Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

fuming red oak

Posts

fuming red oak

#1

fuming red oak

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>My daughter wants a Morris chair, and I happen to have a stash of red oak. Will this stuff fume like white oak? Or do I have to find some white oak?

I can always just stain it, but I'd like to try the technique.

Bruce

Re: fuming red oak

#2

Re: fuming red oak

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Bruce,

Haven't done it but have seen it done. Thing is you need very concentrated ammonia (not the household stuff) and it is somewhat dangerous to use or even have around. While the piece has to be bagged, the surrounding area must be well ventilated; those fumes can KILL I was told.

This would seem to be a Summer kind of thing to do, no?

mm

Re: fuming red oak

#3

Re: fuming red oak

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Actually, I've heard of (not experienced) some guys doing the trick with household ammonia -- it just takes longer. And yes, it is a summertime activity. If it ever gets to be summer again.

As it is, I used to be certified in concentrated ammonia, used in refrigeration at the plant I worked at. It's nasty, but you should see the cute things you can do with a dollar bill and liquid ammonia.

Bruce

Re: fuming red oak

#4

Bart Goldberg

Re: fuming red oak

Bart Goldberg

>It is possible to achieve the same effect as fuming using aniline dyes, and its much safer. I have made several mission style pieces from 1/4 sawn white oak with great success. Check out Jeff Jewitt's site) (www.homesteadfinishing.com) for more info.

Regards

Bart

Re: fuming red oak

#5

Dollar bill with Household Ammonia?

Mark Williamson

>I'm intrigued, would this be regular household ammonia? The curiousity is killing me, what CAN you do with a dollar bill and liquid ammonia? Besides, go and buy another bottle. :)

Mark

Re: fuming red oak

#6

Re: Dollar bill with Household Ammonia?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Nothing with household ammonia, that I know of. The trick uses a dollar bill and anhdrous ammonia, the kind of stuff that can kill you.

Repeated soaking/drying cycles will shrink the bill to a third the original size. No longer good for legal tender, but cute as the dickens.

Bruce

Re: fuming red oak

#7

Re: Dollar bill with Household Ammonia?

Mark Williamson

>HA! Sounds neat, can't be done with regular ammonia though?! No fun!

Mark

Re: fuming red oak

#8

hazzards (or not) of using concentrated ammonia

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I will not deal with why one would do chemistry experiments with dollar bills in liquid ammonia........

There seems to be a prevailing notion that while 3% ammonia is perfectly safe for the woodworker (note lack of sexist slant here) to use for household chores, the same stuff 10X more concentrated is 10000 times more toxic/hazardous or whatever to stick in a plastic bag and color oak. It stinks. It burns the eyes. It is almost as bad as cleaning a chicken house. Farmers use 100% in their corn patches, as do METH lab practitioners. Anyone not bolted to the floor will avoid hazardous concentrations. It is not cyanide or nerve gas. A whiff will send one scurrying away to fresh air with out lasting effects. The main hazard to worry about is avoiding getting it into your eyes.

Re: fuming red oak

#9

Re: hazzards (or not) of using concentrated ammoni

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Bill,

I worked with the stuff with Class A suits with SCBA gear. The CEO of our company walked out into a cloud of the stuff when he'd been warned not to and didn't make it two steps. When the head refrigeration operator retrieved the CEO, he promptly wrote up the guy for failure to follow safety procedures.

Bruce

Re: fuming red oak

#10

the answer to your specific question

Michael Dresdner

>Yes, red oak fumes just as well as white. In fact, any wood with a high tannin content will fume. I've done several articles on fuming, how to do it safely, and even how to influence the color over the past twenty years or so. The most recent are April 2000 Woodworker's Journal, which not only covers fuming but also the ways to mimic it without using ammonia; and one in April 2005 Wooworker's Journal that deals exclusively with fuming, making simple chambers, and even shows comparison pictures of wood fumed with concentrated 28% ammonia fumes and wiped with household liquid ammonia. That article has very specific instructions on exactly how to do it, what to watch out for, and so on.

Re: fuming red oak

#11

Re: the answer to your specific question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Mike,

that's precisely what I was looking for.

bruce

Re: fuming red oak

#12

Fumed with household

Craig Daymon

>I've fumed very successfully with household ammonia. The key is a very tightly sealed container to hold the object to be fumed. The pieces I've fumed have been relativel small, so I have used an ice chest. The biggest piece being a 10" chestnut bowl. It's a deep chocolate brown now. It spent a night in the cooler with 2 dishes of household ammonia.

When the fumed object comes out, it will not look as expected. Frequently it will have a gray cast to it. Let it air out a few days to off-gas the ammonia that it has absorbed and then finish it. The finish will remove the gray cast and expose the deep brown.

I am very convinced that a tightly sealed container is the key. I saw David Marks fume a white oak piece on his show using the strong/dangerous stuff and a simple framed cube tented with plastic and I've always gotten better results than he did for that project.

It MAY be possible to fume the pieces of your project before final assembly, allowing you to use a cooler like I use. (Mines a large, 40 gallone Igloo brand cooler.) Fuming penetrates relatively deep, so a final sanding should still be possible after assembly, prior to finishing.

Any wood with a tanin content can be fumed to alter the color. Tanin can also be added by brushing on a solution of tannic acid and water (distilled) before fuming. Oaks, chestnut (LOTS of tanin) and several others. Personally, I just plain think White Oak is a much better wood than Red and it is also the oak used by the Arts & Crafts folks like Stickley, not red.

-Craig

Re: fuming red oak

#13

a different situation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You were dealing with 100% ammonia gas either under pressure or as a cooled liquid. Upon release of pressure, or warming, 100% of this material becomes ammonia gas which can increase its concentration in air dramatically. "Concentrated" ammonia is a solution of ammonia in water, just like the cleaner, only more concentrated. One would have no issue carrying an open jar of the stuff around in a ventilated area because the ammonia only slowly leaves the solution and enters the air. If you spilled a pint in the garage you would just walk away to avoid the smell which would be less annoying than a chicken house. If you spilled a pint of the stuff you used with it would volatilize so quickly that you might be overcome by its concentration.

Re: fuming red oak

#14

Re: hazzards (or not) of using concentrated ammoni

Bill White

>Most folks have used a blueprint company for the supplier of ammonia.

Bill

Re: fuming red oak

#15

Rick L

Re: Red oak does not fume like white

Rick L

>oak at all. We just did a job with several thousand feet of red oak 10" x 10" timbers that had to be fumed to match fumed white oak. We had to brush on tannic acid to mimic the white oak. Our fuming chambers were 16' x 4' x 2' and we use anhydrous ammonia in a 100 lb tank. The strongest ammonia you can get. Red oak and white oak have totally different tannic acid contents.

Re: fuming red oak

#16

Re: Red oak does not fume like white

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>Here's the other part that has to be considered:

'White oak' represents a number of different species with similar, but not exactly the same characteristics.

'Red oak' is the same way - a number of species marketed as 'red oak' because they are similar.

In California, there are about 9 different species of oak, only some of which are marketed at all. And they behave differently when fumed.

And this doesn't include tannoak, which is similar looking, but in another family altogether.

Thus, I would look at a dye, if it were me.

Re: fuming red oak

#17

Ellis Walentine

My experience

Ellis Walentine

>In order, the best woods for fuming in my experience are English oak and American White oak. I have not tried the German white oak that Talarico sells, but I expect it is pretty good for this. I have had only limited luck with red oak, not enough to justify the effort. Maybe a wash with tannic acid solution prior to fuming would have made the difference, but somehow I never experimented with that procedure.

I used regular household ammonia with successful results, but it took considerably more surface area of household ammonia than blueprint ammonia (28%). I always left the piece and the dishes of ammonia in the tent overnight. Pyrex baking dishes are best for ammonia. Aluminum reacts with the ammonia.

As long as you have a decent vapor concentration, you don't have to get too fussy about sealing the chamber. For a tent, depending on the size of the project, I would drape clear polyethylene sheeting over a couple sawhorses, fold the corners neatly and weight the edges to the floor with beams or cauls of some sort.

As an aside, I had half a dozen steel I-beams, approximately 3"W x 4"H x 48"L, that I used for all kinds of clamping and case assembly work. I contact-cemented 1/8" masonite on one face of each I-beam and 1/2" homasote on the other so I could always have a soft or a hard surface to rest the work on, whether for clamping or assembly or whatever.

Regarding the potential dangers of anhydrous (28%) ammonia, I would not take them lightly. I had an employee (ironically named "Lucky") who happened to get a whiff of that stuff one day, and I thought I was going to have to take him to the hospital. He had some pretty serious respiratory reactions to the ammonia -- gasping for breath, etc. He was back to work in an hour or so, but the episode left an impression on me. Don't take any chances with chemicals.

Ellis

Re: fuming red oak

#18

Rick L

Re: Sodium nitrite is used to test for *LINK*

Rick L

>White oak. A 5% solution and water will verify wgite oak. White oak turns black when the sodium nitrite solution is applied. 100% accurate.


Sodium nitrite