Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT Cable Vs DSL

Posts

OT Cable Vs DSL

#1

OT Cable Vs DSL

Barry Irby

>I have Cable from Comcast

Considering cutting the costs a bit.

Can anybody give me a real world idea of the speed difference?

I mostly go to Wood Central and occasionally down load some bits and pieces that include motion/video.

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#2

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

Chuck W

>Barry,

On the speed test at the website of my ISP it measures a download speed of a little over 4000Mbs and an upload speed of a little over 630Mbs. This is slower than cable but it costs less too.

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#3

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

Stuart Johnson

>I have AT&T DSL at about $40 plus all the taxes and fees. The service is up to 6 MBS download but I normally get around 5.2 which is fast enough to watch a Netflix movie with no problem.

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#4

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

Chuck W

>Barry,

On the speed test at the website of my ISP it measures a download speed of a little over 4000Mbs and an upload speed of a little over 630Mbs. This is slower than cable but it costs less too.

Sorry that should have read 4000Kbs and 630Kbs.

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#5

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

David Yoho

>Unless I'm mistaken, I'm paying about the same for Comcast cable in the same area as Barry. $40 plus taxes and fees is pretty close to my monthly charge. Barry, I don't think you will save much over cable if that's the going price for DSL around here. I thought DSL would be much less. If cable was not an option in my area, then it would be a great deal!

David

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#6

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I did, too. Had cable internet from the beginning, when @Home opened my town as their second community anywhere. 1997, maybe?

My bill was $65, because I had to have the basic cable package AND the Internet package. AT&T had a promo, still running, likely, at $25 (?) + taxes. I use that now, and it's every bit as good. And doesn't lose it's DNS and Mail Server settings every morning, like cable would, for 45 minutes to an hour, even with a router/modem reboot.

There was no way that I was going to give up my sat tv for crummy cable again. Not with the quality at my son's place.

What I have is the 3mbps package, and I get all of that, per the install tech's meters...

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#7

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

David Sparks

>Hey Barry,

My wife and I switched from Comcast cable to Embarq DSL last year. We have been very dissatisfied with all aspects of Embarq's sevice. Comcast is much faster and much more reliable. We are switching back to Comcast cable in March after our one year contract with Embarq expires. We are also dropping our landline because of Embarq's poor service.

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#8

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

Bob Wilkerson - Richmond, VA

>Barry,

I went thru the same process last July. Switched from Comcast to Verizon DSL. Worked just fine... for about a month. Then it started getting slower. Download tests showed that I was getting about twice dial up speeds. Spent over 6 weeks working with Verizon tech support at various times as they were convinced that it was my PC that was the problem. Ok, I've only mesed with PC's for 28 years and I might have run into a problem that I can't figure out... Removed router, tried multiple PC's direct connected using Win98, XP Pro and Vista - same results. DSL modem showed 3MB service but thruput was abysmal. Finally gave up and said to the umpteenth tech support person that I needed someone to come to the house and resolve the problem. They said that they couldn't do it since their tests showed no problem on their end. Did I mention that all support was from India???

Ok, no problem - switched back to Comcast since they had just called with an offer on $19.99 for 1 year. Hooked everything up without any changes on my end and got 29000kbs service this morning - Average is more like 12000 during busy times but is way better than Verizon.

That said, I'll look back at Verizon at the end of the year as they now offer FIOS in my neighborhood. I'll look at it for TV, phone and Internet.... Price/performance Rules!

YMMV,

Bob

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#9

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

Tony - Memphis

>I have AT&T DSL. Not sure what I am paying, but its the fastest service. We have been real happy with it. I never had cable, so I can't compare. It seems very fast though. When we upgraded to the current speed, they sent a tech out to check the line to make sure they could deliver. Because of our location, our speed was actually better than advertised. He said location and all new lines makes a difference. We have a had a few outages, but nothing serious. Anyway, there you have it.

Tony

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#10

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

John McGaw

>I don't know that your question has an answer -- there is just too much variability. Some neighborhoods with cable have slow speed, some have incredible speed. Some neighborhoods with DSL have the same sort of spread. Prices range all over the map too. My ISP is AT&T (BellSouth) and they have a "lite" DSL service for $20/month which would be more than enough for normal web surfing and email and such activities. I have the "extreme" service with 6mbps advertised speed and which costs $43/month.

After having dealt with Comcast for TV and indirectly for internet access while helping others with their computers, they are below consideration for me. I'm convinced that Comcast "customer service" is where those neither clever nor ambitious enough to work at Burger King seek employment. Me, I'll stick with DSL and satellite TV.

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#11

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

ScottS

>I originally had DSL at the house, but switched to Comcast's cable internet service a little over a year ago. Practically speaking, I don't notice much difference in speed. E-mails and web surfing don't use much bandwidth. The occasional YouTube video or software download is theoretically faster with the cable service I have, but I really don't notice a difference day-to-day.

The things I do notice are the improved reliability and customer service I get from Comcast! When my DSL was working, it was great. When it wasn't working, the phone company usually had no idea how to get it working again. Any problem would involved multiple phone calls, multiple visits by on-side technicians, and lots of yelling on my part. Once, the problem was so bad I had to cancel my DSL service, waited a week, and then re-ordered it! Only by having them do a brand-new install could I get it working again.

Anyway, I got tired of the hassle and decided to give Comcast a try. So far, it's been great. There have been a couple of outages, usually resolved within an hour or two. I've also had a couple of problems due to the age of the wiring in my house. In both cases, Comcast had a technician on-site the same day... not weeks later like the phone company. Overall, I've been very impressed with their service!

Re: OT Cable Vs DSL

#12

Re: OT DSL Different Speeds

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>I live out in the country and am able to get the highest speed DSL available from AT&T. My wife needed it for her work. Some of her co-workers who live inside Nashville could not get the highest speed. I am very happy with the speed and reliability of the DSL. I lose my Dish Network signal more often than the DSL. The cost is about $40.00.