Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

Posts

OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#1

OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

Chuck T

>Hey there folks. There's a LOT of collective wisdom up here on the boards, so I thought I'd try seeking some advice for a situation I find myself in. This is LONG and I apologize, but if you have the patience to read I'd appreciate advice on how best to handle this.

We had our front hallway, dining rooom, living room, and upstairs hallway floors redone with Bruce oak pre-finished hardwood floors just before Christmas. Total square footage was probably around 1000 - 1200 sq ft, and the total price for materials and install ended up at around $5700.

We made the purchase through a local flooring dealer who subcontracted the work out. The installers were 2 young guys (early 20's - mid 20's) from Brazil I believe. In any case, they removed the old W2W carpet from the LR/DR, and the parquet flooring from the front hallway and the upstairs hallway. But they did NOT remove the particle board underlayment that sits on top of the 3/4" ply subfloor (which I discovered when I got home that day - I unfortunately had to work). Anyway - towards the end of the day I got home to discover that they had nicked a baseboard hot water heating pipe in the front hallway which of course flooded the area before my wife got the master shut off turned off. They stopped for the day without installing the flooring in the front hall so that we could get the pipe repaired and offered to pay for the repair.

A plumber friend came and fixed us up that night, and we contacted the flooring store who confirmed they would pay the bill. But then I began to look at the flooring that had been installed in the LR/DR. I noticed that on several places the board ends did not match up evenly (where they butt together) and were in some plavces off by about 1/32". Not a lot - but noticeable, and you'd definitely feel it as significant running your hand over it. This raised concerns about it eventually chipping. We also noticed in several areas they had used a nail gun to drive staples or nail into the top face of the flooring around the perimeter. Near the edges, but leaving noticable divits in the top face of the flooring.

So the flooring store representative came out the next day and looked it all over with my wife. He pointed out that the floor was not totally level in the area where the worst misalignments appeared, and explained that these end to end slight mismatches were nothing out of the ordinary and that you need to be more concerned about mismatches in levels from side edge to side edge as these were more prone to chipping and splintering. They completed the job that day and then I got home to discover that with the new flooring in the front hall, the front door would barely open. The new flooring was 3/4" thick as compared to the 1/4 - 3/8" thickness of the previous parquet flooring. They ended up having to remove the weather stripping from the bottom of my relatively new front doors to get it to open and there is no room now for an entry carpet to protect the HW floor. In any case, because it was just before the holidays we signed off on the job and made out final payment figuring we'd just have to live with it.

It is now a month later and we are noticing that indeed there were more areas where the flooring was not perfectly level on the long edges and we are seeing chipping of the finish and minor splintering in those areas. The more we think about it we realized that the reason the flooring may not have been level was that when they removed the carpet/parquet flooring they left the somewhat rough particle board underlayment. We believe that this should have been removed totally. This would have left the floor at a proper height to fit with clearance under the front door too.

In our opinion, the flooring really ought to be taken back out (only the edges were nailed/glued down according to my wife, so they could re-use the majority of it. Then the old particle board subfloor should be ripped out and have a new underlayment put down for a perfectly flat surface to reinstall the hardwood on top of.

Does this sound correct? We paid almost $6000 to get this flooring and have it installed by a professional so it would be done right. They never advised that they should remove the old underlayment - and I would have paid the extra labor to do so if that was what was required for a correct install. We have not approached the flooring store yet, to see about what they suggest to do, but I have a feeling they'll want us to just use the chip crayon to try and cover over the problem areas. What recourse do we have at this point?

Any thoughts or advice would be greatly appreciated. We probably should have just bought the material and found our own installer. But hidsight as they say . . . .

ChuckT

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#2

For six grand . . .

steve mackay

>you, the customer, should get a NEW floor from the bottom up. Including sub-floor etc. and anything the manufacturer requiers for the warrantee. Besides that, for six grand, when you walk in the house you should be FLOORED ( sorry ) be the job they did. If you can notice it from a standing position ITS POOR WORKMANSHIP ! When it cups in six months they'll wash their hands of you. No gaps, scratches, un-levels, warps, nuth'n. And two young'uns all on their own with no supervision ? No way.

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#3

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice req

Barry Irby

>You should go to Bruce Flooring web site and print out their installation guide lines. Also, Go to The National Oak Flooring Manufacturers Association's (NOFMA)web site and print out their guidelines.

I have not looked lately, but I think you will find that particle board is not permitted as a sub floor material.

And, there is a nailing schedule for each thickness and width of flooring. To find the nails you can buy a few of the very powerful ceramic magnets. (Available from Woodcraft and others). Separated the magnets and slide them down the joints in the flooring and they will stick to the nails that should be driven in the edges. This should tell you if they used an appropriate number of nails.

These people are "the Pro's" and they should have pointed out to you that they might have to remove the subfloor, even if there had been an up charge. And they should have warned you about the situation with the door.

If I am correct about the guidelines, you have a basis to take them to court if you must.

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#4

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice req

Chuck T

>Thanks guys. Much appreciated. I did go to the Armstrong/Bruce flooring site and downloaded their installation information and sure enough - you're NOT supposed to use particle board for the subfloor. So now we are going to have to do battle with them to get it remedied. I have a feeling they'll resist, so I may have to take them to court. Am I entitled to get my legal fees refunded by them if I win? What a pain in the butt.

Ah well.

Thanks again!

ChuckT

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#5

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice req

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>One step at a time. Call the store, be nice and cordial and explain the situation to them. Let them know that the installation is not acceptable, but don't tell them what you want them to do. Instead, see what they're willing to do for you. If they take care of you, great. If not, let them know that you have a particle board substrate, that you've researched it and now know that's not an acceptable according to the manufacturer, that the floor was installed by their recomended team and ask them agian if they want to take care of this, and if so, how.

If they still say your on your own, ask them to please send you a notice in writing outlining their position and what they're going to do and not do. Suggest that if they have it ready in an hour, you'll pick it up. Hint that you have things to do with that letter but never actually say "lawyer".

When you get off the phone, call Bruce and ask for their customer service manager. Explain (calmly) what's occurred and that one of their representatives has installed a floor against the manufactures recommendations and see what options are available to you. If the seller is "certified", you may want to request a copy of the criteria for certification. If the installer is certified, I'd ask for similar and also ask for a copy of the company's certification.

Chances are things will work out. They usually do, but if not, the next thing to do is to contact Bruce again, advise them that you have no choice but to follow legal recourse and ask them to send out an expert to provide an opinion on the floor and it's install. Chances are that will shake the tree and they'll do right by you but if not, you may want to contact the lawyer and have him there as an observer when Bruce comes out. If things still don't work out - take off the gloves.

Good luck!

Rob

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#6

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice req

Barry Irby

>Chuck, I am not a lawyer and I don't play one on Wood Central, but I am a Home Inspector and do a lot of Expert Witness testimony in local courts. I don't even know what state you are in and It would not do any good to tell me, because I still would not know what the local laws were. Here In Virginia, it is very difficult to get the defendant to pay your legal fees. It Seems obvious that they should, but the courts are reluctant to do this. It would change the entire "texture" of the system if it were fair. Check with a local attorney.

I do think you have a right to have the flooring installed according to the manufacuter's directions, even if they did not state it and you were not aware that such directions existed. Armstrong/Bruce has an established "brand" and works hard to maintain it so that they can claim their position in the market.

PS, In the vein of "the Cobbler's children have no shoes" I have Bruce hardwood flooring that I installed myself. I thought that the finish was some sort of industrial super tough type stuff. If I had known how fragile the finish realeyez as, I would have screened it and applied a good coat or two of urethin. The finish on it was thin and very poor and not durable.

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

FWIW...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I have installed a little bit of prefinished flooring, more unfinished, seen yet more prefinished installed, refinished quite a bit, and walked on even more of both.

I have NEVER been impressed by prefinished hardwood flooring. Period. Bevels and microbevels do three things: hide unevenness, trap dirt and make refinishing more difficult. I've even been on a few prefinished floors that had no bevel and I could feel every last misaligned joint with my shoes--manufacturing shortcoming, not installer error.

At the end of the day, there's a reason prefinished hardwood is ~$5/s.f. installed. The last time I installed unfinished red oak, I charged about $8/s.f. for materials, installation and finishing. That including tearing up some linoleum in a hallway and adjusting the floor level in there.

I think you got some good advice from the other guys. Give the supplier a few opportunities to make it right before you head to court.

Jason

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#8

Words from a "pro"

Andy Halterman: Finally some winter weather

>Once I got to the part where you said you bought Bruce flooring, I didn't even need to read the rest. I'm going to partially invoke the "can't say anything nice" rule when it comes to Bruce products. I refuse to work with their stuff anymore. Far to many problems like the ones you describe as well as big variance in width from board to board as well as along single boards.

Basically I think the stuff if finished firewood.

You got a cheap price. I would have charged you a bunch more to pull out the particle board and use some real prefinished flooring. Bear in mind also that I would have thoroughly checked the job over prior to giving you a bid so you knew exactly what I had in mind when you got that heart-stopping estimate.

Sorry my man, but, I could have saved you some headaches had you posted up prior to the project.

Andy Halterman

Quite particular about his choices in flooring materials in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#9

I take a few words

Dustmaker Mike

>I am redoing one of my bed rooms on the second floor into an office. I was going to use a prefinished floor for two reasons. One is I don't have the time nor the money to have a non finished floor put down. Two it can't be over 1/2" or it will not be level to the carpet. I have 3/4" T&G sub floor and was going to put down a 1/4 laune to level it out. So any recommandations. Feel free to E-mail if you want to answer off line.

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#10

Not a pro by any means but... *LINK*

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I did two rooms a couple years back. When I researched prefinished flooring quality, I got recommendations (might have been here, probably the FHB forum) for Mirage brand. I did one room with their lower-grade birch - They call it "traditional" now. As a woodworker, I have to say that the quality of the product was first-rate - the machining, the finish, the wood itself. It was just beautiful, well made stuff, and the finish seems to be holding up well. I've used some of the leftovers for trim and such just because it was such nice wood. I have at least one more room to do and plan to use one of their products.

I'm curious to hear Andy H's opinion too.

BTW, the second room was with bamboo. Pretty stuff, but the finish is very brittle and chips easily. I wouldn't use that manufacturer again. I can't remember the name offhand, but will look if you want.

Hope this helps.

Ken


http://www.miragefloors.com/floors/collections/naturels_merisier_traditionnel.html

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#11

Re: Not a pro by any means but...

Steve Schoene

>Ken, I would appreciate if you could find the manufacturer of the bamboo flooring that didn't work so well. I've been thinking I would install bamboo in a room in my house and don't want to make a mistake.

Steve (also in CT)

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#12

Re: I take a few words

Andy Halterman: Finally some winter weather

>I'll post up something later today as I've got to get out of here in just a few. I'll start a new thread up to for you.

Andy

Re: OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request

#13

Bamboo brand

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Steve, it was Hawa brand, and it was the "carbonized". It was fine otherwise, but while laying it had a tool or two drop onto the finished floor, (not anything really heavy, either) and the finish kind of shattered in that spot. By contrast, on the Mirage birch that I was raving about, there was just a little dent when I dropped something heavy, and unless you know just where to look, an invisible one at that.

Hope this helps. I got my flooring (both types, if memory serves) from a distributor somewhere out Waterbury way. Delivery was cheap, on the order of $30. I did tell them I was a contractor, as that's who they want to deal with, but they didn't check that in any way. I can hunt around for the name if you want.

Ken