Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Dust Collector Location

Posts

Dust Collector Location

#1

Dust Collector Location

Paul T

>Hello all,

I am laying out a new shop. Overall size is 25' x 40'. Shop is on the second floor with garage below. Garage will be unheated while the shop will be heated. What would be your thoughts on putting the dust collector down in the garage. There is plenty of head room in the garage to run ductwork as it has 10 foot ceilings. I'm in the foothills of the southern Adirondacks and while it is currently frigid here it can get into the 90's and high humidity in the summer.

TIA,

Paul


img

Re: Dust Collector Location

#2

JL

Re: Dust Collector Location

JL

>Are you going to run all of your ductwork in the garage and have holes through the floor with stubs?

Your garage is a perfect place for your DC collector. You can fit a nice cyclone system in your 10' and use a large 55 gallon drum.

My $0.02.

Re: Dust Collector Location

#3

Re: Dust Collector Location

Paul T

>Exactly, all duct work coming up thru the floor with stubs. Would need some ductwork upstairs to get up to counter top height for some tools, but no long runs. Essentially like some layouts I've seen for dropping down from ceilings, but upside down.

Re: Dust Collector Location

#4

Re: Dust Collector Location

John Veerkamp

>A little gravity assist certainly can't hurt either. Keeping the dc out of shop space is a real plus. It will also be easier to empty the collector. It's amazing how heavy 55 gallons of shavings and wood dust is. Be sure to insulate the floor/garage ceiling too. It will help keep your shop floor more comfortable and cut down on noise from the dc and maybe from a compressor.

John

Re: Dust Collector Location

#5

Re: Dust Collector Location

Phil in NJ

>Sounds like if you suck air from the heated space, you want to return the heated air back to the heated space. That means the filter on a cyclone for instance would need to either be in the heated space,

or at least have a very permissive connection to it that will pass a lot of air.

Note that on most cyclones the filter is also gravity-cleaned, i.e. you hit the filter with compressed air and the dust drops into a pan or bag at the bottom. So the filter needs to have the air from the cyclone come in the top.

Re: Dust Collector Location

#6

Re: Dust Collector Location

Mike Fitterling

>While my DC is not on a floor below my shop my machine pickups are all truly "drops" as opposed to the typical systems where the lines are over head and material must be lifted into the main ducting. All my ducts lay on the floor. There is a big advantage to not having to lift the chips/dust up. It improves efficiency enough that I think my marginal DC (2 hp) would not work well if it had to lift the chips but with the ducting low it gets me by.

Another added benefit would be a drastic sound reduction, and as mentioned, not having to carry the full bag or can downstairs to empty it.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: Dust Collector Location

#7

Re: Dust Collector Location

Barry Irby

>My shop is in a walk out basement and the DC is outside in a little shed. Air compressor is out there too. I have not had any problems with the exhausting of the air. I suppose there is some heat lose, but I am a hobbyist and I run the DC when the tools run, In short bursts. So the fact that the exhaust is out side means I don't have to care about the quality of the filters or fine dust in the exhaust. Major improvement in the noise level and I don't lose the space the DC would occupy.

Your setup would be even better, being able to let gravity help. I might even consider exhausting it out doors to avoid whatever fine dust escapes settle on your car or whatever is in the garage.

Re: Dust Collector Location

#8

Re: Dust Collector Location

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>My shop is above my 3 car garage. My DC with cyclone and air compressor are down in the garage. It is the only way to go from many aspects!!!!

As Barry says, fine dust escaping from the filter is not a concern if it is down in the shop. Having the noise out of the shop and freeing up shop space is the only way to go. I recycle my air, but if I had to do it again I would think twice. If you don't recycle the air, you do not really lose much heat or cooling, due to the mass of the shop- the structure retains heat and stays cool even though you are pumping the air out.

I run my 6" PVC S&D along the garage ceiling, punch through behind knee walls for shop level horizontal runs, and punch through the middle of the floor where I have hinged trap doors for the TS and jointer drops. I punch through with angled runs using wyes and 45s- I have very few 90s.

I'll update this thread with a link to pics once the NCWW site is back up.

Re: Dust Collector Location

#9

**PICS**

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>No luck finding the thread, but here are some pic: (By the way, how do you edit a thread? Is it possible?)

Garage views:



Kneewall area before I installed wallboard:


Another shot of the kneewall area:


Floor hatches for TS and jointer DC ports:


Paul, if you want details on how to get your machines, etc. up to your shop, let me know. Here is a pic of my foldaway I-beam hoist lifting my new (old) 1200 lb 20" planer:


Re: Dust Collector Location

#10

Be A Bit Careful

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>About you exhaust. A bag provided a sercain amount of back pressure for the motor to work against. If you were to simply put the outlet hose outside, the lack of resistence might cause your motor to overload and burn out by overdrawing power.

Re: Dust Collector Location

#11

Re: Dust Collector Location

Barry Irby

>Is your shop attached to your house? If so, you may have created a code "issue" by running the pipe through the ceiling. The plastic pipe is not fire resistant and there may be a requirement for fireproofing between the house and garage. Doesn't matter too much though, If a fire starts in your garage, the studs in the sidewalls will burn out and the shop will collapse. So, it's sort of academic.

Great looking system though. And I like the lift. That would be my only objection to a second story shop, having to hump everything up and down the steps.