Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT noise cancelling earphones

Posts

OT noise cancelling earphones

#1

OT noise cancelling earphones

tom norton

>I am wanting to get a pair but am not willing to pay for Bose! I see sets for $50 approx.

Any suggestions? It is for air travel and MP3 use

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#2

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

Barry Irby

>I bought a set of the Bose and brought them home. I was not impressed and neither were my sons. We played with them for a few minutes and I returned them. Not nearly what I expected. Seemed to reduce background noise about 20%. (Just an estimate, but they were not nearly as effective as my shooters muffs.)

I bought my son a set at Walmart for about $39 and he used them on the long fight to the middle east. He was reasonably happy with those. They seemed nearly as good as the Bose and at $39 they seemed much more realistic than the Bose at $300.

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#3

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones *LINK*

Scott in Montana

>I'm afraid that you will be disappointed in almost any noise canceling headphones you might try. The majority of these are designed for eliminating specific frequencies, such as the drone of an aircraft's engines. Even though it seems like they would use the simple principle of summing an inverted signal of the unwanted noise to the audio signal, it is much more complex than that. Consequentially, the ones that work cost $200 and more per pair.

If you are looking to eliminate much of the shop noise, you might try the in-the-ear style headphones such as those made by Etymotic. They start around $60-$70 per pair and sound pretty darn good. They achieve noise reduction just like ear plugs and offer 20db of noise reduction. And they have a pair specifically equalized for the iPod and like sources.

There is lots of information on these and all types of headphones available at a website for a company called Headroom, who's only business is headphones.

Best of luck,

Scott


Headroom website

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#4

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

Bill Earl

>I have several types, including the Bose. I use them for air travel, as well as for work in noisy environments.

Active noise cancellation such as the Bose, is effective at reducing low-frequency noise, such as the hum of aircraft engines. It does not do much for high frequency noise like the hiss of the aircraft air-conditioning system.

The full-cup 'over-ear' version of the Bose (and clones) does a better job of passive noise reduction than the 'on-ear' version.

'In-Ear' noise isolation earphones such as Etymotic and Shure, are more effective at filtering out higher frequency noise. They don't help as much with the low frequency.

For internation flights, or long days in the equipment room, I often wear a pair of Shures underneath a pair of Bose.

Panasonic makes a decent pair of Bose clones for quite a bit less. The electronics seem to be almost as good. However, I find the earcups to be a little cramped.

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#5

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

David Sparks

>I bought a set of Bose noise canceling headphones on Ebay for $57.00. They aren't the current model and have the battery pack in the cord instead of in the headphones. That doesn't bother me. The headphones work great. If you look around on Ebay, I'm sure you can find a bargain.

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#6

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones *LINK*

Derek

>As others have said, the noise canceling headphones only cancel low frequency noise. I have a pair of Senheiser's *see link). THey work well on planes and similar places. I use them at the gym sometimes and they get rid of a lot of noise there.

I tried the in-ear Shure's (and some cheaper ones). I do not like them at all. Actually, they made my ears bleed due to irritation fitting them into the ears. They are awkward to get in and tend to fall out easily - at least for me.

The most comfortable phones for me are old Sony MDR-V6 phones. They are over-ear phones and are famous for studio use. They are still available. They are not noise canceling but work well for blocking noise and are reasonably priced. I use them when working to block out distractions and people need to tap me on the shoulder to get my attention most of the time. I can wear these for hours.

If you can, I suggest trying on different pairs before deciding. People's ears can be very different and this is truly a place where you need to find what works for you.


http://www.amazon.com/Sennheiser-Active-Noise-Canceling-Headphones/dp/B000089GN2/ref=pd_bbs_2_s9_rk?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&s9r=8a1080b61135d2bb0111381b017c005f&itemPosition=2&qid=1200928533&sr=1-2

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#7

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>These might be bigger than you want. I use regular Peltons in the shop with the mp3 ear buds under them and they work great.If I was going to buy something new these are what I would probably purchase.


Pelton

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones

#8

Re: OT noise cancelling earphones *LINK*

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I tried a pair of the Rockler ones. What I found was that they actually amplified noises that were under the cut off sound level. If you turned up the microphone enough to hear music playing from the radio, they would amplify noise coming from say a hand drill to where it was annoying. The microphone for hearing was very directional. so you couldn't actually hear some one to the side or behind you all that well. They did cut off loud noise pretty effectively, but no better than my Peltor ear muffs. The sound amplification was the most annoying part. I returned them.

Lee


img

Rockler Ear Protectors