OT - HW flooring installer dispute -advice request
Chuck T
>Hey there folks. There's a LOT of collective wisdom up here on the boards, so I thought I'd try seeking some advice for a situation I find myself in. This is LONG and I apologize, but if you have the patience to read I'd appreciate advice on how best to handle this.
We had our front hallway, dining rooom, living room, and upstairs hallway floors redone with Bruce oak pre-finished hardwood floors just before Christmas. Total square footage was probably around 1000 - 1200 sq ft, and the total price for materials and install ended up at around $5700.
We made the purchase through a local flooring dealer who subcontracted the work out. The installers were 2 young guys (early 20's - mid 20's) from Brazil I believe. In any case, they removed the old W2W carpet from the LR/DR, and the parquet flooring from the front hallway and the upstairs hallway. But they did NOT remove the particle board underlayment that sits on top of the 3/4" ply subfloor (which I discovered when I got home that day - I unfortunately had to work). Anyway - towards the end of the day I got home to discover that they had nicked a baseboard hot water heating pipe in the front hallway which of course flooded the area before my wife got the master shut off turned off. They stopped for the day without installing the flooring in the front hall so that we could get the pipe repaired and offered to pay for the repair.
A plumber friend came and fixed us up that night, and we contacted the flooring store who confirmed they would pay the bill. But then I began to look at the flooring that had been installed in the LR/DR. I noticed that on several places the board ends did not match up evenly (where they butt together) and were in some plavces off by about 1/32". Not a lot - but noticeable, and you'd definitely feel it as significant running your hand over it. This raised concerns about it eventually chipping. We also noticed in several areas they had used a nail gun to drive staples or nail into the top face of the flooring around the perimeter. Near the edges, but leaving noticable divits in the top face of the flooring.
So the flooring store representative came out the next day and looked it all over with my wife. He pointed out that the floor was not totally level in the area where the worst misalignments appeared, and explained that these end to end slight mismatches were nothing out of the ordinary and that you need to be more concerned about mismatches in levels from side edge to side edge as these were more prone to chipping and splintering. They completed the job that day and then I got home to discover that with the new flooring in the front hall, the front door would barely open. The new flooring was 3/4" thick as compared to the 1/4 - 3/8" thickness of the previous parquet flooring. They ended up having to remove the weather stripping from the bottom of my relatively new front doors to get it to open and there is no room now for an entry carpet to protect the HW floor. In any case, because it was just before the holidays we signed off on the job and made out final payment figuring we'd just have to live with it.
It is now a month later and we are noticing that indeed there were more areas where the flooring was not perfectly level on the long edges and we are seeing chipping of the finish and minor splintering in those areas. The more we think about it we realized that the reason the flooring may not have been level was that when they removed the carpet/parquet flooring they left the somewhat rough particle board underlayment. We believe that this should have been removed totally. This would have left the floor at a proper height to fit with clearance under the front door too.
In our opinion, the flooring really ought to be taken back out (only the edges were nailed/glued down according to my wife, so they could re-use the majority of it. Then the old particle board subfloor should be ripped out and have a new underlayment put down for a perfectly flat surface to reinstall the hardwood on top of.
Does this sound correct? We paid almost $6000 to get this flooring and have it installed by a professional so it would be done right. They never advised that they should remove the old underlayment - and I would have paid the extra labor to do so if that was what was required for a correct install. We have not approached the flooring store yet, to see about what they suggest to do, but I have a feeling they'll want us to just use the chip crayon to try and cover over the problem areas. What recourse do we have at this point?
Any thoughts or advice would be greatly appreciated. We probably should have just bought the material and found our own installer. But hidsight as they say . . . .
ChuckT



