>I recently finished designing some radiator covers for a friend of mine, and they like the design. They want to use slats with spaces for the front of the cover. I designed a piece with side legs that have upper and lower rails mortised into the legs. Then, I'll mortise into the top/bottom of the rails to accept a tenon from the slats. I want the slats to sit flush with the front, and I want to use a half inch thick slat. So, I went with a quarter inch thick tenon, 1 inch wide, 1/2 inch tall on each end of the slat. Then I'll cut a matching mortise at each place in the rails the slats will go. So, I think that the small, thin tenon on the slats, and the mortises with only a 1/4 inch wall will be enough, since this isn't an abused piece. Oh, and the wood we're using is poplar (it'll get painted).
>Best expect a LOT of movement, Stephen. When the heat comes on, your wood's going to have a summer EMC, but the heat will drive out the moisture to oven dry in short order. Any coating will either let the vapor through or split. You can expect shrinkage and lots of stress on those glue joints.
Haven't seen many wood radiator covers, most are metal.
>There were radiator covers on one of the TOH/ATOH shows a recent while back, and they made them from a composite, possibly MDF. Actually, Tom Silva made them. I think the composite dealt with the movement issues pretty well.
Being in California, in forced air country, radiators are but a theoretical concern to us...
>I meant to add, on the strength issue, that everything that is at sitting height will, under certain circumstances, become used as a chair, at one time or another. This needs to be considered in the design phase.
>Leave shoulders on your slat tenons, the one inch wide mortise is the weak link and narrowing it to 5/8" or 3/4" would beef it up. Since the tenon is long grain it's plenty strong, it's the cross grain strength of the mortise that's in question. 1/2" should be plenty of depth as long as the slats aren't too long, say over 20" or so.
>The slats are 3" wide by 11" long (or tall, as they are oriented). I'm expecting to leave about a half inch or more shoulder around the tenon on all slats (they are facing curves, so some are narrower at the top). I also planned to leave the mortise a little wide so they could move around.
>The slats won't be glued in, they'll just be captured in the mortises. I've planned for at least a 16th of an inch movement room in the mortise, maybe I'll add a little more. With the exception of the top, most of the parts on this project are pretty small, so wood movement should be kept to a minimum. The top I'll attach so it can float, either figure 8 hooks or button blocks.
The only real glue joints will be where the rails are tenoned into the legs, and I'm still tossing around the idea of drawboring them. A joint like that never lets go, and it's good for wood movement.
>Ah, 1 1/2 inch square legs, the top rail is 3/4" thick by 30" long, and the top will be 3/4" thick. It's only about 22" deep, so I expect the top to easily handle being a seat.
>No glue is good glue in this instance, and you've planned well for movement. I still think you're likely to have "joint issues" (even with drawbores) because your tenons will shrink in the mortices whose axis of shrink will be different. The result "may" be that what fits tight and stable when just finished will become a bit wobbly in use. Wish I had a concrete suggestion to cure, but I may also be a bit over cautious.
The covers I've seen focus on maximizing convection around and through the radiator. Your drawing has very little space between those slats for air to circulate the heat. Your piece is going to get very hot and I think you'll have trouble keeping paint or even a resin finish on the wood. If your cover gets as hot as the radiator, you kind of defeat the purpose of the cover, no?
3 suggestions: 1. Widen your air gaps for more flow. 2. Use the same treatment on the ends for cross-convection. 3. Leave the back (against the wall?) as open as possible, ie. do not make it a cabinet back with a solid sheet; a pair of stretchers would be enough to hold the ends together.
The curved slats do translate to a shimmering heat effect. Very appropriate for the use.
>I was worried about going much thinner on the slats. The gaps between them is 3/4". I may play with the size and see if I can get some more openings. I also considered putting some holes in the slats, perhaps in the middles of the wide sections to allow even more air passage.
The bunch of cover designs I looked at generall had the sides solid, since they want to encourage heat out the front. The back is open - it's like a 3 sided box. There is very little room behind the radiators so I didn't plan for a back rail. I was sure to leave room open at the bottom to encourage the passage of air up through the cover.
Thanks for the input, though. This is one of my first projects of my own design, so I figure it'll be a learning experience. I'll take a look at the joints of the rails into the legs and see if I can plan any more for wood movement.
>These radiators really only get "warm". Even at full temp you can touch them with no fear of a burn. That's why i wasn't super worried about dealing with heat problems.
>So is this a "hot water" system rather than "steam?" That DO make a difference. Hot water at 120-140 is way different than steam at 212-240. Just my assumption that what you had was the old style steam radiator that's about 3' high by 10" deep and made in sections.
>Hey, new looks at things are always good. I'm actually checking with my friend to make sure my memory was correct. I believe he has the hot water style. None are more than 22" high and they range from 3 feet to 6 feet in length depending on where they are. I've watched a bunch of games over at his place and I don't recall ever worrying about the radiators. They usually have books and things laying on them. I figure it's always good to double check.
Hey, my day job is in IT and I've been muted on a long conference call this afternoon. I gotta do something to pass the time.
>...I had a couple thoughts for you. One is that for the sake of sanity, I would probably just run a 1/4" groove in your rails and put full-width tongues on the ends of your slats. I can't imagine that you need mortises and tenons. If you're worried about deflection in the center when somebody sits on this thing, glue a floating tenon into the center slat. Mark where the slats will go, and then fill the spaces in the grooves between them with bits of wood prior to assembly. You might want to cut small shoulders (no more than 1/4") at the sides of each slat so that gaps won't be revealed if/when they shrink. The (nearly) full length tongues have an added advantage in that they will keep the slats flat; narrow tenons will not support the edges of the slats, and unless you're using quartersawn wood, you're going to see some cupping. And while I'm on the cupping theme, it would be a good idea to paint the inside faces of the slats as well to keep the moisture transfer as balanced as possible.
On another note, I think your top rails look rather wide for the proportions of the design. Structurally, I don't think you need this kind of width either. Narrower rails will also move less across their width with the seasons, so you will minimize the gaps that will inevitably open at the top and at the shoulders of the slats. If you want to really minimize the gaps at the shoulders, peg the m&t joints where the rails join the legs, and locate the pegs close to the slat side of the rail so the rails will expand and contract at the top and bottom.
I'd also consider adding some kind of rail under the top on the back of the assembly. It will tie the sides together and provide a bit of deflection resistance for the top, not that you should need it. But, you never know when 300-lb Uncle Festus is going to stand on this cover to adjust the draperies or something. :-)
>Thanks Ellis, those are good suggestions. I'm currently doing some re-design, so I can work with these ideas. Right now I'm working on cutting some holes in the slats to allow more heat to pass through. I like your idea of just cutting a 1/4" groove in the rails to hold the slats, and then glueing filler bits in place. I can do that way faster than making individual mortise and tenons.
I'll play with the rail sizes a bit and see how it looks. I do expect these to be sat on from time to time, so I want to make sure they are strong enough. I'll have to double check my measurements to see if I can put a rear rail on. There is very little room behind these radiators, maybe only an inch or so, and there is a window sill a mere inch or two above them, so I won't have much room to maneuver it into place. I need to go over and visit my buddy anyway, so I can re-measure.
Thanks for the feedback. I'll post some new pics when I finish the re-design.