Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

Posts

OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#1

OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

Ken Krawford

>Living in the Atlanta, GA area it looks like water shortages are going to become a way of life. In my house the biggest water waster is the shower. It's only a 35-40 ft run from the water heater to the bathroom but is seems like we waste a lot of water waiting for the shower to turn hot.

I recently read about a device called a Hot Water Lobster. It's a thermal expansion valve that allows hot water to circulate back to the heater via the cold water pipe.

Does anyone have any experience with this gizmo? I've also considered a recirculating pump. How about those?

Thanks for any feedback.


HotWaterLobster

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#2

Here close to Atlanta

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Here, just south of Atlanta, most of our house are on concrete slabs and I guess it made sense to the builders to run the hot water pipes under the slab to get to the faucets. >:| The only exception in our house is our master bath, which is directly above the water heater in the garage.

Several neighbors installed those recirculating devices, and they do work as advertised, water is hot almost instantly.

But at what cost? Instead of letting hot water inside 40' of 1/2" copper pipe cool once, you're keeping that pipe constantly filled with hot water.

So instead of wasting a fraction of a gallon of water that has turned cool down the drain, you are heating up the slab. I guess that might add to the heating of your house, so it's not such a waste.

Well, the whole receiculating idea seems like trading one waste for another, so instead I installed a 4 gallon inline electric water heater under the kitchen sink.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#3

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water

Barry Irby

>I have to agree with Mark.

I looked at the recirculating pumps (Available at Lowes for about $240 at the time). In my case I was ticked about the wait at the kitchen sink. The pump recirculated the water back tot he water heater through the existing cold water lines. I measured the amount of water that ran down the drain before the water got hot and it was about five quarts. (I think). I calculate the cost of that water if I rand it about five to ten times a day. It would take about twenty years t save enough water to pay for the device if you ignored the cost of heating the water. I think you would be int he hole if you accounted for the cost of the heat.

I have never seen the Thermal Lobster before, buy its an interesting Idea. In my case, it would not work, because my (five year old electric) water heater has a set of rubber restrictors in it to prevent convection out into the pipes. They are like little "irises" or rubber flaps that will bend to allow substantial flow, but close to prevent gentle flow. At the time I saw them as brilliant and a good economical way to save energy.

I also doubt the Lobster would work and many cases. For example, if the water heater were above on on the same level as the tub, I doubt the water would circulate much at all. And there would be a limit on how far it would circulate and how far it would go before it cooled off.

I wonder what the affect would be on your other water use. For example, every time I turn the water off to my ice maker and turn it back on, I get some green ice (copper pipes). Would the warm water returning tot he water heater affect the ice maker? Would I get warm water out of other faucets?

Personally, what I would like to have is a pump with a switch on it that would run the pump for about five or ten minutes. (You could just push the button and wait for the hot water without running it letting it run down the drain.) Or a timer to turn it on about the time I got up or headed to the shower if they were at a regular time. The idea would be to circulate the heat to the shower just when I needed it and then stop, so as to waste neither water or heat.

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#4

I didn't "study" the article that well......

Basil

>....but I gathered that it recirculated the hot water 'via' the cold water pipe....ergo, 90-120 degree, whatever temperture selected, water in both the hot and cold water pipes. Might work out to your advantage if all your pipes were well insulated and you never had a need for 'cool' water.

I know someone probably already makes one but what I'd like to have is a mechanical valve assembly (non-electical). One that would allow me to just dial in the water temperture I wanted, push a button and jump in the shower without having to fiddle with adjusting the valves.

Enquiring mind wants to know, does it rain in your bathroom when a woman takes a shower? Does at my house.....LOL

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#5

Re: I didn't "study" the article that well......

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...does it rain in your bathroom when a woman takes a shower?

What we did was install a small lever-operated cutoff valve just above the shower head.

To minimize water waste, I open it fully, turn on the hot water valve wide open, then count to 35 which I've found delivers fully hot water. After adjusting the hot&cold valves to suit, we cut the valve back by at least 50% during use. The little cutoff valve makes it easy to adjust the total amount of water without having to juggle the main valves to maintain the desired mix, or cut it off completely when temporarily not needed.

This not only reduces water usage, but keeps the sauna room effect to a minimum.

JKJ

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#6

You're In The Navy Now . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The little valve was invented for sailers aboard ship where unsalted water (hot & cold) was at a premium. You get wet, turn the valve off, soap up, turn it on and rinse. You can thus take a shower with as little as 1-1/2 gallons of water.

If you guys want instant hot water (like in a hotel), put in a 2-pipe hot water system with a recirculating pump, or use a supplemental in-line flash heater next to your shower that will automatically cut back as the line water heats up. A recirculating system will require a (third) return pipe and super insulating of both the hot water lines to be efficient. These convection gizmos are, IMO, huge energy wasters because they turn your supply plumbing into a big hot water heating system, and, while you may use a few less gallons of water, you will see your bill for the hot water heater really jump. I piped my WH with an anti-convection loop at the outlet side specifically to defeat the heat loss and energy waste that you guys are talking about encouraging.

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#7

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water

Bill White

>Why not just get a tankless water heater? Study up on 'em. The re-cir systems are not too thermally efficient IMO.

Bill

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#8

Some systems do work that way...

John in New Mexico

>"Personally, what I would like to have is a pump with a switch on it that would run the pump for about five or ten minutes. (You could just push the button and wait for the hot water without running it letting it run down the drain.) Or a timer to turn it on about the time I got up or headed to the shower if they were at a regular time. The idea would be to circulate the heat to the shower just when I needed it and then stop, so as to waste neither water or heat."

I think I catch your drift anyway. Ours only runs when you press a button. Pump runs until its thermostat senses hot water, around 110F. This type of on demand system doesn't waste any more energy than running the hot water, excepting the energy to run the pump.

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#9

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water

Joseph Mulherin

>I used to be in the pipe trades for 35yrs before retiring. We used to install a 1/4" return line from the upper lavatory and run it back down to the water heater and connect it to the drain valve. This way you get constant hot water circulation up to the upper bathroom by circulating the hot water ever so slowly but is readily hot for the morning bath, etc.

Refitting an already constructed house would be rather difficult, but it could be done with little repairs being done after opening up the walls and routing the 1/4" down to the WH. And it wouldn't cost you any elec. pump running time....

Re: OT: "Instant" Hot Water *LINK*

#10

Want hot water quicker ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>If you want hot water to a distant faucet quicker, run a smaller line from the water heater directly to that faucet.

Most codes require a 3/4" main hot water line thru-out the house up till it T's off to individual outlets. This whole pipe needs to be drained of cool water before the hot water arrives.

1/2" pipe has roughly 1/2 the volume of 3/4", and 3/8" has roughly 1/2 the volume of 1/2". I wouldn't go smaller than 3/8" for a sink faucet, and 1/2" for a shower/tub.

This trick works only if there is one outlet on this line from the water heater. Putting several outlets on a small line could result in pressure/flow loss when 2 or more outlets are turned on.

In the old days when galvanized pipe ruled the plumbing world, these pipes eventually limed up, thus driving codes to use larger diameter pipes. From what I know, this liming-up doesn't occur with copper or plastic pipes, thus the risk of 40 years from now having your water lines swell shut is not as likely.

As mentioned, any of those systems that cause the water to circulate and provide instant hot water will solve the time problem, but will drive up the costs of heating the water.