Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Posts

Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#1

Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Howard

>have any of you experienced this. when putting the profile on the stick cut, sometimes the edge gets torn up, even when I'm taking only half the cut. Doesn't matter if it's straight grain or wavy. Not even sure feed rate mattered, although when I went fairly quickly at 19000 rpm, the result seemed a bit better. I usually end up with 3 or 4 pieces that can't be used. I am using the matched bits and yesterday used a new set. Is it the Freud brand, my technique, appreciate your thoughts. Really makes me crazy having to junk good stuff.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#2

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

waroland

>What wood are you using?

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#3

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Howard

>It's happened to me on cherry and maple.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#4

JL

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

JL

>Maybe I'm not clear on what you are describing - are you talking about the "ends"? Or along the length?

When I do the ends on both the rails and stiles, I have a "sacrificial" board behind the piece so I won't get tear out. I've never really had any problems along the length of the rails and stiles - I usually make three passes.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#5

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Like JL said for end cuts you need a piece of scrap to support the wood where the cut exits the piece. Don't take all the stock out in one pass. Try to make the last pass a light one. If you have a variable speed router set the speed to Freud's recommendation. Experiment with your feed rate. Usually a slower feed rate will give you a cleaner cut. Too slow and you can get burning. Is your wood held securely in a jig or fixture for your coping cuts?

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#6

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Charles M

>Howard,

Sorry to hear of the problem. When working with tricky woods the best way to minimize the tear out along the groove is to make the first pass with the fence set so that the groover is only cutting about 1/16" deep. You should be able to cut full depth on the next pass.

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#7

Thanks Charles -BUT.......

Howard

>I am really surprised to hear someone describe cherry and maple as tricky woods! particularly when the cut is in straight grain wood.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#8

Ellis Walentine

If I hear you right...

Ellis Walentine

>...you are talking about the edges of the groove on the sticked edge of the stiles or rails -- not the coped cut on the ends of the rails. Maple and cherry are both woods that have a higher than average tendency for grooved edges to tear out. I would test your same cutters on some oak, pine, walnut, what-have-you, to see if you get similar results before you put all the blame on the bits.

That said, there are a couple other variables at play here. One is the diameter of the cutters. Router bits have a notoriously small cutting radius compared with shapers, stickers, molders, etc. The tighter cutting radius means the grooving cutter enters and exits the wood at a higher angle than a larger cutter would, and the result is a different array of forces on the fibers, tending to lift them (away from the grain) as opposed to pushing them ahead in a closer line with the grain.

The other variable is the tooth geometry of the cutters themselves. The rake angle and the tangential and radial taper of the tips, as well as the smoothness of the grind and the overall sharpness of the side edges all contribute to cutting performance. Different manufacturers deliver different combinations of the above and the best way to judge for yourself (apart from a good reputation, which Freud has) is to try similar cutters from different makers on the same material and see whether they both produce similar results.

Add to this that any manufacturer can produce a bad batch of cutters on a given day, and you have a pretty uneven landscape of possibilities. If you can produce better results with a different brand, I wouldn't hesitate to bring it to Freud's attention and see if they are willing to help.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#9

Re: Thanks Charles -BUT.......

Charles M

>In this operation I would certainly say that they are two species that are more prone to splintering along the groove than average.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#10

Re: If I hear you right...

Dick Coers

>To limit that tear out, set the cutter to only cut about 1/16" deep. Feed the stock using a climb cut (opposite direction that you normally cut). This cut is normally not a safe operation, but since the depth of cut is only 1/16", you can easily control it. When everything is cut at this depth, move the fence back, and make a full depth cut on all the pieces.

Another thing that can help is to machine the profile of the cutter in a sacrifical face on the fence. It will support the grain a little better during the cut. Also try to orient the grain of the board so the grain run out is facing away from the cutter. Similar to correct orientation needed to use a hand plane.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#11

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Hal Smith

>I've had the same problem and have noticed that maple tends to be a bad actor. Just finished a large oak pantry/cabinet using a new

Freud matched set as well as their new 2+2 raised panel bit. When running the sticking cuts on rails and stiles, the material tends to come off in little "splinters" for lack of a better word. The finished profile was generally OK, and I didn't lose any pieces. Had a few little nicks along the lengths on some pieces, but can live with those. I made the sticking cuts in at least three passes with first one taking only 1/16th or so as others suggested and tried to have the grain running "up and out" of the piece away from the direction of the cut. The raised panel bit (with backcutter) did OK except for some tearing along the edge of the tongue that fits in the groove on the rails and stiles. That's no problem since all the tearing is concealed when the door is assembled. I thought the coping cuts were pretty good with no tearing. I used a sled with backup piece to avoid blowout when exiting the bit. As an aside, I've had the same experience with MLCS bits as well as their premium Katana line, and also a couple of Whiteside bits I have. Don't think the make of the bit makes a difference. Just the nature of the beast. I would like to mention to the gentleman from Freud that in the video CD they furnish with the raised panel and matched stick/cope set, they show their craftsman making the raised panel cuts in one pass (they recommend three) and the sound and the appearance makes it look as though the cuts went as smooth as silk. ??? I guess for edge profile work, a router table is never going to match a shaper. Unfortunately, a lot of us, myself included, have neither the space nor budget for the latter. Good luck. Hal

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#12

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Here is where some advanced planning really pays off.

What is happening is that your cut is being run against the grain. That usually will result in splintering, sometimes severe, depending on species and angle at which the grain runs off the side edge.

The solution is to plan the direction of cut when laying out the rails and stiles.

Failing that, I have used a block plan, making a couple of passes at 45 degrees to break the edge. Make the final pass very light. You should be good to go, but know that there still could be some failures, depending on the grain.

Carol, aka formerly the 'Router Lady'

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#13

There may be a solution...

Jerry Nicholson

>I've had the same problem and my cutters are not Freud. I think the solution is to buy a shaper and a power feeder. Feed the stock in the back way (climb cut) with the power feeder and you shouldn't get chip out. Might be a little expensive though.

Jerry

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#14

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Charles M

>Hal,

Thanks for the feedback. Freud 3-1/2" raised panel bits can be used with a Freud 3-1/4HP Router properly mounted in a table to make raised panels in one pass, although we do recommend 3 or more passes.

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#15

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Hal Smith

>You answered one question. He really did make the raised panel cut in one pass. My other question; was the cut really as smooth as it sounded and appeared? I could see or hear no sign of splintering or tearout. I have a Freud FT2000E in my router table as you recommend.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#16

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Hal Smith

>Your philosophy is correct. In a perfect world it should produce consistently good results. The world of wood is not perfect however. Unless you have the luxury of wasting a lot of wood, you will have to deal with some sticks where the direction and pattern of grain change, maybe more than once, and sometimes radically throughout the length of the piece. Don't mean to be contrary, and it will certainly help if one follows your advice as much as possible. Hal

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#17

end cuts

Curt Harms

>I'll show my ignorance here-I thought the "end cut" was the cope cut-whatever. I've had this problem with oak, no surprise there, I guess. Saw an interesting idea-cut the end profiles BEFORE ripping. That way there are fewer exits from the work piece. Another thing I've done is using a coping sled, carefully do a climb cut on the back of the piece about 1/4 of the cutter, the jig makes this reasonably controllable. back away the stock, lift it out and route as normal. No tear out.

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

#18

Re: Really Mad-Freud Rail/Stile Bits

Charles M

>The sound in the video was the real deal so yes, it was a smooth cut without the sound of the splintering and popping that often accompanies large cuts. I think the primary reason is that he picked the stock well. My personal experiences are typically much louder although the cut is still smooth.

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.