Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

Posts

OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#1

OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

Dustmaker Mike

>for a GPS unit that has a built in antenna and it has not failed me yet? I see a lot of different styles to pick from. I sit in my living room 15' away from a window that faces south and get a good signal off the units antenna. I am not buying one I just wonder why?

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#2

You probably don't need an External Antenna

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Both of my GPS unit have the ability to connect to an external antenna. On some boats, the hard top can interfere with the signal so an external antenna mounted outside give a better view of the sky. I've seen the signal degrade while in the city with lots of tall buildings or in a thick forest with lots of tall trees. The external antenna may help in those situations.

Lee

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#3

Gees I should think out side the box

Dustmaker Mike

>just cause I use it one way don't mean there isn't other ways to use it.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#4

Better question... why do you need a GPS?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"... I sit in my living room 15' away from a window that faces south and get a good signal off the units antenna. ...."

Unless you're scared your house is going to move, or the living room happens to be on a yacht, why exactly would you even need a GPS?

;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#5

Shoot that is an easy answer

Dustmaker Mike

>I travel the world and drive just about every where I go. I have a Garmin Nuvi 360 I just bought cause the Tom Tom (in my PDA)I had speak went out. I was just getting the new Maps of Maylisia so when I get there next month I knew where I was going.

Mike with the Maps of Europe and the US waiting on Asia. 455,000 miles in an airline seat in 3 years oh what fun.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#6

More sky man ! . . .

steve mackay

>Without going into the triangulation mumbo-jumbo, the more sky the ant sees the more sats you " hook ". The more sats you hook the more acurate you are. In the ARMY I needed to hook seven to get a " good " launcher emplacment. I was never warm and fuzzy 'till I'd hooked nine. Just facing south you're only hooking a couple. Now-a-days I don't know how many sats are available to civilians but its more than it used to be. Remember also that with minimal sats most GPS rigs have a neat " best-guess " thing built in. So yes, more is better.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#7

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

JohnKJordan in East TN

>When you use the GPS in an automobile, it is limited to the satellites it can see through the windows, usually just the front windshield. The signals cannot move through the metal roof and pillars. It can be far less accurate when limited to fewer sats in one direction, and at times will fail to work at all. For the best results, the receiver needs to see as many satellites spaced as widely as possible in the sky.

Years ago I compared the built-in antenna to the external roof-mounted antenna and decided to always use the external for automobile. When I don't or can't put it on the roof, I lay the external antenna on the dash as far forward as possible. I don't use it on horseback. :)

BTW, depending on the house construction, you can get signals through more than the window - some may penetrate the roof and walls.

PS, I don't know the latest, but there used to be 24 satellites in orbit plus several spares; the Rockwell chip set that I'm familiar with can receive up to 12 in parallel. AFAIK, all satellites were available to civilians, but in the degraded "selective availability" mode until sometime in 2000 or so.

JKJ

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#8

24 Sats SiRF III chipsets

Dustmaker Mike

>and the world is at your finger tips. I guess I have never been in a spot where the GPS didn't work because it could not see the sky. I may have to buy an external ant. to see what differance it may make in my truck.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#9

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

Steve Schoene

>Yes, I remember well when the selective availablity was turned off. It was just AFTER I got GPS with differential capability.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#10

SA, DGPS and Loran C

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...Yes, I remember well when the selective

>availablity was turned off.

Even with SA enabled, my first GPS experiences were wonderful compared to what I had been using - Loran C! I had a portable loran unit I would use when flying, in the car, and on foot. It was about the size of a few fat paperback books so I made a strap to hang it around my neck when in the woods. In the car I had to use a 3' roof-mounted antenna. In the airplane, we would run a long wire antenna out the window and tape it to a wing strut.

The loran unit displayed only coordinates, so I carried Lat/lon maps, ruler, and calipers with me. What's worse, the long wave signals had to travel up over and down the mountains to get to East Tennessee (the transmitters were on the coasts) so the coordinates were off by about 1/2 mile in the SSW direction. I carried a programmable calculator with me and typed in each coordinate to get the correction before I plotted it on the map. When I got my first GPS, it had a screen for tracking (still no maps), but it was good to a few hundred yards. Zounds!

These days I'm still amazed when I look at my WAAS GPS and it reports 9' accuracy.

As for SA and DGPS, I thought it so ironic that one part of our government spent money to degrade the GPS signals, while other parts (i.e., Coast Guard) spent millions to defeat it. Only in America.

JKJ, hardcore card-carryin' map freak

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#11

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

Steve Schoene

>My first experience with Loran involved a unit in a box at least 15" x 15" by 24" high. It only gave Loran TD's (time differences) which could only be plotted on charts specifically printed with the TD lines overlayed on the lat./lon. coordinates. Graphic interpolation was required. This was courtesy of the US Navy.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#12

I'm gonna attach one to my @#!% car keys.

Tom MacGregor

>

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#13

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...Loran involved a unit in a box at least 15" x 15" by 24" high.

Did it have nixie tube readouts on the front? I had one of those on loan from the Navy for a while. I couldn't figure out how to mount it on the dash of my car.

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

#14

Re: OT Why do I Need an External Antenna

Jerry Nicholson

>I bought an external antenna with my Garmin 350 but found that the Garmin works great just laying on the console in my wifes Chrysler 300C. When I tried the external antenna, the Garmin might have initially acquired satellites slightly faster but I found I didn't really need it at all. It did get lost on US400 in eastern Kansas but it wasn't lack of satellites - I think the map is screwed up there. My daughter borrowed my GPS and it got lost in the same place coming from the other direction.

Jerry