I'm rebuilding my poorly built house and removed part of a load bearing wall to get to the supporting floor joist which needed total replacement. The subfloor is removed from the entire area so that the joists can be leveled for new plywood. I set jacks in place on the floor joist one over from the bad one to hold up the ceiling. A few weeks have passed and I noticed that the joist that's now temporarily carrying the load has deflected downward from the leveled state I had previously gotten it into. I think it's over 3/16" in the middle of a 10 foot span.
It's a 40 yr. old grade 2 doug fir 2x10.
My question is this: will the deflection (warp) remain after the load is removed from the joist or is it likely that it will spring back to where it was previously leveled?
>How much of the roof is bearing on the 2x10. Without a line drawing to show the spans it is not possible to tell what the load is. How long do you plan on having the one 2x10 in place 3/16 isn't much but I would have used at least a couple nailed together. Dug fir is really a strong wood but everythin has its limits. Can you put another brace in the middle??
>D fir has a Young's modulus of about 1e6/in2/in. It will also start to yield (take a "set) if loaded to 1/4 of shear strength. It's only wood subject to humidity and temperature. If you have a significant load on a wood member for a time it will sag. I suggest you get out the Lolly columns and relieve the bending load in that poor littke stick you have holding up half your structure.
>I have a little experience with this, but not much.
My experience is that the wood is springy and will spring back over and over, but if you force it into a bent shape and leave it there it acquire a "set" and will not spring back. There are several variable in this. How long it remains bent. How far or how deformed it is. Temperature and humidity.
My experience is with beams in crawl spaces. They are often undersized or spanning too far or over loaded, (three ways of saying the same thing) and they sag. If the house is years old and you try to straighten the beam with jacks of screw columns, it does not work well. The beams appear to resit straightening with about as much strength they had to resist bending.
As an aside, floor joists are not engineered to be perfectly rigid. The design has a characteristic deflection of the length (L) over 180, 240 or 360. The most rigorous would be L/360. With a ten foot span (120") the the allowable deflection would be 120/360 or 1/3" This is with the ordinary loading that would be expected on the floor. Not with the weight of the upper structure. The weight of the upper structure should be carried on columns and beams, not the joists, and certainly not a single joist.
The "time" here is relative. Wood has very different characteristics depending on the duration of the load. It has literally twice the strength under instantaneous loading as it does over long term loading. (That's why you can drive stakes with a sledge hammer with blows that would crush them over the long term.) Its 15% stronger under short term loading (storms) than it is over the lone term. There are also changes that take place in the wood over the very long term (many years). So, the less time you spend on this the better.
I think it is time for you to move along with your project and gett he load off the bent joist. Or supported joist from below and jack it back up. If the joist sagged 3/16", the upper structure of your house has probably moved the same amount. You may have to use a jack to light it all.
The joist that was removed was the only thing carrying the load of the wall previously and the plumbers cut half of one end away, thus the wall itself has sagged. So I thought no problem on one intact joist.
This is going slowly due to... stuff, so I gather it would be best to support the joist down to the basement floor with a couple more jacks and hopefully get my straight joist back.
>I would consider using a screw jack or whatever the columns are call in your area. Or even a could of 2 X 4's nailed together and maybe some wedges.
Do be careful about the basement slab. Locally, many older homes have a "Sweeping" slab in the cellar. Its a very thin slab over gravel or cinders to allow for the easy cleaning of the basement and it is not structural at all. If you have a rough thin slab, do not jack off it. If you have a regular four inch slab, I would put a pad of several thickness of "2 by" lumber down to spread the weight of the column.