MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Steve Silca
>Pros and cons when you're sweating copper? MAPP gas is costly but works faster. Does it get things too hot?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Steve Silca
>Pros and cons when you're sweating copper? MAPP gas is costly but works faster. Does it get things too hot?
Re: MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Nat Robison
>My neighbor is a plumber and helped me with a big project. He said that MAPP does burn hotter and there is a learning curve to using it. The potential is there to get the joint too hot and burn away all the flux.
I'm no master joint sweater but regular propane has always worked fine for me.
Re: MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Steve in Denver
>Once you go MAPP you'll never go back. I did some some plumbing a few years ago when I finished our basement and after running out of propane I made the switch to MAPP. It's like night and day, almost made sweating pipes enjoyable.
I've used both..........
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I've used both, on perhaps (I dunno exactly) maybe 1000 joints over the years. Once in a while I've wished the blue propane was hotter, usually when the pipe and garage are really cold in the winter, or the fixture I'm soldering is extra thick and takes more heat, but usually the propane is fine. I've also used the MAPP gas and have noticed it gets hotter faster, and rarely have ever had an issue to it being too hot.
I've got a few bottle of both and I might pick the yellow one if I was in a hurry, but would pick the blue one if I didn't have to reach are far to get it.
Happy Woodworking!
Re: MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>No, people get things too hot.
Clint
Re: MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>I did plumbing on the side, (did hold an Indiana Plumber Contractor License) and couldn't count the number of sweat joints I have installed in sizes from 3/8 to 4" - the 4" sewer line is just about the max I where I would want to use propane. I don't see any reason to use Mapp gas. As has been said you can overheat a joint and burn off the flux before the solder wets completely. I have seen one job where the pipe joints were damaged / melted (cost Sears' several thousand due to slow leaks that almost destroyed a house foundation - and did ruin a fairly new boiler. However I believe the incompetent installer used Acetylene instead of propane or Mapp gas. If I were you I would stick with propane, although a little slower it is a little surer and cheaper. Really you spend very little time properly heating a joint anyhow.
Re: MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>I vote MAPP, but not for plumbing reasons (can't recall the last time I had to sweat a joint--my plumbing problems in the last few years have all been fixture-related). I just like MAPP because it's cool...err...hot. I have a trigger-start setup on a MAPP bottle and I use it for all sorts of things--de-icing locks, heating metal to be bent (you knowing--making "specialty" tools), starting fires (camp, firepit, woodstove, etc.). It's much better at all of those things. And, I find with it being so hot, it does the job quickly and I don't use much of it. A bottle lasts me a long time.
Jason
Re: MAPP gas (yellow container) or normal propane?
Pat Riley in SLC
>I have used both. In general if I'm doing anything over 3/4 that involves valve bodies etc (anything thick) I will use mapp if I have it. For typical house stuff, just use propane.