Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

is this such a bad idea?

Posts

is this such a bad idea?

#1

is this such a bad idea?

Lee Beeden

>I've been finishing the front of my cabinet doors with Varathane Dimond (oil based) finish. But its slow to dry.

What about finishing the inside of the doors with a quick drying water based finish to hurry things up a little?

The cabinets have a oil based stain on them. But it has been at least 3 days so it should be no problem with the water base finish on top right?

I did finish the inside of the cabinets with a quick drying water based poly.

thanks

Lee

Re: is this such a bad idea?

#2

Re: is this such a bad idea?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Lee,

Depending on the stain and the waterbased finish, you may have adhesion problems over the oil stain unless you use a coat of dewaxed shellac to seal the oil stain. Either way it's test-on-scrap time.

mm

Re: is this such a bad idea?

#3

Re: is this such a bad idea?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Definitely do not finish the door inside surfaces with an oil base. It will impart a foul odor. Use a water base or shellac on the door backs.

Ed

Re: is this such a bad idea?

#4

Re: is this such a bad idea?

steve mackay

>I switched to water base LONG ago. If the weather is just right I can get three coats a day. Looks as good as oil IMHO and ( again IMHO ) is easier to work with. My other switch was to Min-Wax. I was a die hard Varathane man but I thought they got to pricey. Min-Wax's product surpased Verathane in ease of application four or five years ago. I go through a LOT of poly, you might give it a try.

Re: is this such a bad idea?

#5

Question Steve.....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I also use water base Varathane over oil stains with absolutely no adhesion problems. And I rarely wait more than a day to apply the first coat of water poly. Your comment about Minwax water poly interests me. The only gripe I have with water poly in general is that it dries sorta white where you get it too thick in corners or in grooves or beading on routed edges. I've never used the Minwax product. Does it do that too? Other than the white opaque issue, I love the way Varathane applies.

Re: is this such a bad idea?

#6

Nope . . .

steve mackay

>My work is mostly carved scale models with lots of itty-bitty nooks and cranies. The Min-Wax water base never causes me any heartache. " Takes " every time over oil based stains also. My only beef ( because I forget sometimes ) is that carpenters ( including Tite-Bond ) glue wont bond even when sanded. But thats my goof-up and no fault of the finnish or glue.