Way OT Anybody tried this Phone service/gadget?
Barry Irby
>My cousin sent me this URL for this phone service. Anybody tried it? Know anything about it?
http://www.magicjack.com/site/index.html
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Way OT Anybody tried this Phone service/gadget?
Barry Irby
>My cousin sent me this URL for this phone service. Anybody tried it? Know anything about it?
http://www.magicjack.com/site/index.html
Re: Way OT Anybody tried this Phone service/gadget
Steve in Denver
>No personal experience with this, found this review, sounds like it might be worth a try.
http://www.laptopmag.com/Review/magicJack.htm
You've got me thinking...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>Since we moved to a place just outside the "big city" last summer, my family has not had phone service other than my wife's and my cellphones. We could not have done this due to poor reception at our old place (I knew of about 3 2'x2' pockets of good reception on my property, 2 outside). One option I considered was a device that plugs into a cellphone and your house bell wiring, allowing you to use "normal" phones. But, that would be a $150 device, and another $10-15/month for another cellphone. This magicJack thingie looks like it may be the ticket as I have (for now, anyway) good broadband service.
I had sort of seen an infomercial for it a few weeks ago (fell asleep watching TV and only woke up enough to hear a little about the magicJack), but I figured it was just a cheap gimmick. With the online reviews I've now read, it looks like it could be a viable option. The one kicker may be the renewal price--good for now, but in a few years?
Jason
Re: You've got me thinking...
Barry Irby
>Jason,
I am considering this also. I pay about $45 a month for phone service at my house. I rarely use it. I sue it a few times a month in my business for faxing. I keep thinking I should give it up, but I have had a phone for forty years and it just seems odd to not have one.
However, for forty bucks for the first year and twenty a year after that, I may just hat to take a whack at it.
I wonder if I can wire it into my hose wiring so that I can use the phone anywhere in the house? I have several phones. Can I fax over it? Can I keep my existing phone number? Will I get a listing int eh phone book? will it work with 911 or 411?
Still, I have spent more on dumber ideas.
TANSTAAFL
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free Lunch. Well, this isn't free, but is sure is cheap! I, like you, have spent more on dumber things. There is a FAQ index on the website that answers some of your questions--911 works, fax may work, etc. I don't see any reason why you couldn't wire it into your existing phone wiring, but who knows? That's what I would want to do so that I could scatter ~3 phones throughout the house.
If you do it first, post your experiences, and I will do the same. If I do it, I doubt it will be for another few weeks at least (work has been a little slow this month, so I'm in "no-spend mode").
Jason
It's big deal among boaters
Garrett in Victoria
>The word on the cruising websites is that it is everything it claims to be.
Cheers, Garrett
I'm skeptical about this
Ed Beck
>I just switched to Vonage so when I saw this post I was curious. I looked into Magic Jack and am skeptical, mostly because it's difficult to find information from their own site. For example, what's the compatibility matrix look like? What are the minimum operating system and hardware requirements?
The Magic Jack web site appears to be a sales pitch and nothing else, something that I would see on a late-night infomercial. I intrinsically do not trust companies that do not provide a fast and easy way to determine if their product will work for you, but instead just repeat the mantra of �is just that easy�.
There are plenty of complaints about this product on various message boards, and their technical support seems to be non-existent. They do provide a couple of JavaScript tools on their web site that �fix all of your problems�, a claim which I flat out do not believe.
One of the bigger problems with this service seems to be the lack of local exchanges. This is not a problem for making outgoing phone calls, but it could result in your neighbor paying long-distance to call you. I did find a table that lists their area codes and exchanges at Magic Jack Area Codes
This table is sorted by area code, so I pasted it into Excel, sorted by State, and added a filter so you can quickly check to see if there is a local exchange that you can use. Go to my SkyDrive site to use it: Sorted Magic Jack Area Codes.
One thing that you will not be able to do is keep your existing phone number. According to the Magic Jack web site you�ll be able to do this in the coming months. This will also be dependent upon the exchanges that they can provide service to. If keeping your existing phone number is important than I�d at least wait.
With Vonage I was able to keep my phone number, but they are up-front about the fact that you may not be able to.
To answer one of your questions, I was able to plug my Vonage line directly into my house wiring using a standard RJ-11 (phone connector) and it provides a dial tone to all of my phones over the existing wiring. I do not know why the same would not work for Magic Jack.
IMPORTANT- If you use your existing house wiring, you should isolate your house from your local phone company. This is pretty easy, all you do is remove the cover on the phone connection box on the outside of your house, and disconnect the RJ-11 connectors that run from the �phone company� side of the box to the �customer� side of the box. You probably have two lines, and it�s a good idea to label them with something that is not going to be worn away by the weather so in case you want to reconnect to the phone company�s network you�ll know which line goes where.
Another comment is that your experience is going to depend on the speed of your hardware and your installed applications, as well as your broadband connection speed. There are reported conflicts between Magic Jack and some software applications, but I was not able to find any kind of list. If you have a slow computer you�ll have a poorer experience than someone with a fast computer. However I can�t tell you what the minimum hardware requirements are since Magic Jack does not make this information readily available, and I�m not so interested that I�m willing to spend more than 5 minutes looking for it.
While we�re talking about system requirements, there are usually minimum and recommended system requirements. Minimum are usually just enough to allow the thing to work, while recommended is what will make it work with some degree of satisfaction. If you see one but not the other think yet again about buying.
If you lose power you will also lose your phone line. This may or may not be a concern for you. If you have reliable cell phone coverage at your house this will probably be a non-issue. You can mitigate this by buying a UPS for your computer and network equipment. Then you�ll have a phone line for as long as the UPS is able to supply power. In contrast to this, if you were to go with a system like Vonage all that you would need to power is the networking equipment and adapters to still get a dial tone (providing that the phone lines were not also down). Another caveat to this solution is that your phones would need power. In the case of a phone connected to the wall it should still work, but a cordless phone would not work unless it too was on a battery backup.
My biggest question is about terms. If I were to sign up for this service am I making a commitment for more than a month? Again, this information is not readily available, as it is for other companies.
This has been a pretty negative post, but if my only commitment would be the $40 to test it out, I�d give it a try. That is if I had not already arrived at a phone solution that I was satisfied with.
I agree
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I agree, I'm a little skeptical... but then I'm skeptical about EVERYTHING.
"For example, what's the compatibility matrix look like?"
I'm not sure, but I thought I read somewhere that a standard phone connected to the MagicJack, can only call a phone on another MagicJack. In order for the MagicJack to break out of the VOIP/ internet realm and call a normal phone on the normal telephone system, they would have to work with Telco's all over the world, which I don't think they are doing. I could be wrong about that. The other's like Vonage, and Skype do that, but that's why Vonage costs $25/month and Skype is only free to other Skype customers and have to charge a low per minute fee when you call outside their network. A little like how one cellular company can offer in-network calls less expensively than when you break out of their network to call someone on another cellular service.
So, as I understand it (again could be wrong... there is very little good information about it) this MagicJack is not a whole lot better than voice calls made for free over MSN Live, or AOL, or any of the others. Instead of paying $20 for a earphone and microphone for your computer to talk to others who are on MSN Live for free, you pay $40 to use your standard phoneset, to call others who have a MagicJack.
Happy Woodworking!
It's there...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>You have to dig a little for it, but it's there. If you go to the main page, then click the "Ask Dan the inventor..." link at the bottom, then click "Browse all topics", you can drill through the menu to find that you can call to/be called by people who do NOT have a magicJack--it is connected to a "traditional" phone network, not peer-to-peer. Somewhere in there I also read that the doohickey needs about 80kbps of bandwidth up and down, so dialup is out--may work, but not well if it does (and would be silly anyway, unless you make a lot of long distance calls). I didn't see any exchanges local to me (nor my area code), but I think that list is just not updated, as it claims elsewhere that you can pick your area code when you sign up.
Jason
Picking Area Code
Ed Beck
>I interpret that to mean "pick your area code and exchange from the list of those available".
As I said, if the only commitment was the $40 I'd try it out if I were looking to replace Vonage.
As to dialup - you would not be able to use dial up for 2 reasons.
1. The required bandwidth exceeds dial-up's capabilitites.
2. If this is your only phone line, where are you going to get your dial tone from to initiate your dial-up session?
Re: Picking Area Code
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>From what I gleaned on the website, you could use dialup--connect to the internet via your phone line, plug in the gizmo, then make your call. Obviously, the bandwidth issue would cause problems, but if you could make it work, then you could make no-charge long distance calls that you otherwise couldn't on dialup.
I may try one of their support chats or whatever to find out for sure on the area codes/exchanges. If others had to make a long distance call to get ahold of me, that would be a deal breaker--I'd go with the additional cell phone with the device that puts the call into house bell wiring.
(I hope I'm not sounding like a shill for this product, just trying to flesh out the details).
Jason
Check this site for info *LINK*
Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN
>
http://WindowsSecrets.com/comp/071213
Thanks!
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>
MagicJack Review - here at WC - in 1 week
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I will post a review of the MagicJack here at WoodCentral in about a week. Sooner if time permits.
Happy Woodworking!
Thanks, Mark!
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>I take it you have taken the plunge with one?
I did finally get on their online sales chat, and they don't offer a number local to me and don't know when that will happen, so for now, I will not be getting the magicJack. I'm going to give it a few months, and if they don't add numbers local to me so that my local friends can call me non-long-distance, I'll be considering the Dock'n'Talk gizmo, which would plug into a cellphone (I add another cell line to my plan) full-time. More up front ($150ish) and more per month ($10ish for the extra cell line), but still much less than a landline ($35-40/mo, w/o long-distance) or Vonage ($30ish/mo).
But I'm still curious how well they work...
Jason
Unofficial magicJack forum *LINK*
Paul Cates - Henderson, KY
>I learned lots at the site below, such as magicJack doesn't work with Windows 2000 any longer. :(
Still, it might be worth an upgrade to XP considering how inexpensive MJ is.
Unofficial magicJack forum
Main weaknesses with internet phone services
wilbur
>1. If you lose your electricity, you lose your phone service.
2. 911 service may be an issue. The magicJack site has this to say:
Q: How do I get 911 Emergency Service on magicJack?
A: Register your current US address during the registration process.
Please make sure that your address information is complete, up-to-date and accurate. (If you travel, you must update your 911 service address.)
Wait for a confirmation email that your 911 service address is registered. Dial 911 only in an emergency. Our 911 service is different than 911 service offered on traditional phone lines.