Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

Posts

Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#1

Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

Bob Falk, Madison

>Help! I went to my local woodworking store and bought some no-name (Made in China) Forstner bits for a project. What a mistake. Though I was cutting end grain hard maple, they cut terrible. Before I take the plunge in buying some better quality bits, I was hoping to get some opinions on brands (Freud, CMT, Others? etc). I need to bore up to about 2" in diameter. In cruising the web, bits vary from about $10 each (China) to nearly $100 (Germany).

BTW, I have some old Freud bits that cut well (smaller sizes), however there seem to be some low opinions of Freud on Amazon, so I am wondering if quality has changed.

Any opinions would be greatly appreciated

Thanks, bob

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#2

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

John Weber

>I just did the exact same thing. Bought cheap bits - junk. Ended up with a set of Freud bits, but also liked the CMT and Lee Valley sets. I'm very pleased with my Freud set.

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#3

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

Chuck W

>Lee Valley Forstner bits seem to get a good rap on this and other forums. You may pay a little more up front but the end result is worth it. I know because I bought a cheap "made in china" set of Forstners which turned out to be junk( no pun intended).

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#4

carbide

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Bob,

I don't remember brands, but I bought two sets of forstner bits from Woodcraft - one is HSS and the other is carbide. There is no comparison - the carbide cuts better and cooler and stays sharp, especially in long end grain holes. (I did some long 1" and 1.5" holes recently with an extension in very hard woods to make pepper mills.)

JKJ

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#5

Re: carbide

Doug Ring

>McMaster-Carr shows carbide-tipped 2" Forstner bits for ~$48. Not sure of the brand, but a few years back I used a 1.25" carbide tipped bit from them to drill a couple of hundred holes in ESD bench tops (very thick melamine and particle board core), and the one bit showed very minimal wear at the end of the project. They will gladly sell to individuals, and usually ship the same day the order is placed.

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#6

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits *LINK*

Charles M

>The Amazon reviews that are negative are by users that show their lack of knowledge of Forstner Bits. Forstners are basically two rotary chisels chisels and HSS bits will require regular sharpening (like a chisel) to maintain the cutting edge and low RPMs to avoid damaging heat build up. Ours are made in Austria and have long been considered among the best available. If you are interested in Carbide tipped Forstner Bits like others have mentioned, Freud was the first to offer these and you can find more info at the link below.

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.


http://www.freudtools.com/p-296-carbide-forstner-bitsbr-nbsp.aspx

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#7

It's Not Just The Brand Of Bit

Dave's Not Here

>The correct RPM speed of the drill or drill press is critical when drilling with any type bit including forstner bits. Make sure that you use the correct RPM speed that matches the size of the bit you're using and also the type of material being drilled into.

I've used Freud forstner bit for years and have always gotten excellent results with them as long as I've followed the above advice.

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#8

Re: It's Not Just The Brand Of Bit

Bob Falk, Madison

>Thanks for the response.....I, like JKJordan (woodturner Jordan?), am making peppermills.....sounds like Freud will be ok...will look into carbide.

Cheers, Bob

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#9

Re: It's Not Just The Brand Of Bit

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>... JKJordan (woodturner Jordan?),

I have been called a woodturner, and other things. :)

BTW, I am not the other John Jordan, who happens to be the same age and also lives in TN.

I used the carbide bits in cocobolo, dogwood, oak and other hard woods. When drilling long holes on the lathe, I constantly blew compressed air into the hole behind the bit to clear the chips and to help keep things cool. The two mills I did recently (image attached) used the ceramic CrushGrind mechanism. (I posted this earlier on the Turning forum, so sorry if it's a rehash.)

JKJ


img

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#10

JL

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

JL

>You can get the carbide tipped bits - just make sure that they have a sharpening service.

You can touch up your HSS inexpensive ones and they will work okay for a while. I sharpen mine or touch them up with a diamond hone every once in a while.

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#11

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>It could be the end grain. But, are you running them slow enough? I hate to buck the trend here, but I have a cheap set that has worked quite well. Over the last 8 years, I have burnt a few of them pretty bad to the point that they won't hold an edge very long. So, I've replaced them with carbide assuming they are my higher use bits. I just drilled a ton of holes in hard maple over the last couple weekends installing my vices on my bench and they still cut fast and clean. The caveat is that they cut fast and clean at a slow speed on my drill press. They've never cut well at higher speeds or in a handheld drill.

Jay

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#12

Very nice!

Bob Falk, Madison

>ok, even if you are not the John Jordan of Woodturning fame (hollow vessels, Stubby lathes) you do good work. My compliments!

Re: Need opinion on buying Forstner Bits

#13

Re: carbide

Dick Coers------WebKitFormBoundaryqFOmq51H3saAc+aC

>I'll second the referral to get the carbide from Woodcraft. They have very long side spurs and will almost eliminate the need to flip the stock over to limit chipping. Almost no trouble with the bits clearing the chips like steel bits. I've locked a couple of steel bits in the wood by not clearing them enough. Almost never need to do that with the carbide. I suspect they will be a "once in a lifetime" buy. Can't imagine using them up.