>I would like to put some hardwood flooring into a family room. Not sure what type or thickness, engineered or solid etc.
BUT the subfloor in the house is T&G OSB 19/32" thick.
I have read several minimum sub floor specs for different manufacturers that says the subfloor needs to be 23/32" thick.
How critical is this? I really hate the idea of of having to add another 1/2" underlay on top of the OSB just because I am 1/8 of an inch out. It's not the install of it but the raising of the floor and differing levels it will create that is concerning.
The other point is that the H/W flooring and the joists would be perpendicular to each other for this install which would allow for lots of nailing directly into a joist versus just the OSB sub floor if that helps
Anybody have Hardwood floor expeprience and some comments on how critical that missing 1/8 of an inch is, or if there is a product that is maybe better suited for a thinner sub floor short of the click togther faux flooring
>I would add at least a 1/4" launa to that subfloor. Myself I would glue it down then screw it or staple. I would also go across the subfloor you have now, not in line with it. 19/32" is just over 1/2" and that is by no means a strong subfloor, at least in my mind. Now to the rest of the question I will refer to the experts.
>The hardwood flooring industry resisted plywood when it came out, preferring the older diagonal board sheeting. They had to acquiesce and permit plywood. Then they resisted OSB. I think their principle complaint was that it lacked nail holding ability. It also has slightly different expansion characteristics and may cause "panelization" or "Rafting" but that is principle in new construction.
I would be reluctant to install a thin layer like luan because I would be afraid it would simple act like a "puffy" layer and not contribute much. It would be better if you glued it well and rolled it well.
I think the preferred nailing schedule is to NOT nail into the joists. This has to do with the phenomenon known as a "nail pop". (Nails driven into lumber tend to back out when the lumber cycles through changes in moisture contend and shrinks and swells.) The Durall industry reduced or solved this problem with shorter ring shanked nails or screws. The roofing industry solved it by driving the nails all the way through the sheeting. (If the point is not buried in the wood, it can't get the grip on it necessary to "squirt" it back out.)
So, if you nail all the way through the subfloor but not into the joists, you have a better chance of not having nail pops or nails backing out causing the floor to be loose and squeaky.
I installed 3/4" thick 2 1/4" hardwood over 19/32" T & G plywood. I used a stapler that I adapted to the project. It shoots the heavier gauge 2 1/2" long half inch crown staples. I ground the "snoot" on it down so that it would nest right in the inside corner of the tongue. I used a lot of staples. The flooring has been down for more than ten years, not a squeak.
My advice to you would be to look up the installation guide on the "National Oak Flooring Manufacturers Association" (NOFMA) web site and follow it carefully. I might ignore the part about the thickness except that I would increase the number of nails bay about 25%. If it calls for a nail or staple every 10", drive one every 7 or 8". I would rent a air powered stapler made for this purpose. The hand driven nailers scare me, I have the impression I am going to drive my kneecap down to my ankle). Also, buy the flooring in advance and store it in the space for two or three weeks to let it acclimate. (DON'T skip this step). I might also consider gluing it with excellent glue like some of those by BF Goodrich (PL400?). I would also try to buy longer lengths of flooring so that the pieces will bear across several joists and pay close attention to "breaking" the joints.
>When we laid our floors, we had a similiar issue. Since we had carpet, our subfloor had OSB. I have read that OSB cracks when driven for floors and will eventually sqeak. So, we pulled up the OSB and laid a thicker layer of ply. Ended up raising the floor by 3/4", but then we also later installed tile in the kitchen, so the floors are now even.
Floors also have to expand/contract, so I would personally not glue. If you want to make sure (as least as much as possible) that you won't have squeaks later, I would get rid of the OSB and put plywood up to the minimum. IMHO.
>Mark, I've been somewhat involved in the istallation of hardwood floors over 50 years. Back then we hand nailed with 8 penny cut nails into the 16" on center floor joists with 1/2" plywood subfloor. With the development of power floor nailers, both spring activated and air driven, the custom is to nail 8" oc and 3" from end of each board since these power nails don't pass through the subfloor enough to get a good bite into the joist. Sub floor should be minimum of 1/2" plywood or 5/8" particle board. The one thing I didn't see mentioned in the above posts is to use a layer of 15# felt or rosin paper between the subfloor and the hardwood. This should always be done to prevent squeeky floors. Good luck, George
>5/8 or 19/32 is ok for 3/4 nail down hardwoods. Nothing to worry about with regards to thickness. The important thing with OSB is to make sure it's sound. Newer OSB products like Advantech work very well with wood floors. Some of the older stuff had a tendency to delaminate thereby earning it the name of SOB board. I doubt I need to expand on that point.
You don't really need to worry about the joists as a 2" nail or staple only shows about 1/2" of length through 5/8 subfloor. That's not enough to matter when it comes to gripping a joist. Do use some felt or rosin paper to keep the squeaks at bay. DEFINITELY run the floors perpendicular to the joists or you will develop waves in the floor. With regards to the thinner engineered or solid products, there are different nailing requirements and such that can occur when using those kinds of things. Just need to read up on the particular product and what they recommend so you can cover thine buttocks with regards to warranty issues.
Hope some of this mindless drivel helps you out.
Andy Halterman
Not really a floor guy but I play one on WoodCentral in Henderson-Vegas, NC�