Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)
Alan Young
>Hi friends,
In December of 2007 I filed some papers to apply for a re-finance on my mortgage. I faxed papers to a company that I believed to be reputable company in the greater Detroit area. As part of my application process the mortgage company said they would pay up front to have the home appraised. The home was appraised before the first of the year, and in fact the appraiser was paid by the mortgage company.
Just before the first of the year, I received a Sears Card and a Target Card in the mail. I didn't think much about either card at the time and just set them aside in a stack of papers. Time marched on and the mortgage company began processing my application. In the mean time about the second week of January, I received a bill from Sears for $2500.00 -The bill contained two items at approx $1200.00 and cash out for $40.00. At this point I realized my identity had been compromised. I immediately called Sears and Target and a explained that I had not opened the accounts. I also have been pursuing the appropriate actions with the three major credit bureaus and have put out a fraud alert.
I informed the mortgage company that my identity had been compromised and that as they continued to process my application they would note a fraud alert had been placed on my records. In further investigation I found that the cards were each opened on December 17 in the Dearborn Mich area. The information I faxed to the mortgage company was sent on December 12. In conversations with the mortgage company I was given verbal assurances that the identity compromise was purely coincidental to my application with their company and that the fax machines were not anywhere in public view and in fact were sent to an individual computer.
I was willing to believe this and in fact still do-generally. Except I received instructions from one individual at the company on what to send- W-2's pay stubs etc and to what fax no. I followed these instructions as given. I have now found out that this person is "no longer with the company".
So here's the situation. I have no "proof" that my identity was compromised by anyone at the mortgage company. But circumstantial evidence shows I sent detailed information on December 12th to their company and on December 17 unauthorized accounts were opened in my name at local Sears and Target stores. The individual that gave me instructions is no longer with the company. This person may have legitimate reasons for being gone and the company is not a "fly-by-night" operation in some dark alley. Still I am reluctant to finish off the loan process with them. I have signed no papers but did give them a verbal go ahead to process the application with the appraisal cost being absorbed at closing.My question finally is this. Am I morally or ethically obligated to follow through with this company considering they did pay for the appraisal?
Thanks for your thoughts.
Alan



