>I recently got a new dovetail jig and was trying some joints on scrap MDF.
Is there any reason MDF shouldn't be used for dovetailed drawer sides?? I want to make a small drawer for a bedside table out of 1/2" material with half-blind DT's. I've attempted using baltic birch so far and I've had some of the common problems in working with plywood. I don't own a planer yet so I can't mill my own 1/2" solid wood.
>A couple of points.. I don't think MDF would take a lot of wear and tear, especially where it rubs on the bottom or on a rail. Second point is that I have heard that dovetailed MDF is strong once the glue sets, but is very fragile until then, so be gentle at assembly time - don't try to make it fit with a mallet.
>I would agree with JC. I would take extra special care with assembly of the DT. 1/2" MDF is not going to give you a lot of strength while putting it together. Once you have it together, I think it would work very nicely! I would imagine that it would take all the wear that you are going to put on it as a nightstand drawer. (Assuming you are not expecting this to be passed down to your great grandchildren. LOL) As a nice inexpensive project table, I think it will work out fine. (Better than what you would find in some of these discount stores for almost $100 anyway!)
>It sounds like your problem is more about not having the capability to dress your own lumber to 1/2", you need 1/2" stock for drawer parts, dovetailing BB ply is difficult at best, so your only other choice of 1/2" stock is MDF. I'm sure this is something lots of us faced at some point but here's my problem with your reasoning:
This is not meant to be offensive but why in the world would anyone use MDF for a drawer in a night table - much less go through the work of dovetailing it just for the sake that it's a drawer? It's like putting a Lexus joint on a Pinto piece of material. That DT joint will be there long after the MDF is toast!
If already dressed 1/2" material is not available to you (sometimes you can find it at Lowes and online sources), why not use the BB ply and use a different means of joinery? Standard rabbets, and lock rabbets along with yellow glue makes strong joinery and the BB Ply will look and wear better. Also, if you use mechanical slides, the screws have something to bite into. Once you have the abilty to dress your own stock to 1/2" or can purchase it already dressed, THEN go with the dovetails!
Use wood for the drawer. Have it milled to 1/2 inch and then use dovetails, box, or other joints. MDF and dovetails will be problematic for reasons discussed above. Plywood won't be a good alternative. Use 1/2 inch poplar for your drawer boxes.
>Using MDF will be a challenge however as far as using the DT. I was underthe impession that you just wanted to use your new jig and get practice making DT's. If this is the case then MDF is a cheap alternative to buying wood stock. Myself, I can't always afford the things I WANT to do and would like to get the cheapest thing available to get the practice before using the more expensive wood. To some of you Poplar may not be expensive but to someone like me that just started a busines, bought a house and had a newborn all in one year, not much room to make typical mistakes with wood when I can get a sheet of MDF that will give me the pratice I need for about $20! That way when I can afford the wood, whether it be the "cheap stuff" or the more expensive woods, I have gotten some practice and I am less likely to have to tell the wife that I screwed up yet another piece of expensive wood and to complete the project I now must go and spend ANOTHER $100. LOL Good luck with your project, even if it is made from cardboard, you can still be proud of your experience at the end!