Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Posts

?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#1

?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Malcolm Timbers

>?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

A friend owns a building where copper water pipes are becoming eroded and the elbows, because they are rather thin, have started leaking a year and half ago. Recently, four elbows started leaking during the past month. The plumber said it is cause by eddy currents in the pipe caused by a circulation pump. The fist elbows to start leaking were over 20' from the pump but the ones that started leaking recently are near the pump.

The copper pipes run closely along heavy duty electric conduit and fuse boxes. I suspect that electromagnetism is being induced into the copper pipes causing electrolysis to etch the pipes. I suspect this because I once had to replace a straight section of water pipe in my parents home that

was etched as the result of a family friend putting a night light on a visible pipe next to the washing machine. The bulb was lit from current via the water pipe and a hot wire from the water pump to indicate if the pump was running to help prevent running the well dry.

There is another building on this property with a hot water circulation pump, but the water pipes do not run through the electric room and there have been no leaks.

So is it a matter of water induced erosion caused by the non-stop circulation of water, or electrolysis that is etching/eroding the pipes?

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#2

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Malcolm,

I'm going to assume that the el's you're talking about are "wrought" rather that cast copper or brass. It is more likely that the water had a ph on the acid side. El's and other wrought fittings are of a thinner gage ("M" rather than "L") and are therefore more likely to show failure from errosian whether chemical or physical. If your friend has "hard" water, the constant flow is more likely to be abrading the copper many times faster than in systems that have flow for a total of an hour or so per day. The first place such damage will show up is in the thin elbows.

As far as that induced voltage is concerned, you may have weak fields in play but I rather doubt they are the cause of your issue. There is an electromag water softening "system" that clamps on the pipes and plugs into the wall to create a pretty strong field. Its purpose is said to lock dissolved minerals in the water, and has been claimed to reduce internal corrosion in the pipes. My FIL, a retired master plumber and PA state engineer, has such a system installed in his home. His pipes are not dissolving.

I would check you friend's system for sediment and PH; both issues are easy to adjust. I'd also suggest you start replacing those thin elbows with cast copper or brass fittings.

MM

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#3

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

John McGaw

>I would first suspect that the problem is turbulence at the ells aggravating the normal day-to-day corrosion that copper pipes suffer.

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#4

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Jim Dillon

>Malcom,

I agree with Mark on this one regarding the importance of water pH, especially if you are on well water. If the water is on the acidic side, over time the copper pipe can erode until one starts to get pinhole leaks. Despite the advertisement, copper may not last forever under these conditions If you are on well water and have a lot of oak trees nearby, the pH of the local groundwater might be on the acidic side and causing the problem. On the other hand, if you are not on well water, even "city water" can have problems as the Washington DC area found out 5 years or so ago when residents had a massive outbreak of pinhole leaks in their copper pipes. I'm not sure if they ever found out what was causing the problem except I did have to replace all the copper pipes in a rental property - not an inexpensive undertaking. If I remember right, outbreaks of pinhole leaks in copper in various regions of the conuntry have been reported. My own house is on well water and I'm surrounded by oak trees 8-(. After 35 years, the copper pipes are paper thin. Last year, I finally got a water conditioner - something I should have done decades ago. And now the water is drinkable for the first time and, hopefully, I've minimized any further corrosion. Regarding your eddy current theories, I think that is a stretch; I would check water pH first.

Jim

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#5

Malcolm, not Malcom. Sorry!

Jim Dillon

>

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#6

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Barry Irby

>I tend to agree with the others.

I would suspect the chemistry of your water. It may also be that the plumber used fittings that were thinner than the pipe (type M rather than type L) and it may be that the constant circulation has and effect. Perhaps there is an erosion factor or that whatever the chemicals in the water are being "exposed" or presented to the metal more than they would be if the water lay still in the pipes.

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#7

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes. *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Malcolm,

Here is a link to what is going on in the Washington DC area regarding pinhole leaks in copper pipe. I glanced over portions of the report and found it to be very interesting. In a nutshell, lots of possible causes, but very difficult to "pinpoint" (sorry, couldn't resist 8-)) the problem. The only solution, it seems, is to replace the pipe. As an aside, I seem to remeberHope this helps.


Pinhole Leaks in Copper Pipe

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#8

Darn, pressed the wrong button too soon!

Jim Dillon

>As I was saying, I seem to remember some class-action law suits going on at the time in some regions of the country regarding the alleged premature failure of new copper pipe. So this might encourage "finger-pointing" to some extent. In the Washington DC area, IIRC there was a change in city water chemistry prior to the leaks that some feel might have played a role in alteration (or prevention of) the inert coating on the inside of the pipe. Anyway, hope this helps. Will try to press the right button this time 8-).

Jim

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#9

Only if a lot of iron in the water :^)

mdclor

>

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#10

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I expect you will find that either the water is "acid" or if alkaline it may be extremely hard and contain lime particles that have separated out of the water. Acid water is kind of rare but I had one case in northern Indiana where the water was so acid it dissolved the iron drill casing and a new well had to be drilled about every 3 years. I had the water analyzed by Calgon's water laboratory. The results indicated the (100+ foot deep) wells were in a vein left by the last ice age where trees were decaying. The other possible problem is that particles of lime are causing mechanical erosion where turbulence in the lines occur - as the elbows are obviously one of these areas they would be one of the first areas to erode and fail. Thicker elbows or a different pipe/fitting material may be required to eliminate the problem. I personally would not believe that electrolysis could cause the problem. If electrolysis were an issue the entire piping system would be equally affected as both copper and hard water are excellent conductors. My experience: Mfg Engineer, Licensed Contractor Plumber, trained in Century Bruning water softener course (owned by Calgon corp)

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#11

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

Jerry Nicholson

>When I had my previous home built (1961) I specified copper for DWV. Over the 38+ years I lived in that house I had many problems with failure at soldered joints in the drain pipes and have always suspected that the plumber left too much acid flux on the joint. Other than some leaks early on due to poor soldering, I had no problem with the water pipes. My in-laws house, built shortly after mine by the same contractor, also had copper DWV pipes and there were no joint failures up to the time we sold the house in 2004. Could have been a different plumber.

I fixed the joint failures in my DWV pipes with plumbers epoxy and electrical tape.

Jerry

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#12

Thanks guys! moore info:

Malcolm Timbers

>The water is supplied by the city (if you can count a town of 3,000 souls a city). From what they tell me at the local building supply store, the problem is not the water because nobody else in town is coming in with the problem. This is a copper mining town along a main highway. Therre are places in the hills where the dirt is green with copper ore. There are no fish in the river, not because of the mining but because everything is stained with copper sulfate and mineral other oxides. There is/was also gold and silver mining in the area and lost of exploration activity in the area.

I have replaced a section fo the waterpipe in the crawl space with PEX that also eliminated a whole bunch of elbows because the plastic pipe can be snaked around obsticals. I might try to use the epoxie trick n one elbow that is difficult to work on.

The building is only about 12 or 13 years old. The elbows are thin ones as nothing else is available in this town except for those compression-like plastic ones. It is a long drive to any town of any size from here.

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#13

Re: Thanks guys! moore info:

Jim Dillon

>Malcolm,

Sounds like you are on the right track with replacement of the copper pipe. Are you located in Arizona, specifically in the Southeastern Arizona area?? Just curious, as I lived there for several years and know that copper mines are common in that neck of the woods. Thanks also for getting back to us with your approach to solving the problem.

Jim

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#14

A question for Larry

Barry Irby

>Sorry about hijacking the thread, but it's semi related.

Larry, I have heard that the problem of galvanic corrosion (where different metals contact each other) could be reduced or cured by having an excellent (electrical)ground on the pipes. (The story was that in every case where galvanic corrosion was severe, there was a poor ground or no ground.)

What do you think?

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#15

Re: Thanks guys! moore info:

Malcolm Timbers in British Columbia

>I live in British Columbia near Princeton, a mining and logging town. There are two mineral laden rivers that converge on the other side of town. I live on a ridge between ther two rivers.

The problem with replacing all the copper with PEX is that the circulation pump is supported by the copper pipe and the plastic version won't support the weight of the pump. I could use hangers on the pump, but I don't want to change things too much since I am not a plumber and this is a rather complicated system.

I don't like the way they plumed the pump. Too many turns. I would raise the line up above the swing of a door and run a straight section with the pump near the ceiling. But I am afraid I'd be asking for trouble. Anyway a real plumber should be working on it. I got roped into fixing the leak when a plumber wasn't available. But when the plumber came around after I had things torn apart, he was angry and left thinking that I couldn't fix it myself. But I have a professional tourch and know how to solder a good joint.

Re: ?Electromagnetism and copper water pipes.

#16

Re: A question for Larry

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I really don't know Barry. I understand the thought logic behind this theory but can't say whether it would prevent damage or not. I do know that when aluminum roofing panels became popular (many years ago), a lot of people used them as skirts for house trailers. All - regardless of grounding or not - in a year or so were corroded to above the ground level. The galvanic action of dissimilar materials is due to the two materials becoming plates in a battery. If moisture is present a voltage is going to be generated between them. The voltage causes migration of material just like a plating bath. I'm not sure (though I have doubts) that any type of earth ground could totally prevent this action. Zinc is often used as it becomes a sacrificial "plate" or anode - as it releases its material easier the other material remains complete.