide to not do some things or to hire the pro's to do it.
I'm in Amelia, tho' I worked for Chesterfield for 5 years and VA B-C OM before that.
Agree, each jurisdiction has the legal authority to interpret the code in their own way, altho' most things really are pretty black and white.
I don't think I would have gotten into the underlayment thing, and I know I wouldn't have gigged you on the steps. If you replace them just like they were, albeit with new material, they have to be better than what they were. And I really don't like that 4" deal on the risers, because taken literally, I could put a 1x2 up there 1/2way up the riser and be legal, but that sure would be dangerous. We like to see either a solid riser or nothing. That's one of the problems with a big jurisdiction like C-field, each inspector also interprets the code in a different way. If you call one and ask, you may get something different from the actual inspector.
Not sure why he/she would have said anything about the door frame, that's sure not structural unless you altered the rough opening. It's gonna make a long day if I gotta start 'spectin' door frames......
And yes, you were the good home inspector I spoke of, I enjoy reading your posts.............
Your assessment of the VA USBC is right on, for sure. We try to be fair, and as my boss says, as cordial as the law will allow. Common sense goes a long way, and I'm certainly not out to get anyone, "just because I can".........
>Nice to meet you Richard. What type of wood boring do you do? If you are interested, you should come to the Turning Club meetings at the Wood Craft store in Willow Lawn on the third Thursday at about 6:30. Really good group. The national symposium is coming this year to Richmond.
On the Door thing, I thought it hung on the difference between and door jamb and the frame of the opening. Or At least it should have, in my mind. If I had changed the RO then it should have been inspected, but not for the jamb. OTOH, I saw a Steel door and frame that had been installed with about four 6d finishing nails through the brick molding. The customer's complaint was that he slammed the door and it fell out, frame and all and tumbled down the steps. The builder's response was, "Why are you calling me, it's your house?"
A day or two after I installed risers on the steps (I did front and rear anyway) I saw a multifamily multistory project that had exterior wooden steps that were open. They had screwed a 2x2 under the toe of the treads. Took me a while to realize that it reduced the opening to 3 7/8". I could have done that to mine a lot easier. However, on the multi-story units, I would have pushed for closed risers to keep fire from sweeping through the steps because they were the egress route. It would have been a cheap way to buy them a few minutes in a fire.
I've been to the TA meeting once a year or so ago, even joined up, but the date sorta interferes with my other job (wife and I own a florist), and don't you know, those women get upset when you don't do payroll on Thursday night!!!
I wasn't aware that door frames were structural........:)
The open/closed riser thing is there so that the toddlers don't fall through, but if you had that piece like you described, your heel would surely catch in there and that's why I have a problem with it.
shoot me an e-mail and I'll try to hook up with you one day, daughter lives in Chester..........
>Structure, plumbing, electric & HVAC. And I've learned the hard way . . . if in doubt . . . call and ask ! You feel pretty darn silly taking something down for them to look inside or tearing it down completly ! CYA !
>Hi Dan, what part of the country are you in? City or County? I just got a house in town re-roofed and the city required a permit just to replace shingles. The house we just had moved will be under the counties jurisdiction. I spent $1750.00 on permits and with what we are doing the inspector won't even come in the house. I had to get a permit for an existing driveway. To top things off I have to get my pole barn re-enginneered if I want to keep the intermediate floor the former owner installed without permits. I do understand where the county is coming from and they have been very pleasant to work with, (I understand the former owner wasn't, in fact he made the whole purchase procedure was a bit of a nightmare. So much so that HIS realtor absorbed some additional costs the seller tried to add to extend escrow at the last minute). I guess this turned into a bitof a rant. Anyway the county is happy to work with me.
>Years ago I installed my own chain-link fence...posts and all. I measured the line and divided it up evenly and posts came out to be spaced evenly...well within the allowed spacing...dug down 24" for the corner and gate posts...poured water and then dry concrete into holes. Line posts were dug 12" and installed the same. Covered up the cement with dirt I had on hand and called for the inspection...Inspector turned it down cause he could not "see" the concrete. Well, I went to the city hall and wondered if he had ever heard of using a 1/4" steel probe to make sure concrete was there. I got the OK from the main inspector.
Strung the chain-link...stretched it tight and installed bars. Installed upper and lower rails...and it is still as good as when i did it back in 1975.
I am a retired const. man and know const. from the planning, drawing, schematics, construction of all natures, and later in my career...did the mortgage financing. Also took and passed a Home Inspection course in 2004.
FYI: We're in the Snohomish county area of Washington state (county, not city).
I agree with all the points made. Richard, I don't necessarily consider inspectors to be "the enemy". Even putting aside amateur do-it-yourself calamities, if some of the "professional" work I have seen in just the handful of houses with which I am directly familiar is any example, there is clearly a need to have some regulation at least in areas (like Mark's deck) where serious injury could result from a failure.
Also agree with the point about removing shop wiring prior to a sale. My feeling about the additions I made was that if I sold the house & there was any kind of stink about it, it's easy enough to pull the wiring (you'll pardon the pun ;-). Also agree about it being hard for a buyer/insurance co. to know when something like wiring was added. Being a cynic, I would expect an insurer to attempt anything they could to weasel out of a large claim, say, in the case of a big fire, but how could every homeowner be expected to know the extent/quality/legality of each and every modification which had been done under a series of owners.
The observation about the ceiling fan is interesting; on the one hand, it's clear that something this heavy with spinning blades could be seriously dangerous, on the other hand I'd be amazed if even 10% of such light-to-fan "upgrades" were executed with a permit/inspection.
A question about procedure. The 3.5 car garage is detached on the ground floor, though it has added living space above which does connect to the main upstairs. The space between the garage & back door is about 6' wide, over poured concrete, and about 60% covered by the 2nd floor transition between the original upstairs & the 2nd floor, above the garage addition (I hope I'm making this clear enough). Directly across from the back door is the side door to the garage. I would like to enclose the space between the back door & this side garage door. Obviously, this should have a permit. I pretty much know "in my head" how to go about this, but what do I need to present to the inspectors, in terms of plans, drawings, materials lists, etc? Contacting them "anonymously" is a good idea, but an early heads up would be helpful, if anyone can enlighten me.
BTW Barry, glad you got the spa bits, let me know if they were of any use.