Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Posts

OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#1

OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Scott in Montana

>I posted to the subject of HDMI cables earlier and it got me thinking. What is the public's current perceptions on which is better?

Would you buy a plasma monitor or a LCD monitor?

Which would you prefer, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Do you think the best technology will win out or will we settle for an inferior technology that has stronger marketing or a lower price? I don't think many would disagree that the old Beta format videotape was a superior design over VHS... and yet we chose VHS. Will it happen again? (some of you may not be old enough to even remember Beta.... sigh)

Since I work in the A/V industry I think my views are sometimes jaded and I would like to know what you are thinking.

Thanks,

Scott

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Well, I'm biased. I have an LCD and would do it again in a heartbeat over a plasma. I just don't like plasmas. That, and I think the technology research is going to go to LCDs anyway. Half the weight, half the power usage.

As for HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray, I think that will be a toss up for some time to come. I don't have either or a need or desire for either, so for now, I don't care. But, what I've heard is that Blu-Ray is technically superior, but not finalized as a standard. HD-DVD sounded like it had the market edge due to the porn industry using it (pretty sad, huh?), but with Warner Brothers pulling their support of HD-DVD, it may go down, who knows.

Jason

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#3

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Jerry Nicholson

>I bought a new 46 inch Sharp Acquos LCD HDTV a few weeks ago and have had a 32 inch Panasonic HDTV for a couple of years. I would make these choices again. Plasma makes a great picture but I am still concerned about the burn-in problem.

Jerry

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#4

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray? *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Picture quality is subjective, but I had a 42" 1080P Samsung LCD for about 5 weeks. I personally found more to dislike about the picture the more I viewed it, especially with regard to color accuracy and depth/evenness of black image areas. I returned the LCD & opted for a 58" 720P Panasonic plasma about 6 months later (bigger since we moved to a larger house in the interim), for about the same price we had paid for the Samsung. Although the resolution is lower, I find the picture to be of vastly better quality to the Samsung & other LCD's I have seen, such as my in-laws brand new 46" Aquos. The link below gives a good overview of the 2 options. It's true that plasmas consume more power than LCD's, but you're not likely to notice the difference in your electric bill ;-) Also, most experts will tell you "burn in" is no longer a plasma issue, nor is the similar "image sticking" which LCD's can suffer. Plasmas are heavier, but once you install the set, so what? I have the Panasonic suspended from the ceiling with small chains, no big deal with the assistance of my 108# wife ;-) For me, picture quality was ultimately the determining factor, I personally find the plasmas remain superior to LCD's in this regard.

Dan


LCD vs. Plasma

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#5

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

ScottS

>Story I saw yesterday or today said that the week following Warner Bros. announcement, HD DVD sales went in the toilet. A fall from 14,000 sales/week to 1700 sales/week. For the same period, Blu Ray sold 15,000 players/week. Sadly, I think the writing is on the wall of HD DVD. Too bad given that an HD DVD player costs half of what a Blu Ray player does.

For myself, I think that LCD will ultimately win out over plasma but at the moment a plasma display is significantly less expensive...

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#6

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Ray, SW Ohio

>I was trying to find the article about LCD monitors. If I remember, LCD's had a short life spam than plasma monitors. My 2�.

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#7

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have an LCD television which I purchased because of lower power consumption than plasma.

As for HD DVD or Blu Ray it will be decided the same way VHS and Beta was decided. Whatever the porn industry embraces will be the standard.

Stephen

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#8

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Scott,

My oldest son, a "video" guy who follows these things told me at Christmas that from his perspective Blu Ray appears to be winning. Forces unbound by reason will decide.

PS: and I certainly remember consumer Beta (not to be confused with Betacam which is often referred to as Beta). I had to locate a Beta deck once for a dub. I'm a former video guy, having not edited a video in over a year but still sitting here surrounded by Betacam SP, Svhs, video-8, high-8 minidv, and dvd decks. I think I still have a U-Matic deck somewhere in my storage building and a friend still has a granddaddy B&W reel-to-reel video deck - you sure don't see many of those anymore!

Hmm, I wonder if I can trade a couple of Panasonic AG-7750s somewhere for a good workbench. :)

JKJ

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#9

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

Paul Stone

>Scott,

All the discussion so far has missed the biggest reason I chose LCD. There is less glare from windows or room lights. My wife absolutely loves the LCD as she now doesn't see the glare from my reading lamp in the TV.

Paul

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#10

LCD and BlueRay

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I think that they'll be still be making LCD screens in 5 years, not sure about Plasma. Plasma was good at first, but I think LCD has overtaken it and will go forward, leaving plasma way behind.

I feel that HD-DVD *SHOULD* win over BluRay, but I think BluRay *WILL* win, for a few reasons. First is that Sony had an embarrasing loss with BetaMAX in the 80's.... their executives won't make that mistake twice. And now we have the snowball effect..... last year it looked like the movie studios would be 50/50 in the format. Both discs cost $30 and both players cost $900. With the news about WB, it think it will be a snowball effect with more companies moving (unfortunately) to BluRay. Cost of a BlueRay player today $800, cost of a HD-DVD player $180.

Just my thoughts of course.

I have a 47" 1080p LCD TV and was thinking about geting a HD-DVD player, even more so when I saw the price at under $200, but then stoppen and now not sure, now that I know WHY it dropped to under $200.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#11

Not quite true...

ScottS

>Actually, non-glare screens aren't inherent to LCD technology. Look at Samsung: their XX65 series LCD TVs have gloss screens, while the XX61 series doesn't. Many plasma manufacturers are starting to add non-glare coatings to their displays. Regardless of which technology you think is superior, you can buy it with the screen sheen of your choice... just like polyurethane!

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#12

Sorry - response to Scott in Montana, not Paul

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#13

LCD, glare or not to glare

Scott in Montana

>You're right, nearly all LCDs are now equally reflective as plasma screens.

Initially LCD monitors were all none gloss. This was due to the Furnell type lenses that had to be used to improve the LCD set's off axis viewing angles. Without lenses, the first LCDs only had a viewing cone of 90 degrees or 45 degrees off axis. Even then there was substantial picture degradation as you approached 45 degrees.

Scott

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Huh?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>My LCD claims a viewing angle of 178�, and the screen is non-glare. With an SD picture, the colors get bad near the edge, but with an HD picture, they remain pretty good even at the limits. When I was shopping for LCDs, (and I still look at them in the store occasionally), all plasmas had a glass screen, and all LCDs were a plastic, non-glare screen. I have yet to see an LCD that had significant glare.

The only glare my LCD gives off is the piano-black plastic of the housing, and the pretty bright colors of the display (grin).

Jason

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#15

Re: LCD and BlueRay

Dan Donaldson

>I just recently read something about Sony basically buying the business to get BlueRay in. They spent a couple of Billion dollars buying out some of the HD contracts and it appears that the majors are going to go that way. You can probably find info on it with a search.

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#16

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

wilbur

>Plasma and Blu Ray.

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#17

Re: Huh?

Scott in Montana

>Hello Jason,

Your LCD can have 178 degree viewing angle because of the lense system that diffuses the light after it passes through the LCD panel. Almost all companies have used that technology although recently most manufacturers have now started producing LCD panels with very thin matrix's and are therefore getting away from the use of dispersion lenses.

It seems that the public actually likes the smooth gloss look. There are also non gloss plasmas available in the commercial market.

Scott

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Huh?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Mine is a thin-film--Samsung 40", model LNS4051 (one of their early S-PVA offerings). The viewing surface doesn't look like a lens at all, either, but it's not glossy, it just looks like frosted plastic.

Jason

Re: OT- Plasma or LCD, HD DVD or Blu Ray?

#19

Thanks to all for your kind input.

Scott in Montana

>