Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

Posts

Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#1

Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

Paul Kierstead

>I'll be finishing a bunch of birds-eye maple and regular maple. I am a bit torn (ok, a lot torn) how to go about it. It is a wine cabinet with relatively low usage, though the top could get some abuse. I'd prefer a semi-gloss or satin finish, but can always knock down a finish if necessary.

The goal is to keep it reasonably blond or perhaps a little brown (the birds-eye is actually fairly brown considering) and not too yellow. I'd prefer *not* to dye if possible. Jeff Jewitt has a recipe, but it angled to making an antique maple look, which is not necessarily what I am looking for, plus it is dyed and glazed.

The goal here is to pop the grain. So far, I have tried



  • Deft Danish Oil Finish, cut 50% with mineral spirits. This popped it some, left the colour largely untouched. The eyes were enhanced, but other figure didn't come out much.

  • Tried and True Varnish Oil. This did amazing things to the eyes and figure, with a fabulous 3-D look, but added significant color, and not entirely the desired color; a little more yellow then one might like.


I figure on top-coating with something waterbased (or "water clear" at least) for durability if necessary.

Other thoughts, techniques you have used? Or mods?

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#2

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Do you have some polymerized tung oil? Pretty tough finish, pops up the grain, and does not yellow the maple that much. IIRC T&T contains linseed oil, which will darken the maple more.

Worth a try...

DC

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#3

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

Paul Kierstead

>Good thought. I do have some (both polymerized and unpolymerized actually). At the price of high grade veneer, I am wary of running too many experiments, but that sounds like it be worth a shot.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#4

Re: Super blonde shellac

Dave Mount

>The lighter shades of shellac don't impart that much color and, more importantly, do not darken with age like many other finishes do. By putting on the first couple coats highly thinned, you can get the finish down into the fibers to accent the figure. I used to put oil on under the shellac, but my own experience and an article in FWW a couple years ago convinced me it doesn't make a difference, you can just start with shellac. Once you've fully saturated the wood (i.e., additional coats don't soak in they just build on top) then sand it flat and apply your finish coats as thick as pleases you.

Posted below is an example in curly maple.

Best,

Dave


img

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#5

Re: Super blonde shellac

Paul Kierstead

>I didn't try shellac since my experience with some other woods let me to believe it doesn't pop grain nearly so aggressively as oil (which isn't always desired). However, your pic convinces me that the last "berth of 3" tests in this round shall be the shellac. I happen to have some de-waxed super-blonde that I recently used, so I even know it is good. Still, I forsee making up another test board for 3 more goes "just to see" what some other finishes look like.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#6

Re: Super blonde shellac

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I used some of the Jeff Jewitt supplied German sourced super ultra uber blonde liquid shellac on a Shaker clock case in maple a few years back. It did a very nice job, and was very easy to apply and modify (ie: fix my errors). This is VERY nice stuff, and I'm glad that it seems to keep a pretty good shelf life as shipped.

What I don't understand is the mix of oil- and water- based material in your original post. That seems to me to be asking for more trouble than you'd want, for very little gain. But YMMV, of course.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#7

Re: Super blonde shellac

Paul Kierstead

>I was (am) concerned that enough oil build up to provide protection would significantly alter the colour. So one oil shot, then a clear protection finish; probably water based as they are generally the clearest. It would need a coat or two of de-waxed shellac in between to allow adhesion.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#8

Re: Super blonde shellac

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>You could do that, or you could just do a shellac finish, with sufficient number of applications, say wiped or padded on. No need for oil. Much of that pop will come with the shellac wetting.

Keep it simple.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#9

Re: Super blonde shellac

Paul Kierstead

>I am a fan of shellac, but in this application I am not entirely comfortable with the protection nor the finish type (shiny film), particularly if it is built up enough to impart the protection required for the top.

I tried wiping some one last night and it looked better then the thinned Deft but still less pop then the T&T. It imparted almost no color, which was quite nice. I am going to sand it smooth and coat again to get a better idea of the outcome.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#10

Re: Depth comes with build

Dave Mount

>In my experience, you need a build of the finish before it will gain much depth. The roughness of a surface without a complete film over the surface will disturb the light path and interfere with the sense of depth.

This phenomenon is clearly observable when you coat a project with Danish oil. When you wipe it on, the surface has great depth, because there is oil laying on top of the wood forming a film. Once the oil soaks in, much of that depth is lost, because the outer surface is no longer a smooth film.

My $0.02,

Dave

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#11

Re: Depth comes with build

Paul Kierstead

>That was my thinking, so I'll run it down for a fairly complete finishing schedule.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#12

Re: Super blonde shellac

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>While you are working on your test piece, try padding on the next 'layers' without leveling or sanding. Shellac melts into the prior shellac surface, and so, often, the sanding is not needed, and the 'build' happens more quickly. You can always sand or scrape later, if needed. That's one of the speed beauties of a shellac finish.

When it's time to cut the gloss, at the end of the process, some furniture wax and white synthetic steel wool works pretty well.

Re: Thoughts on finishing birds-eye maple.

#13

Re: Depth comes with build

Paul Kierstead

>In my experience, you need a build of the finish before it will gain much depth. The roughness of a surface without a complete film over the surface will disturb the light path and interfere with the sense of depth.

Follow-up: Did another round of finishing and, indeed, it is much better. It now has flow and is dynamic as you move and good depth. Interestingly, the eyes are different then when you use oil; shellac tends to strengthen the middle of the eye (making more of a dot) and oil seems to make more of an uncompleted donut; eyebrows sort of (but more around). I think I'll try one round of the diluted Deft followed with shellac, since I slightly prefer the oil effect and the Deft did not color the Maple (but didn't bring out the over all figure well). But even if that did not work out, the shellac did a smashing job; almost zero added yellow/orange tint, great figure.