Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT: Home Insulation

Posts

OT: Home Insulation

#1

OT: Home Insulation

David Hay @ Denver

>We're looking to upgrade the insulation in our home and we're having a hard time finding good information on what materials to use and how much it might cost. I'm hoping someone here can point me towards some helpful information.

I've read about some kind of slow rise foam insulation, but all I've found is the do-it-yourself kits which seem kinda pricey. Blown in cellulose sounds like an option, but it's unclear whether it's better/worse than fiberglass? How does it compare to the foam?

Are there any good sites out on the 'net that might help us calculate the cost of reinsulating our home (we've got some fiberglass bats already) both walls and the attic?

Thanks!

David

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#2

Re: OT: Home Insulation

Kneale Brownson enjoying snow in N. MI

>Your best bet is to consult local materials suppliers. You can DIY for either blown in cellulose or glass batts (provided the wall spaces and ceiling area are accessible). Most suppliers of cellulose products will rent you the blower equipment, so you just have to poke the holes. Done correctly, cellulose will insulate just fine. You can judge from pricing your local suppliers provide which method best suits your budget. Don't forget to check with local installers. They may make it worth having them do the work, especially with the current state of the construction industry.

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#3

Re: The $.05 answer

Philip

>Web site: Owens-Corning Site is great for info on various sizes and R values for fiberglass batt insulation (no prices though)

You will get most bang for your buck by concentrating your efforts in the attic first (where you will typically have the most heat loss).

Don't forget air leakage: recessed cans and other penetrations fromm the heated to unheated spaces can significantly contribute to heat loss.

I added fiberglass batts to my attic this past year, and it was not too bad a job (more work getting the supplies up into the attic than it was actually installing them).

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#4

Re: OT: Home Insulation

Geoff (in Madison)

>Also check out www.biobased.net They produce open and closed cell spray-in-place foam insulation. We had open-celled installed in the spring and it has made a huge difference. The foam really excels when there is limited attic space (or you want to insulate the underside of the roof deck and finish off attic space). We have vaulted ceilings in 50% of our house (2X6 framing) with recessed lights.

It has sealed the house so well that our whole house humidifier hasn't turned on all winter.

It is pricier than cellulose or fiberglass, but works GREAT.

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#5

Fiberglass in rolls...

Joe Pack

>About 5 years ago I added 6" of fiberglass on top of the 14" (supposedly 18" when it was installed 25 years ago) of blown cellulose in our attic. I forget the exact name, but it was an "upgrade" product that I bought at Home Depot. It was a bit more expensive than regular bats, but worth every dime. Not the typical pink, scratchy fiberglass, but a softer, almost non-irritating white product encased in a breathable pink "plastic" sheath. Think "bag of cotton candy." It was a breeze to pass it up the attic stairway, carry it to the position necessary and cut open the roll there. Standing on the center 4' walkway I thought to install when I built the house, we used a painter's extension handle to unroll the product between the trusses and to adjust the "tubes." It took less than 2 hours to install a new 6" layer in a 60x32 attic.

It would have taken less if I had stayed out of my son's way and let him do it by himself. Fat boys with bad backs don't belong in attics.

If you do put in additional insulation, be sure to keep the eaves open. No matter what kind of insulation you use, you need to keep the eaves open to insure air movement.

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#6

Re: Fiberglass in rolls...

richard jones

>Joe,

That plastic sheath is not supposed to stay exposed, unless it has the proper flame spread/smoke development numbers. That particular insulation is made for spots where the poly film/wrap will be covered, usually by drywall. Some of it is also made to be removeable after installation, not sure which you got.............

rich

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#7

further to above......

Richard Jones

>excerpt from J-M re: poly insulation wrap:

"In addition, ComfortTherm is the only encapsulated insulation earning the UL mark. By achieving a fire safety rating of 25/50, ComfortTherm can be left exposed if local building codes allow. Traditional kraft-faced insulation is flammable and cannot be treated in this manner. "

So the J-M product appears OK with regards to leaving the poly exposed. Flame spread/smoke development #'s along with the UL listing should be visible on the poly.

rich

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#8

Re: OT: Home Insulation LONG

Barry Irby

>I do not know of such a web site. There may be one out there, but I don't know of a general purpose one not sponsored by a manufacturer of some product and therefore suspect. On second thought, you might try going to the HGTV site and poke around. They have a Pro section that has videos on "Best Practices". Might find something there. (They send me E-mails about once a week. I allow them to continue because as a Home Inspector, they occasionally hit on something I want to know more about.)

Check with your local utility company about he recommended insulation levels in your area. Are You in Denver, Colorado? I would assume you would want at least and R-38 in the ceiling or higher.

Generally, the first place to start looking is the attic. If you have access to the top side of the insulation and no space constraints, its the easiest place to add insulation. Since the warmest air in your house rest against the ceiling, the heat loss through the ceiling is often the most significant. So If you can, increase it to Whatever the recommended amount in your area is, or higher. Keep the vents open to allow for attic ventilation.

Do not crush or compress the insulation. It's the air in it that does the work and the fibers or cells just hold the air still. The "loft" or fluff should be "just right". 6" batts compressed to 3 1/2" have less insulation factor than properly installed 3 1/2" batts.

Under the floor is pretty far down the list, but is almost as easy as the attic. (If you have a crawl space). You should have at least an R-19 there. This is a place the mathematics don't exactly work out. The attic Amy get very cold, maybe Zero, But the crawl space does not. So, the math says that if there is forty five in the crawl and 70 in the house, there will be less heat loss that if the ceiling is as 70 and the attic at zero. The ceiling to attic temp, difference would be 70 while the floor to crawl difference would be 25 degrees. BUT, your feet are at about 98 degrees. So the the difference between your feet and the crawl would be closer to 55 degrees. If the insulation warmed the floor a few degrees, it would make you more comfortable.

You did not say how old your house is. If there is already insulation in the walls, upgrading it may be cost prohibitive. If they are not insulated, you should consider adding it.

It is a truism that insulation is insulation. There are differences, but you should compare R factor to R factor. If fiberglass has to have 9" to reach R-19 and cellulose has to have 6" for the same R factor and they cost the same and you have the room, they are nearly equal. OTOH if you have only five inches and foam will give you R-38 at double the cost, you may have to go with the foam to get the higher R Value.

There are other differences as well. Cellulose is often made of recycled paper. Paper is a renewable resource. This might appeal to you. Fiberglass is made of a very common and abundant material. Fiberglass itself will not burn and vermin will not eat it. Cellulose must be treated to resist fire and insects like termites. Every one of the products has pluses and minuses other than its ability to insulate.

The other major thing you need to consider is that once a house is fairly well insulated, the major source of heat loss is air flow through the house. Its called the stack effect. Hot air rises, finds leaks through the ceiling and escapes. This draws in colder air through the lower part of the structure. That can be very significant.

Can lights may be major culprits. Many are "open" so that air can flow through them to let them stay cool and not set the insulation or framing on fire. In effect, they are little chimneys that suck air through the ceiling. They can be replaced with sealed units that are more efficient and that you can completely cover with insulation. If you have the open ones, the insulation must stay back three inches and they should not be covered.

If you are interested in other possibilities, let me know and I will post some more, but for the moment I feel like I'm shouting into the wind and no one cares. Some of the stuff is really low tech and involves a lot of grunt work but little expense. My experience is that most people don't want to do the grunt work and won't pay somebody else to do it.

Your local utility may offer energy audits at a reasonable price. The tests may include a blower door test and that will help find the air leaks. (I would be somewhat skeptical of anyone doing and audit that also made the repairs and profited from them.)

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#9

Re: OT: Home Insulation LONG

DP

>Great information--thanks.

Re: OT: Home Insulation

#10

Re: OT: Home Insulation

David Hay @ Denver

>Thanks for everyone's responses. We're definitely looking at blowing additional insulation into the attic spaces. It sounds like doing that and fixing any air leaks are the main things to do.

We called around the other day...nobody seems to want to do the slow-rise foam...at least not in our area. Maybe we'll just do it ourselves in the one room that's really cold.

David