Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT Hi Def TV question

Posts

OT Hi Def TV question

#1

OT Hi Def TV question

Barry Irby

>If I get one of the new hi def TV's, will the tape player and DVD player I have now work with it? I'm being given the not too subtle nudge to get one of those BIG NEW TV's. So, is it just a TV or is it all new stuff?

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#2

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Mike in Savannah

>Yes they will, you'll just see the same quality picture, not Hi-def, then you'll get to bite the bullet and get a Blu-ray Disk player!

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#3

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Tony - Memphis

>Technically, yes, but beware, my fairly new Sony VCR doesn't play very well over the new Sharp LCD. Something funny in the conversion from analog to digital. Almost seems like a buffer gets full or soemthing. It plays, but is kind of skippy. My fairly new Toshiba dvd recorder, however, plays just fine. To overcome all of this, I bought a new Sony dvd/vcr with digital tuner (I have no cable or satellite), but it didn't work, darnit! And after reading a lot about various recorder issues, I just decided to get a refund and wait a while. I was a holdout. Our tv was a 26" I bought in 1989. I have enjoyed the new tv. It does get a much better signal via the digital tuner and the picture is nice. I still say it looks pixellated. Overall, it wasn't worth the money (we got a 37" Sharp Aquous). What drove us was the poor signal we were getting via the old analog tuner and that a lot of shows are broadcast in the wide format which showed up around 12" tall on the old tv. Anyway, more than you asked...sorry.

Tony

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#4

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Barry Irby

>Actually, this is exactly what I wanted to avoid. I have cable, so I guess some of those issues will not affect me, but I think this is a good time to wait for all this stuff to sort itself out. I am actually pretty happy with my TV. Just don't see the need for a bigger one or a better picture.

Next, I'm going to get me one of those new fangled cello phones and a lathe with a motor on it. Who knew? I heard you can carry those phones in your car. How long is that cord?

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#5

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Pete in Holland, MI

>I have been vasilating on the same thing. A lot of money to watch the History Channel.

The kids for years have been after me to get a bigger (current is 25") TV. I keep telling them to sit closer to the current one and get the same effect. Sucks as a kid to have an engineer as a dad sometimes.

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#6

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Tony - Memphis

>Yeah, I still can't grasp spending what it cost to get a new tv, and we bought a smallish one by today's standards. Oh well. I must admit that I carry one of them there cello phones, but I rarely turn it on! I had to upgrade the lathe as my wife started complaining about the peddling after she found out that "other" wives didn't do that for their husbands.

Tony

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#7

You have to replace EVERYTHING........

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Let me tell you.... you have to replace everything.

Well, no, you don't HAVE to but you'll want to. The general rule is buy a device with output to match your monitor. Partly because it makes sense, partly because the devices are so much cheaper than the actual monitor.

Here's the deal... you kinda have to understand the difference between 480 and 720i, 720p, 1080i, 1080p displays.... it doesn't stop there. Then look at the media you want to watch, VHS tapes? TV? DTV? HDTV? DVD? HD-DVD? BluRay DVD? .......

THere's too much to discuss in this post, but I'll just give yuo some info I've gone through.

Sample case:

$2000 47" 1080p LCD screen..... not what I paid for it but anyways :)

Has a whole bunch of inputs, in order of performance (and ignoring audio at this point):

Single RCA jack - those really old round plugs - video feed from VCR

S-VHS - looks like a PS2 mouse plug from a computer

Composite (or as I like to call it: 3 RCA jacks) - splits the video

HDMI - Wang-bang best (today at least)

So I discover that my 2 year old DVD player lacks HDMI. So I go to the store and guess what? I plug it in with the less cables, and can watch things, but only marginally better than my old 480 TV. So I look and learn about HDMI and discover:

My HDMI-less DVD player sells for $49 now.

New HDMI-equipped DVD player is $99 now (some models were $79, but I wanted the $99 one)

HDMI is capable of handling 1080p (best today) but STD DVD's are still not that good, so the $99 DVD with HDMI-output player up-converts your STD DVD to 1080p. So not as clear as tru HD-DVD or Blu-Ray, but......

Today, as far as I can tell Blu-Ray DVD Player is $600+ and HD-DVD player is $200, but HD-DVD might die now that WarnerBrothers has bailed.

There did I though enough acronyms at you? I'll decipher later if necessary ;)

Moral of the story...... like a lathe, you don't stop buying at the machine but start buying nicer gouges.

So to answer your question, yes, your new TV will display your old VCR tapes just fine, but if that's all you want, might as well save your money and get a 720 LCD monitor since a 1080 will be a waste. If you get a 1080 TV, you'll prbably decide to upgrade your other components to match.

Technology is fun! I've been meaning to report on my Rabbit-Ear antenna story (based on a question I asked here last week). Will do soon.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#8

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Jerry Nicholson

>Your new HD TV will have so many input possibilities you might have trouble sorting them all out but HDMI is best, Component Video is next, S video is a big step down from that, and composite is not as good as S video. I haven't tried watching any tapes on my new 46" Sharp Acquos but the Sharp does a really good job of showing everything, including defects. DVDs look pretty good but would probably look a lot better with an "upconverting" player. Most real HD programs, such as the earth series on Discovery, look really good (we have Cox cable). Our PBS station has 3 digital channels but they are not HD and aren't very impressive. The other local stations transmit HD but their newsrooms still use old equipment and the signal conversion to HD is pretty sloppy. With a new HD TV, you enter a new world where people talk about 480i, 480p, 720p, 1080i, 1080p, HDMI, DVI, etc.

Jerry

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#9

What mark says!

Jerry Nicholson

>Mark was posting his reply while I was writing mine! Sorry about the overlap.

Jerry

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#10

Lee Gordon

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

Lee Gordon

>To add to what everyone else has mentioned, if you get a new HDTV, your old tape player will almost certainly work with it, as will your old DVD player with one caveat: some DVD players tout their "Progressive Scan" feature, while others have a button or switch that allows you to disable progressive scan. If the native resolution of your TV is 1080i and your DVD player has progressive scan that can't be disabled, there's a chance the two devices won't play well with each other.

Any other combination of progressive vs. interlaced scan ought to be OK.

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#11

HDMI cables prices are amazing!

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>After you spend $1600 on a LCD screen, you'll be pleasantly surpized that a DVD player only costs $99. And then mortified to see the HDMI-cable costs $79-$99. Hard to imagine that a cable can cost as much as a DVD player.

It's been said here often, but let me remind you. Buy your HDMI cables online for a fraction of the cost. A Monster� HDMI cable can cost you between $79-$149 at a BigBox store, and you might find a no-name brand HDMI cable for a bit less. Online you can get a no-name brand HDMI cable for $11 and if a no-name brand scares you, get a good quality brand name cable for $25 online.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#12

Re: HDMI cables prices are amazing!

Jerry Nicholson

>Cyberguys.com and newegg.com are good places to look for cables. The geeky guy at the BigBox store will try to tell you his oxygen free left twisted gold plated large diameter cables are FAR FAR superior to those you can buy on line. The proper response is Bull Patties or something of that nature. Selling HD television machines is really competitive. They probably make a lot more profit on the overhyped and overpriced cables than they do on the picture box.

Jerry

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#13

Re: You have to replace EVERYTHING........

George (Oxford, NC)

>Mark -

We got an LCD 37" for Christmas. It came with aN HDMI cable. Come to find out our cable DVR box did not have HDMI output. Called and they replaced the DVR box for free. But, when the cable guys came out to switch out the DVR (yeah, it took two of them) they claimed that Composite was far better than HDMI. They furnished the cables and hooked it up with Composite. Should I unplug the composite and plug in the HDMI cable or is there THAT much difference (for normal TV programming - not a lot of big nature documentaries etc)?

George

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#14

Re: You have to replace EVERYTHING........

Jerry Nicholson

>For HD, composite is far inferior to HDMI. The ports labeled "component" are, however, good enough for most practical purposes. If you are watching plain old analog cable on your new HD, the "composite" ports might actually filter out some annoying noises and artifacts that your old analog TV would not have reproduced anyway.

Jerry

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#15

Right!

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>If composite (the 1 single RCA jack) is a dirt road, and component (3 RCA jacks) is a paved road, then HDMI is a freshly paved Interstate highway...... nah, make that a straight track at the Bonnville Salt Flats in Utah :)

If you're riding a bicycle you'll notice an improvement between a dirt road and a paved road, but chances are you won't find any benefit of the Interstate over a paved road on a bicycle. If the quaity of the picture comeing from the source (the cable company) isn't great, then you won't notice a difference between component hooked over HDMI.

But if a device has a HDMI output then you'd think it would be producing a signal that warrants that. It's a little strange that a cable guy would say what he did, but I'm not expert on this subject.

But I'll tell you something, if a cable guy told me that, you KNOW that as soon as he left, I'd be testing out all the wires and cables possible just to see for myself.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#16

Re: HDMI cables prices are amazing!

Pete Stahl

>Hey Mark, try Monoprice. Very good quality cables at very good prices. Very highly recommended on AVSForum DOT COM. What HDMI DVD player did you get?

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#17

You can catch STD's from your DVD player?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#18

Re: HDMI cables prices are amazing!

Scott in Montana

>Jerry, I'm curious what brings out your claim of "Bull Patties" in regards to cable technologies. It would seem to me that connecting a $2000 television with budget HDMI cables would be akin to buying a Unisaw or PM66 and putting a Sears blade on it.

While I agree that some of the highest priced cables ($1000+) seem outrageous, I try to keep in mind the law of diminishing returns.

A couple friends and myself recently had an opportunity to compare four 3 meter HDMI cables in the $30 to $150 price range. The source was a Pioneer Blu-ray DVD player and the set was a 60" Pioneer plasma.

The comparison was conducted as a blind test where we, the viewers, did not know which cable was being used. We were simply told it was cable A, B, C, or D, and asked if it was better or worse than the cable it was being compared to. Kind of like going to the eye doctor... "Which is better, 1 or 2?" Both cables were hooked up simultaneously through input 1 and input 2 on the plasma monitor. After we had repeatedly compared the cables back and forth we rated them 1 through 4. When we finish testing, we compared our results, both my buddies and I had rated the cables in the same exact order and as expected we liked the most expensive cable best and the least expensive was at the bottom of the list. Once again, it proved to us that you get exactly what you pay for.

Without this comparison I might have been more skeptical, but the differences were not subtle. Color vividness, three dimensionality, sharpness... everything. Unfortunately the test was not set up to allow us to also compare sound quality, but I know through past experience that digital interconnects do make a sound quality difference.

It's too bad that more retailers haven't set up tests like this so we could all make more informed buying decisions.

Scott

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#19

Belkin PureAV

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I went to monoprice.com and saw them, mostly the no-name (at least to me) for $10-$11. Then I went to buy.com (or egghead.com?) and found a Belkin PureAV for $25 which was the same I saw a BestBuy(??) for $69. So I got the Belkin PureAV cable.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#20

Oh, sorry

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>The HDMI DVD player was the Sony model something-something 77.

I see that I can get a Toshiba HD-DVD for about $80 more, and was thinking about that and then heard WB Studios just dumped HD-DVD in favor of Blu-Ray DVD which might be the nail in the coffin for HD-DVD.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#21

thanks Mark

Pete Stahl

>

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#22

Re: HDMI cables prices are amazing!

Jerry Samsen

>I would like to see an engineering explanation of this. HDMI is a digial interface. A digital signal is either delivered or not. I'm not sure if HDMI has two-way ack/nack or forward error correction. But failure to deliver the signal would result in lost transport frames and would probably manifest itself visually in lost frames, missing pixels or lines -- not in a loss in picture quality as would be the case with an analog signal.

The cable quality is probably more relevant to the length of the cable that can be supported until the specs of the delivered signal fall outside of the specs of the receiver (TV).

Personally, I think the premium cable is in many cases, a slick marketing con. I distrust Monster particulary given their history in upselling speaker wire in which I know has no engineering basis for baseband speaker-level audio signals.

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#23

Re: I must be a 39 yr old....old fart

Brian in Brighton

>because there is no way I am going to pay that kind of money for a TV. I'm happy with my standard cable signal and will fight paying for digital tooth and nail. I could care less about HDTV, even though my 3 yr old tv is HD ready. We watch a few hours of tv a week and find the picture just fine. Is it super-duper? No. But then again, I visited someone with one of the giant HDTV's and got a headache from my entire vision being consumed. The eye strain was unbearable from always looking around to see the action.

So I guess I'm just an early starter with being a grumpy old man.

Brian in Brighton, who would rather spend $2000 in the shop than on a tv every day of the week and twice on sundays.

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#24

Re: I must be a 39 yr old....old fart

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>Well, today, in the US, they began the bidding on the spectrum where the 'old school television' is broadcast. And the bidding is expected to run into the $10B range. So there is reason to make this happen, and without waiting too much longer.

You don't have to watch the new tv. You just won't easily be able to watch the old tv, without some sort of changes.

And I agree that there isn't much on that rivals some of what we do with our hobbies, friends and families. It's just television, and most of it isn't 'for me'. It doesn't have to be watched at all.

Re: OT Hi Def TV question

#25

Re: HDMI cables prices are amazing!

Scott in Montana

>Hello Jerry,

While I am a EE, I received my degree long before digital signal transmission was offered as a specialized area of study. My field of study was analog signal processing and transmission.

First of all, I agree with you in regards to Monster Cable. Their initial products were discovered by accident and slickly marketed. Some of their current top of the line products have significant research behind them but you are paying for it and a ton more for their marketing. None of the quality cables that I am familiar with have a stadium with their name on it.

Anyhow, in regards to HDMI and its cabling. The newest standards are bidirectional with most manufacturers using noise shaping (error correction) circuitry on the receiving ends. To my knowledge, nobody is using any form of acknowledgment as it isn't covered in the formal standardization. The bidirectional communication is used mostly for recording devices to eliminate the need for a send and a receive signal cable.

The noise shaping or error correction circuitry is necessary to overcome errors that are often created in substandard interfaces... cheap HDMI cables. It is these circuits that prevent the loss of frames due to faulty signals. And as you probably know the correction circuits essentially have to guess at what is noise and what information has been lost. This all sounds like a good idea, but these little brains are often wrong... up to 40% of the time. Therefore preventing the injection of noise that can occur between the source and the monitor as well as preserving the integrity of the original signal are of great importance in an effort to keep this signal shaping to an absolute minimum.

In an effort to do this, the cable manufacturer does several things. Simplest is good shielding; keep the interference out. Also along this line is the wire's geometry; how it is wound, types and numbers of conductors used, and how it is stranded. This is very important in maintaining a signal's purity. Choice of conductor (never gold, preferably silver), dialectric (air is best, and teflon isn't bad), and what the terminations are constructed from are all very important. On the best cables the ends are also often made from teflon. All of this is important to maintain a quality signal.

Impedance of the the conductor is also important. A higher uniform impedance of the cable will aid in keeping the digital information clean and the envelope of the signal very distinct. Again, less errors to correct.

And maybe most important in regards to HDMI cables is the clocking of the information. All of the information must arrive at its designated time. This is the reason that when running longer lengths of HDMI cables you must insert a small box. I've heard it incorrectly referred to as an amplifier; it's actually a reclocking circuit that realigns the signal.

I hope this long winded post has shed a bit of light on the subject and why some HDMI cables are $100 or more. One other thing I think we often forget is that video from a DVD player or satellite/cable decoder is much more demanding than most anything needed for computer video. PowerPoint presentations just aren't very challenging by comparison. (I know, ultra high-end video editing is an exception)

Again, I am not any sort of digital engineer, but my job necessitates me knowing my way around the basics and a bit more. If you want some more technical aspects addressed, send me an e-mail. I'll be glad to answer what I can, or if I don't know the answer, I'll find out for you from somebody who does.

Scott