Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

Posts

Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#1

Alan Young

Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

Alan Young

>Hi friends,

In December of 2007 I filed some papers to apply for a re-finance on my mortgage. I faxed papers to a company that I believed to be reputable company in the greater Detroit area. As part of my application process the mortgage company said they would pay up front to have the home appraised. The home was appraised before the first of the year, and in fact the appraiser was paid by the mortgage company.

Just before the first of the year, I received a Sears Card and a Target Card in the mail. I didn't think much about either card at the time and just set them aside in a stack of papers. Time marched on and the mortgage company began processing my application. In the mean time about the second week of January, I received a bill from Sears for $2500.00 -The bill contained two items at approx $1200.00 and cash out for $40.00. At this point I realized my identity had been compromised. I immediately called Sears and Target and a explained that I had not opened the accounts. I also have been pursuing the appropriate actions with the three major credit bureaus and have put out a fraud alert.

I informed the mortgage company that my identity had been compromised and that as they continued to process my application they would note a fraud alert had been placed on my records. In further investigation I found that the cards were each opened on December 17 in the Dearborn Mich area. The information I faxed to the mortgage company was sent on December 12. In conversations with the mortgage company I was given verbal assurances that the identity compromise was purely coincidental to my application with their company and that the fax machines were not anywhere in public view and in fact were sent to an individual computer.

I was willing to believe this and in fact still do-generally. Except I received instructions from one individual at the company on what to send- W-2's pay stubs etc and to what fax no. I followed these instructions as given. I have now found out that this person is "no longer with the company".

So here's the situation. I have no "proof" that my identity was compromised by anyone at the mortgage company. But circumstantial evidence shows I sent detailed information on December 12th to their company and on December 17 unauthorized accounts were opened in my name at local Sears and Target stores. The individual that gave me instructions is no longer with the company. This person may have legitimate reasons for being gone and the company is not a "fly-by-night" operation in some dark alley. Still I am reluctant to finish off the loan process with them. I have signed no papers but did give them a verbal go ahead to process the application with the appraisal cost being absorbed at closing.My question finally is this. Am I morally or ethically obligated to follow through with this company considering they did pay for the appraisal?

Thanks for your thoughts.

Alan

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#2

JL

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

JL

>Sorry to hear about your situation.

You gave your verbal acceptance of the mortgage refinancing. I would say you are somewhat obligated.

If the former employee was responsible or someone at the company was culpable for the identity theft, they should pay for credit monitoring and rectifying that situation.

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#3

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Alan,

That really stinks! ID theft is a scary thing.

I'm no expert but I'd try to get out of it. You might lose some fees or something but maybe it's worth it.

Meanwhile, the rates are likely to go down a little more and maybe, if you can break free of that lender, you can find a better deal now anyway?

Tom

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#4

Here's an idea

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>You may have done this already, but I would talk to the mortgage company, and tell them your concern, and that you need more information about the person who left. I'm sure they won't give you any, but tell them you believe there is the possiblity of a breach in security and this person may be involved. Also tell them that you are going to contact the appropriate authorites (FBI?) about this. Don't threaten them with this, but make it clear that a formal investigation needs to be done.

And then contact someone (start with the police, but you'll likely need to go hirer up with that). I have worked with enough people to know that fraud is a real present issue, and there are police units, and bank units that would like to.... need to... hear your information.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#5

Re: Here's an idea

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I like that idea. Might serve as leverage to get out of it too.

Tom

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#6

Guido's # is: 1-800-KNEEMAN. Good luck.

Art Silva

>

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#7

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

Stuart Johnson

>I think I would look at this in a slightly different manner.

You said the company isn't a 'fly-by-night' company. By that I take it you mean as a company they are reputable. If that is so, then they might have had a rotten apple that they have fired. If that is so I doubt if they will tell you because of potential law suites. Heck, if you can't tell someone calling for a reference that someone was fired because they were a crummy worker what can you expect if someone asks for information on why they aren't there if they were fired for suspicion of I.D. theft.

If you don't feel you can do business with the company then by all means talk to someone with real authority and either be re-assured or cancel the deal. If they try to charge you a fee either fight it or pay it whichever is in your best interest. I don't think ethics or morality comes into play in this case.

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#8

My Suggestion

ScottS

>Alan, I can't really tell you whether you're morally or ethically obligated to follow through with the re-financing. Legally, you may have had a verbal agreement with the mortgage company. If it came to them proving that in a court of law, they might find it difficult to do so. My lawyer friends are always fond of telling me: if you expect to prove it in court, you'd better have it on paper!

It sounds like you're on the fence about doing business with the company, and I do think you have a right to be concerned. I'll suggest that you give them the opportunity to earn your business back. Explain your concerns to them and the reasons behind them, then ask for a signed (preferably by a VP) letter from their Human Resources department stating that the employee in question was not terminated for mis-use of customer information. Explain that you don't need to know exactly why the person is no longer at the company, merely that you want insurance that it was not because he was involved in identity theft. For all you know, the employee may have quit to take a better job or been fired for something completely unrelated to identity theft (e.g. being late to work, making long-distance calls on company phones, etc). It would think that this letter shouldn't contain more than 3-5 sentences, nor take more than 5-10 minutes to generate. If they truly want your business, I would think it should be simple for them to comply with this request...

At the same time, it wouldn't be a bad idea to talk to police in Detroit or Dearborn about the case. I wouldn't accuse anyone of anything, but I would mention the surprising coincidence: documents FAXed, the employee who received them suddenly unavailable, etc. Maybe they'll follow-up?

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#9

Alan Young

Thanks Art, I called that number

Alan Young

>and got a message.



Aay! yousa reeched da office uh" Guido,Bashum and Ow!"

Yous a leavea us a message and we'll leavea dem guys ina betta place.

Ifn ya knows whata mean...."

They seemed friendly and helpful.

Alan

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#10

Re: Thanks Art, I called that number

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Nothing gets the point across better than a good old fashioned "tune up". ;-)

Tom

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#11

Re: Police don't care, call the DA direct

Brian in Brighton

>I had that $830 stolen by check washing and the Denver PD sent me a letter stating that they don't have the time to deal with it. Too bad for me if the bank and HD never pay up.

I would go to the DA's office or call the state AG and ask about the fraud unit. Tell them you want to physically visit and sit down with them, not just some crap over the phone. Explain the situation, offer to let them have copies of any papers. DO NOT tell the mortgage company, but ask the DA or AG what to do. They might already be under investigation or involved in a suit that you can become part of. The mortgage company will lie thru their teeth to protect themselves. Only the AG or DA can get direct access to the personelle file.

Again, and I can't state this loud enough. THE POLICE DON'T CARE. If it isn't something that harmed anyone and they can't get any money from someone (as the criminals rarely have money) they could care less. Your case will be assigned a number and filed away, never to be looked at again. Just like my several cases involving theft over the last 20 years.

Brian in Brighton.

Best case is to kill all the bums. Hooked on Meth so bad that you want to steal from people? You need to die. I think I caught the officer offguard when I told him I would like to find the guy, beat him to death with a crowbar and burn his remains in front of his family. :-)

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#12

Re: Here's an idea

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>A couple years ago I had my credit card number stolen. It was a credit card I never used, but pulled out by mistake when I got some gas. I plugged it into the fuel pump at a gas station near my old office that I never used, but for some reason did that day. My next bill arrived with a bunch of stuff on it (about $4K worth). Mostly prepaid long distance cards, all purchased within hours of me buying gas. Of course I called the credit card company. They were very interested in getting a new card in my hands ASAP. Hey, good customer service ... great. I did have to talk to their security office and file a report with lots of details of the whens and hows.

Then I called the police station nearest to the gas station, asked for the fraud unit, and told them my story of the first use of the card in 2 years and suddenly $4K. They took the info and gave me a case number for my credit card company. Uhhh, I already got done with my credit card company and they didn't need a case number. Oh ... moment of silence ... OK. Thanks for the report.

o I followed up with the CC security office a week later. They didn't quite say it, but I got the suspicion that $4K wasn't enough to bother with. So, I called the police. They didn't quite say it, but I got the suspicion that a card number theft is nothing but a case number for the CC company.

I think it should've been a pretty easy to solve case. There's only so many people that should be able to see the numbers that come out of that gas pump within hours of the transaction. Combine that with the address that the long distance cards were shipped to (I called, but the place wouldn't give it to me) and you got someone. So much for anyone needing to know who a credit card thief is. As long as the CC company gets a card back in my hand asap so I can start spending more money, all is good.

Jay

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#13

Re: Here's an idea

Jim Dillon

>Jay,

Did you see that worrisome (to me at least) 60 minutes episode several months ago where credit card info is "captured" by someone sitting in a car near where the card is swiped? Apparently, some stores (gas stations? liquor stores?) do not encrypt the info when it is transmitted through the ether. It just takes someone with a laptop computer, the right receiver and software to capture your credit card info. They then sell it or use it.

I've had the same credit card for 35 years with virtually no problems. But in the past 3 months I've had to cancel the card twice because of fradulant use. The second episode was for over $7000 attributed to four PayPal Online Services transactions. I seldom use PayPal for anything except my monthly contribution to WoodCentral. Now here is the strange part. I called PayPal and they said they had NO record of these fradulent transactions! I guess (hope) my credit card company and PayPal are working it out. Food for thought in this digital world. Thanks for posting your story and I hope things work out.

Jim

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#14

Partly right

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Whle I must agree with you, the police departments in certain cities and counties aren't that interested, or more likely unable to deal with this sort of thing, but there are some counties here at least that have special task forces dedicated to fraud. It's these groups that are very eager to hear about these things. Around here it varies greatly from county to county from what I've seen.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#15

I see you haven't lost your sense of humor.

Art Silva

>

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#16

Have you contacted the credit bureaus? *LINK*

Derek

>Alan,

If you have not done so, you should immediately contact all 3 major credit bureaus and find out what your options are. You have some. You can require all credit inquiries to be approved by you in writing, for example (my memory is a bit vague on the details though).

You also need to find out if any other credit has been taken out in your name and stop it.

Act fast!


http://www.experian.com/identity_fraud/fraud_prevention.html

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#17

Alan Young

War on several Fronts

Alan Young

>Thanks Derek,

Yes I have contacted the Credit Bureaus. I have also been in contact with the two department stores and two police departments.

My concern on this front is the ability to remove myself from the current lenders realm without incurring any further fees or liabilities. That is still in question.

Since yesterdays post I have received some good legal council that will hopefully help resolve my obligations to the current lender.

Alan

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#18

Alan Young

My dear departed mother always said

Alan Young

>"Don't Cry over spilled milk."

I suspect she'd say

"even when someone else spills it."

Alan

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#19

Some thoughts

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>You were expressing concern about continuing the principal transaction. My feeling (absolutely unsupported by any empirical weight) is that you owe this mortgage company nothing. I would not continue the transaction with them regardless of why the particular employee is no longer there. If they want to force an issue of fees, I'd refuse and make them prove that the employee had nothing to do with it. That would be hard, if not impossible, but they must have some kind of indemnification against just that sort of circumstance. I don't see how you could interpret the credit card actions any other way, and so far as I'm concerned, the mortgage company is tainted by the poisonous apple, regardless of whether he's still there. They're going to have to die by the sword, in my opinion. I wouldn't let them even remotely suggest that you owe them anything, including continued custom. Now, if they're the only/best game in town, you might have to swallow some angst. However, morally and ethically (and probably legally), I think you are on firm ground walking away from the whole enterprise.

Rod

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#20

Re: War on several Fronts

Mike L, Orange County, CA

>Alan,

You probably already plan to do this but keep documentation of everything (including police reports) because this sort of thing can haunt you for a long time. DAMHIKT. Good luck.

Mike

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#21

Re: War on several Fronts

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>"this sort of thing can haunt you for a long time. DAMHIKT."

Amen, brother. Amen.

Re: Totally OT Identity Theft Situation & ?(LONG)

#22

My mother's favorite, and now mine, ..............

Art Silva

>"It costs so little extra to go first class, and it does wonders for your EGO!"