Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Problem matching stain!

Posts

Problem matching stain!

#1

Problem matching stain!

Ron Hildreth

>I was asked to make a new bed side rail that had been broken by the customer's kids jumping on the bed. The rail, I'm sure is made from maple, but I'm having a hard time finding a stain that even comes close. Factory stains are always hard to match, but this one has me scratching my head. Hoping you guys, in all you infinite wisdom, might be able to lead me in the right direction. I thought it was a cherry stain, because of the red tint to it, but cherry isn't even close, unless it might be mixed with something else. Any ideas?


img

Re: Problem matching stain!

#2

Re: Problem matching stain!

Ron Hildreth

>Photo #2


img

Re: Problem matching stain!

#3

Photo #3

Ron Hildreth

>Photo # 3


img

Re: Problem matching stain!

#4

Re: Photo #4

Ron Hildreth

>Photo #4


img

Re: Problem matching stain!

#5

Re: Problem matching stain!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Ron,

Is it the rail which is broken or the cleat which supports the box spring? And, can you get the two pieces apart? I'd be inclined to separate the assembly and install a new piece of maple. I've just went thru a similar exercise with matching a Thomasville factory finish, and the results are only live-with-able at best. I tried to find something which would match but neither water based dye or store bought stain worked real well with the multi-toned factory finish. I finally applied light oil based maple, a "Honey Maple", sealed that with shellac, sanded, and applied an "antique maple" gel stain which had a lot of red in it. After shellac and sanding, I applied a little minwax special walnut and came close. No cigar, though. With the bed reassembled with a new piece, will you be able to see the cleat once the box spring is installed? BTW, I initially thought to use cherry to color match. No Way. I had to sneak up on the final result.

George

Re: Problem matching stain!

#6

Re: Problem matching stain!

Ron Hildreth

>Hi, George

The cleats were just fine, as it's the side rail (most visible) that's broke into two pieces. If you look at the photos, you'll see the two pieces side by side.

Ron in Iowa

Re: Problem matching stain!

#7

Re: Problem matching stain!

Dick Coers

>It doesn't hardly look like maple, but hard to tell from the pic. If I were you I would take some maple scrap, sanded to the level of sanding that you are going to do on the finished part, and the bed rail to the best paint store in your area and let them do the hard part. My favorite method for matching old finish is at least 1 coat, maybe 2 of orange shellac. Then top coat with your favorite. The orange shellac will mimic the yellowing of the antique clear coat. A lot of factory finishes have at least a clear coat that has some tint added. It lets them hide the various tones of the wood and in the case of that bedrail, it helps hide the finger joint. You can get aresol cans of tinted lacquer.

Re: Problem matching stain!

#8

Re: Problem matching stain!

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I'm thinking it looks like beech...hard to tell. And the stain looks like antique maple.

Rob

Re: Problem matching stain!

#9

Re: Problem matching stain!

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Plan B.

Think bed skirts, matched with the spread.

heheheheh

Re: Problem matching stain!

#10

Re: Problem matching stain!

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I see a lot of yellow and green in the original sample. I'd take a large (24" x 4") piece of scrap maple (?) and give it a yellow stain all over. Then, put a coat of greenish brown such as Minwax special walnut on a small section. Apply a coat or two of clear, and compare to the original. If it needs more red, start adding small amounts of a compatible red stain and continue until it looks reasonable.

Use measuring spoons from the kitchen or similar so you know exactly how much of each color you have added to the mix. Keep notes as you go along. Do your color comparisons in sunlight and stand back 6 feet from the samples.

Ed

Re: Problem matching stain!

#11

Re: Problem matching stain!

Dave Mount

>I'm virtually certain the wood is an exotic, probably from Asia -- the diffuse porous structure and lack of clear grain lines mark it as something not from a temperate climate. That's not to say you shouldn't replace it with maple if that's available to you.

Shellac in a range of colors, or with dyes added, is a good way to go about this kind of matching. I think you want color in the layers of topcoat; using a stain at the base is likely to accent the differences in wood structure between what this is and what you replace it with.

That said, the suggestion to take a piece of the replacement and the original to a paint store (a real paint store, not the Borg) and have them match it is the easiest way to go if you're going to stain. I did that when building more cabinets to add to an existing factory kitchen and they did a great job. You pay a couple bucks more for the stain, but it saves you a lot of messing around, well worth the trade IMHO.

Good luck,

Dave