Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

wood selection and staining

Posts

wood selection and staining

#1

wood selection and staining

Rob1950

>am building a kitchen "gathering block" - a freestanding 2'x2' table at counter height

with a cutting board on the top. The cutting board for the top is made of 8/4

maple with the top in an checkerboard end grain pattern set into a white maple frame.

My wife wants the base to finished with blue stain or paint that's given a sort of distressed

or antique appearance by putting applying the blue stain over a preliminary coat of gold

or amber stain and sanding the blue in places.

My question is whether it would detract from the project to use poplar in place of maple for

the base. She wants 4x4 legs for the base, and 8/4 maple gets kind of pricy for the entire

base- 8/4 poplar stock is less than half the price. My concern is that poplar has a somewhat greenish tint \

and a grain pattern that is not particularly appealing (to me at least). I'm worried that the grain pattern\

and/or the tint will show through the stain

and will detract from the project,

but I don't know enough about staining (I'm a complete novice with this) to have a good idea. Since blue+g\

old=green, more or less, the tint might not be a big problem, but I suspect it would tend to give the base \

of a greenish than blueish look, and unless one used a very solid stain, the grain pattern would be likely\

to bleed through. Probably I should go with the maple- its always a good idea to keep one's wife happy, b\

ut if anyone has some suggestions about whether the poplar would work, I'd appreciate hearing from you.

Rob

Re: wood selection and staining

#2

Lee Grindinger

Soft maple to the rescue?

Lee Grindinger

>It sounds like soft maple would be a good solution assuming the maple you're talking about for the top is hard maple. Soft maple is cheaper than hard. Pine might be a decent alternative as well if most of the grain is obscured.

Lee

Re: wood selection and staining

#3

Re: wood selection and staining

boardman

>I'd say forget maple entirely. It's notoriously bad at accepting stain - it tends to get "blotchy" with uneven absorption of the stain.

Poplar may indeed work, or another evenly light type wood - like birch. Best bet is to get some smaller pieces to experiment with. With stain there's no going back, so try samples before putting stain on the finished piece.

Re: wood selection and staining

#4

Re: wood selection and staining

John Pappas

>Birch has the same problem. It blotches if not done right. There are various ways to stain blotch-prone woods like maple, cherry, pine, birch.... I would suggest following the advice given in books by Bob Flexner, Michael Dresdner, and Jeff Jewitt.

Re: wood selection and staining

#5

Re: wood selection and staining

Yonak

>I find that a pre-stain conditioner helps the poor ability of maple to accept stain, to an extent. While not perfect, it helps a good bit.

At the times when I have to stain using a color (such as blue) instead of a standard wood stain, I have had good luck with an oil-based paint mixed with Penetrol, experimenting with the concentration.

Re: wood selection and staining

#6

I say ...

Joe Burke

>use the hard maple throughout.

Have you already made the top? It sounds as if you already have the top ... maybe I'm wrong.

I say use the hard maple for the base as well, but use 4/4 stock and assemble the 4x4 legs as a hollow box. This as opposed to laminating 8/4 solid stock. Of course, I don't know the design or how this would affect joinery.

The hard maple will provide consistency throughout and it will hold up much better ... because it's tougher ... in a kitchen environment. The 4/4 will be cheaper than the 8/4 too. Now, there's more joinery invlolved, and you do have more glue joints ... which means more change in grain direction ... unless you mitre the boxes. Life's one big trade off ... for me anyway.

Maple does blotch, but I don't think hard maple blotches any worse, and maybe less, than soft maple or birch. I know you said you're a novice with the stain, but a very thin wash coat of shellac will greatly reduce the blotching. That wash coat is the only extra step you'd need.

I hate trying to stain poplar. Maybe that's why using hard maple is my knee jerk reaction. However, if you could find a nice cream colored 8/4 poplar board ... with little or no green ... it sounds as if there'll be enough color on the base to obscure any big differences. Also, in the interest of full disclosure, if you go with the maple and wash coat, the cost of the shellac and dentaured alchohol has to be included in the equation. If spending as little money as is possible is the primary objective ... it sounds more and more like settling for poplar might be the answer.

How's that for indecision? I like this type of thinking exercise, and I go through it constantly.

I still think the maple is a better choice.

Re: wood selection and staining

#7

Re: wood selection and staining

Jesse Cloud

>You always need to test how stain will work on some scrap, but I really think that with two coats of stain (or even better, paint), there is little chance that the tint of the poplar would show through, probably not the grain either. In any case, consistency between the top and the base just doesn't seem to be an issue - I say go with the poplar.

Re: wood selection and staining

#8

Dye is the answer

David Yoho

>If you go with poplar for the base, the best way I've found to color poplar to get it to turn out even and hide the different colors in the grain is use a dye - alcohol or water based. You'll never know the various colors are even there afterward. The best water based dyes I've used are W. D. Lockwood. These are sold by one of WC's sponsors, Tools For Woodworking, and they have an excellent Web page on how to mix and use them. The Lockwood WB dyes are also very good for soft maple and avoid the blotching associated with this wood. You can apply your favorite oil based topcoat over these dyes too!

David

Re: wood selection and staining

#9

Re: I say ...

Rob1950

>Thank you all very much for your excellent suggestions. It sounds as though there are quite a view viable options, and the best thing would, as suggested by most of you, to experiment with some scraps. The cutting-board top is already built and will be fastened to the base later on, so that it would be easy and inexpensive to get a feel for how different woods and finishes would look by setting the cutting board atop small scale mock-up bases made from scraps. I've found that cutoff remnants of all kinds of woods from a local woodworking company cost next to nothing- I can usually find useful-sized pieces of hard maple and poplar there. (As well as many other woods- they seem happy to have someone to cart them away!) In any case, I think Joe's suggestion of sticking with hard maple for a piece that will have intensive use in a high-volume area like the kitchen makes good sense. The concern was not only the price, but it made me shudder a bit at the thought of a finish that would obscure the beauty of all that maple. However, the hardness is as much of a factor, as pointed out by Joe, and the suggestion of using a preliminary coat of shellac under the stain sounds like it can solve the problem of blotches, which I was only dimly aware of. Perhaps an amber colored shellac under the stain could be used to achieve the blue-over-gold look. David's idea of using a water based dye over poplar- which is also very durable wood, I'd think- is very intriguing too- I've never used either finishing method before, and it sounds like there's a lot I can learn by experimenting with both. thanks again, Rob

Re: wood selection and staining

#10

Re: I say ...

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I doubt that you'd have any durability problems with Lee's suggestion of soft maple, and would, in my west coast pricing experience, spend 40% less on materials.

I did the cutting board/counter tops in my daughter-in-law's well used kitchen in soft maple, and they are really tough. And there is very little difference in the coloration between that and the hard maples used elsewhere in that same kitchen.

Enjoy the project, but don't sweat this detail all that much. Your wife is going to appreciate whatever you build this with.