Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

table top question

Posts

table top question

#1

table top question

Dan Collins

>I am going to make a computer table with a 50" by 26" by 3/4 inch top. It will be cherry hardwood. I am thinking of using 4 pieces that are 4 1/2" wide glued side by side, then having a 2" miterd (?) border all the way around the top (a picture frame effect). I am concerned that maybe the wood will move and open up the miters at some point. The top isn't very wide so maybe I am needlessly worrying. An alternative thought would be to eliminate the border and use breadboard ends, but I think I like the border look better. This is my first larger table, so my experience is limited. If it affects your answer, I am using kiln dried wood and I live in Wisconsin. Thanks for your opinions and ideas. Dan

Re: table top question

#2

Lee Grindinger

A mitre won't fly

Lee Grindinger

>Breadboard ends are the only way to attach a cross grain piece to your ends. Your cross grain movement will destroy the look of a mitre. If a mitre is necessary it would have to be done in veneers.

Lee

Re: table top question

#3

Yes and No

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>You could miter a breadboard end to the front. Make the miter end the solid point of attachment and let the rest float. Molding running across the grain on solid wood cabinets was done that way.

Re: table top question

#4

Lee Grindinger

No and no

Lee Grindinger

>Reread the post, he wants the frame all the way around the top.

Lee

Re: table top question

#5

oops

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>

Re: table top question

#6

A similar failure

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This question reminds me of attending a show sponsored by a club in a distant city. Someone had these stunning chess boards with mitered borders and the "squares" made from solid pieces. Incredible joinery, everything was perfect. I asked their maker how he handled the cross grain expansion. I got a puzzled response so I elaborated on cross grain expansion. Light bulbs flickered and he replied, "so that is why the corners break open". I was astonished that someone that could do joinery that skillfully and allow form to lead function.

Bottom line, it doesn't work even on something as small as a chess board or the end piece of lowboys.

Re: table top question

#7

Lee Grindinger

It's why God made veneer

Lee Grindinger

>Heh, heh, he...,

Veneer makes things possible that are not possible in solid wood.

Lee

Re: table top question

#8

Re: table top question

Mark McC

>My solution to a similar computer table/cabinet combo was to use the best quality cherry plywood (i.e veneer core not particle core) and then apply the solid cherry mitered border to get that look, as well as hide the plywood edges. Perhaps this is similiar to what Lee means by veneers although when I hear veneer I think of gluing sheets of it to some other type of substrate.

Mine looks great IMHO, has been flat and dead stable with tight mitres all the way around for a few years now.

Re: table top question

#9

Re: A similar failure

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I made a chessboard for my son, using 1/8" thick squares. It has a mitered, solid border. Cross-grain expansion is handled by gluing up the pieces with a piece of paper spacer between each one (plan from the Woodsmith mag).

Bruce

Re: table top question

#10

Re: table top question

Chicago Bob

>A Norm rerun recently showed how to do exactly what you describe using biscuits to attach a 2" outer trim around the table. He made long biscuit slots on the table�s edges so the edge trim would "float" when it expands & contracts. He only used to glue on the biscuits in the miter joints, glued the other side biscuits to the trim pieces and let the other side of the biscuits float in the table slots. (As I read this I realize that my description is confusing and I don't know the show number. It was on DIY channel Sat night Norm marathons within the last month. He was very sure that the results would be as good as breadboard ends and it really gave the table a more contemporary look.

Haven't personally tried this technique but am considering for a future table project. If you try this, please psot your results.

Good luck

Bob Haines

Re: table top question

#11

Re: table top question

Dan Collins

>Thanks for all your responses. You convinved me that the mitered picture frame idea won't work. Saved me a lot of hassle. I just picked up all the cherry at the sawmill. Looks and smells great. I'm thinking of doing breadboard ends or maybe just leave the ends bare. Thanks again. Dan

Re: table top question

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: Check out.....

Dale Lenz

>breadboard tops by Green & Green. With the right details, Green and Green tops w/breadboard can be made to look contemporary.

Good luck and please show us your results

Re: table top question

#13

Re: table top question

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

Following up on Dale's suggestion regarding the G&G style of breadboard, you might also consider a simple retangular inlay of a complimentary wood on the top surface of each breadboard. The current (I think) issue of Popular Woodworking has a very nice article by Rob Millard on doing a simple inlay and even fancier stuff. Please post a pic when you are done or even along the way. Sounds like a neat project.

Jim

Re: table top question

#14

Actually... *LINK*

Orinda Dan

>Classical Chinese furniture traditionally uses mitered frame and panel construction for the tops of tables and other furniture that lasts centuries. The joinery is not simple but can be fun to make if you have the patience. It always amazes me that craftsmen in those times can make such exact joinery and lasting beautiful furniture without any power tools.

Dan


Classical Chinese furniture

Re: table top question

#15

Lee Grindinger

Design parameters

Lee Grindinger

>So, would you want a raised frame in your desk top?

Lee

Re: table top question

#16

Lee Grindinger

It's a great solution

Lee Grindinger

>Products like veneered plywood are a terrific solution to wood movement issues. I've used it many times and it's the standard to use veneered sheet goods in the production furniture and cabinet world.

I've used plywood as a substrate to more expensive or thicker veneers and I've used solid wood with the same species veneer for "special" effects.

Here is one in which I simply laid up a veneered top and stuck it to a solid walnut slab, this made the edges easy to address...,


Here's one in which a plywood core was edged with solid wood, then the veneers were pieced together so the joints in the solid wood and the veneer lined up creating the illusion of a solid wood edge, which it was but solid veneered with the same species. It made for a very stable top with a look impossible with solids,


I'll just repeat, though, there have been many, many times I've done exactly what you did, framed veneered products. It's an ideal way to get the framed look.

Lee

Re: table top question

#17

Depends

Orinda Dan

>This is a change in topic, but this design has withstood the test of time and is esthetically pleasing to my and many others' taste. While I would not use it for a bench top, I certainly would for a writing or painting table, perhaps even for a dinner table. There certainly are large dinner tables that use similar design which can seat and hold all the food, drink, china, and utensils for a dozen people. I just would not dance on it afterwards. As to the original question of a computer table, it would depend on how heavy are the equipment that would sit on it. I see no problems with laptops and lighter LCD monitors.

Dan