OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
Howard
>I am planning my garage shop and want to bring water in and this will be the way it will be run, but I am afraid I'll get a freeze-up. The wall are 2 x 6 with r-19 insulation. Thanks for the help
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
We moved into a new old house when I was 16, and started to have floods and burst pipes in the winters. I'll make a long story short.....
I got pretty good a mopping up and soldering copper pipe. But the main problem was the pipes were going through a section of wall that was an exterior wall. No amount of insulation and heating kept those darn pipes from bursting, so I moved them to another part of the wall. Problem solved.
This was in Montreal and it wasn't until the wearth dipped to below -25C that they would burst, but even in Toronto, I'd really avoid putting any pipes in an exterir wall.
Heck, even here in Atlanta, you can't put a pipe in an exterior wall. It might only get to -10F here, but there's very little insulation in our walls.
Happy Woodworking!
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>I think, as a general rule, that water pipes are not put in exterior walls. My parents' house is a 160-year old farmhouse in Mid-Michigan and the basement is unfinished, very drafty, and has a stone foundation. On the coldest days of winter, the water pipes nearest the western basement wall would freeze up, but I don't recall them ever bursting. The pipes did not come up through the outer wall but very close to it.
If you can avoid putting pipes in an exterior wall, I would.
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>Back in a previous life I had a small contracting company. Got a panic phone call on Christmas morning from my business insurance agent that a pipe had broken in an attic belonging to another of his clients up in Sacramento. I guess I was the only contractor dumb enough to answer my phone. So, I ended up with an emergency job over two hours away in a former model home that the builder had not set a meter or shut off valve, and he had not insulated the pipe, which was above the ceiling insulation.
Before the utility would shut off water to the street and I could set a valve, I had to give written 24 hour notice to EVERY house on the street. To stem the flow of water, the only thing I could think of was to crush the pipe with a big pair of pliers, then duct tape the break. That got the leak down to a steady drip, but the parquet floor and wide screen TV were already ruined, so....
Anyway, long story to say don't put ANY water pipes in uninsulated spaces. You may regret it.
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior w
Pete in Holland, MI
>Advice is against outer wall installation. If you do need to do so though, make sure it is on the warm side of all of the insulation. Burrying it in the insulation gets it closer to the cold side of the wall, and further from any heat. Simply insulating it will retard the freezing when it is really cold. Leaving access points for room heat to enter and exit along the pipe will help too.
Days that you would cut the heat back due to being away for some time will allow the house to cool down more, and leave less heat to radiate thru the drywall, and raise the opportunity for a freeze on a cold night.
Overall - - advise against it, regardless where you live.
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>Problem solved. Doesn't matter if it freezes, it's only an inconvenience then, not an emergency, because PEX will not burst when water in it freezes. Plus, PEX has more of an insulative quality to it over copper.
Jason
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>There was a segment on This Old House for their Shingle style house, where Tommy built the bathroom wall some 10" thick, so he could insulate really well behind, and still run the plumbing in that wall space. But REALLY thick walls, and well insulated behind it.
We had a place in Utah, where there was a cold air leak in the basement for some reason, and the water pipes 12' in from the side walls would on occasion freeze. First time it happened to me, an inexperienced Californian, I was perplexed. And poorer, too, after the plumber came out and thawed the pipes for us on a Sunday morning.
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>With copper you're at the mercy of mother nature! The weather get's cold and you're all wet.
With PEX you're at the mercy of time, or chemistry, or something. Ya, ya, I know that PEX is different from the PolyBlue pipe fiasco, but you know when they used PolyBlue pipe they THOUGHT it would work. They thought it would last. With PEX or any other man-made material you're waiting for the chemists for them to say "oops, we thought it would last longer" ;) ;)
Hey, I was a PolyBlue victim... I'm ALLOWED to be skeptical :) ;) ;)
(ps. PEX is probably a good solution)
Happy Woodworking!
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>Pex will freeze and split, maybe not as easily, but it will. As many of you have heard before I work at a ski area. I am responsible for several thousand square feet of heated deck. One system was a combination of pex and old iron pipe. we developed a leak in the IP, but couldn't shut the system down. Long story short, I was trickling in make up water, to a normally glycol based system and we had a night time power outage where my circ pumps did not restart, single didget temps. It took 3-4 days to get stuff circulation again. I had pex pipe that split inside concrete. I can tell you looking for leaks encased in concrete is no fun. I have had, much to my dismay, way too much practice at it. All that said, Pex IS much more forgiving than IP, just not freeze proof.
glc from snowy Bend, Oregon
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>Pex will freeze and split, maybe not as easily, but it will. As many of you have heard before I work at a ski area. I am responsible for several thousand square feet of heated deck. One system was a combination of pex and old iron pipe. we developed a leak in the IP, but couldn't shut the system down. Long story short, I was trickling in make up water, to a normally glycol based system and we had a night time power outage where my circ pumps did not restart, single didget temps. It took 3-4 days to get stuff circulation again. I had pex pipe that split inside concrete. I can tell you looking for leaks encased in concrete is no fun. I have had, much to my dismay, way too much practice at it. All that said, Pex IS much more forgiving than IP, just not freeze proof.
glc from snowy Bend, Oregon
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>I just moved into the new digs last Aug. Maggie says that we have a workshop with an attached house. (Well, that's another story for another day.) I used IPEX. It has the metal "sleeve" between the layers of whatever the coating is.
Last home had copper pipes burst UNDER THE SLAB. Ya think that was fun? Home before that had the poly butalene from the meter to the slab burst. Can you spell class-action lawsuit?
I am of the opinion (imagine that) that installation is the key.
Bill
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
>Bill, I surely can sympathise, at least when I have to find leaks it is in outside decks, no floorcovering or furniture. Under certain light snow conditions I can close all the return valves and go to the last place that is melting, only the leaking line will flow. I can tell you that Iron pipe will only last about 22-25 years in concrete. I have systems that are 26 years old. Interestingly enough, the pipe goes bad (rusts through from the outside in) in concrete that is in contact with the ground much much faster that decks that are over air space.
glc
Re: OT-Can a cold water pipe go into an exterior wall?
PEX may be slightly more resistant to freezing because the plastic is a better insulator than steel or copper. And it may resist bursting because it may stretch a bit before it bursts.
But, its important to understand a couple of things:
The older polybutylene pipe that was the subject of the class action suit had three failure modes. The early generation of plastic fittings failed under the influence of chlorine, the connections failed because of poor workmanship in clinching the rings, and the pipe eventually failed when exposed to chlorine. The Pex pipe I see uses what appears to be the same clinch rings to join the pipe. I hope they have improved it, but I wonder. I also hope the chemistry of the plastic resists chlorine better. Additionally, polyethylene is subject to UV degradation. A friend had some that was left in the son just fall apart.
The freezing of pipes and how they respond to it is interesting. As the water in the pipe freezes, it expands. At first, the expansion is linear. It acts like a piston in the pipe. This increases pressure in the entire system. IF this continues long enough and expands enough, the weakest point in the system will fail. Sometimes this is the wall of the pipe and it will bulge and burst. This is not always where the pipe froze, its just the weak point. Often in copper pipe, the solder joints fail and blow a fitting off the pipe. (This could be a good reason to use type L rather than type M, easier to fix) But if you have Pex with poorly clinched joints any joint anywhere in the system could blow off, so the pipe that freezes in your shop could blow off a joint in your living room ceiling.
So, Insulate well to stop the freezing. Might even put a little heat in the area if the shop is not centrally heated. An old fashioned incandescent light bulb will do a nice job. I actually recommend two, in case one burns out.