Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT: Learning to weld...

Posts

OT: Learning to weld...

#1

OT: Learning to weld...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

Sorry for the OT, but several times in the past few weeks something has come up in the shop where I needed to weld something. Does anyone know of any good resources for learning this skill? I plan on checking local adult education programs, but I fear there are none around here close.

Thanks for the info,

Rob Hix

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#2

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...something has come up in the shop where I needed to weld something

Rob,

Yikes, if your woodworking shop looks anything like mine, I hope you don't actually weld "in the shop"!! :)

What kinds of things do you want to weld? I know you didn't ask about the kinds of welding and equipment options, but that makes a difference.

If you primarily want to weld thinner materials (less than 1/4" or so), a wire welder is extremely easy to learn to use. You can easily read a bit in a book and weld up a project the same evening. You can get one at the box stores for around $300 that works with flux core wire which saves the cost and complexity of setting up a gas tank with regulators, hoses, etc. The biggest drawback with flux core wire is it spatters all over the place, so it's harder to do pretty work.

A wire welder is far easier to learn than stick welding. Small wire welders are 110v.

Stick welding is better for thick materials, such as for farm equipment repair. If you get a stick welder, get an AC/DC welder instead of a straight AC "buzz box". Stick welders are 220v.

Gas welding is great for very thin steel and for brazing, but it is tricker than either type of electric welding. Even if you use an electric welder, an oxyacetylene rig is fantastic to have around to use with a cutting torch and to heat thick steel for bending. BTW, brazing is a very strong way to join a variety of metals including steel.

As for learning, both of the big box stores usually carry excellent books on welding that cover gas, stick, wire, etc. The books explain the theory, safety, and techniques and suggest practice exercises. You can certainly learn stick and gas welding from a book, but if you can spend a 1/2 hour with an experienced welder it may be all the instruction you need to get started. Welding is like anything else - practice, practice.

Although I was a welding inspector for years (bridges, buildings, and shop welding), I never learned to weld until about 10 years ago when I first got a wire welder, then a gas rig, then a stick welder. Having welding capability certainly gives you a new perspective about holding things together. Unstead of scratching my head to figure out the best way to join things, I'm just as likely to weld up a bracket now.

If you don't have a steel supplier handy, check local fabrication shops - some will resale from their stock - one near here will make one cut without charge which is handy since stock comes in 20' lengths. The fabrication shops also tend to have piles of offcuts they will sell by the pound or by the guess. Many shops will give you small pieces for practice if you tell them you are learning to weld. Don't even THINK of buying steel from the box stores unless you own a diamond mine somewhere. A few years ago I ran into a guy who was clearing out his machine shop and I bought about 8000 lbs of stock (rods, square tubing, angle iron, strips) at scrap prices - right before the price of steel shot up!

Oh, and don't forget you'll have to have good ways to cut steel. My favorite is a portaband bandsaw, followed by a reciprocical saw using a blade called "The Torch", followed by a 14" abrasive cutoff wheel. The cutoff wheel will make perfect square ends, but it can throw fire a long way. It is best to always have a "fire watcher" when abrasive cutting and welding.

Some other things needed or useful:

- side angle grinder

- wire brushes and abrasive wheels for the grinder

- bench grinder (metal work is dirty - keep away from woodworking machines)

- helmet (auto-darkening is easiest to use and cheap these days)

- magnifying insert for helmet if you need reading glasses

- many clamps (large-opening vice grip clamps are great)

- magnets

- long, heavy guage 220v extension cord (if you need to weld outside)

- protective clothing - apron, sleeves

- hand wire brushes, slag hammer

- welding table - steel and/or firebrick top

- protective blanket (if you weld on vehicles or equipment)

BTW, the first thing I did when I got my wire welder was to repair a broken blade guard bracket on my old radial arm saw that I had wired together about 20 years earlier - all it took was one touch with the welder!

JKJ

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#3

A local voc/adult ed course is your best bet

Forrest Addy

>A local voc/adult ed course is your best bet but if that is not available to you, a local mentor is an invaluable resource.

I learned my manual skills from others. I've taught many people the basic of welding. Believe me its far better to learn what you need to know from people who know what they are doing than from those who presume to know. I refer to a local welding teacher who has served an apprenticeship and has credentive of compentency as opposed to the usual self taught shade tree welder. If you learn correctly from the start you won't have to un-learn when you run into trouble later.

The peripheral welding knowledge base (joint perparation, fit-up, basic metalworking skills, welding lore, filler metal compatibility, heat and distortion control, procedures, certifications and qualifications, etc) take a full four year apprenticeship to master. Welding is a full trade the mastery of which is an adult livelihood.

That said the actual manual welding skills take but a few hours to learn and a few weeks of on and off practice to master well enough for basic home welding. You will need some hands on training from a good teacher. Trade school libraties, mititary training manuals, welding equipment manufacturers pampphlets, etc abound and the home welder wanna-be has but to look aroud a little to find plenty of materials to study and nowadays video tapes and DVD's.

I'm quite sure that Hobart offers a very good video with their entry level MIG machines. Maybe other do too.

You will get lots of conflicting advise about welding. Try to connect the validity of the advise with your perception of the competency of your putative advisor. My own contribution is this: never weld over dirt, rust, or paint. You will not "just burn through it". The weld deposit will be ievitably contaminated to the detrement of strength and reliability. Weld only clean metal.

Good corrected color vision is necessary for good welding. If you have uncorrectible vision problems, welding can be a bigger chore than you bargained for.

I will take a look and log back in with some links. Meantime look for home welding course materials at the major welding equipment manufacturer's websites - like Lincoln, Miller, ESAB, Hobart and so on.

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#4

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Wow John,

That was a thorough response. Basically what I am looking for it the occasional (and very occasional) use. For instance, this week I came up with a nice idea for a long tool rest for my Shopsmith lathe. I need this soon for some chair legs, etc. After checking with a local machine shop, this nothing fancy tool rest was relegated to my memory. I can handle the cutting even if I have to use a hack saw. The grinder I have, and I even have an angle grinder. I have a lot of old file from my grand-father-in-law (he was a machinist). Most of what I would be doing would be no more than 1/4" thickness. Probably most of it square and round tube. Maybe some bar stock.

Thanks for the response. I will be sure to save it away for future reference.

Rob Hix

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#5

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I disagree a LITTLE...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>You don't HAVE to learn from someone else. But, if you have the time and resources to do so, do get instruction as Forrest laid out. A little reading will help you immensely.

I say this not as an experienced welder, but as someone who has done a little out of necessity and opportunity.

My first experience with a welder is a ladder rack that still sits on my truck almost 10 years later with no broken welds. The welding was done in my FIL's farm shop with a MIG welder. Some of the welds are prettier than others, but in 6 hours, I had cut all the pieces with his metal bandsaw, laid it all out and welded it all together (use heavy tarps if you weld over a windshield...live and learn). This is the second truck this ladder rack has been on, and I drive trucks, like, well, trucks, if you know what I mean.

At some point along the way, I picked up a 200-220A AC "buzzbox" stick welder. It's definitely not for thin metal (<1/8"), but was actually pretty easy to use (with the right rod) on a piece of 1/4" steel that holds my truck's spare tire (long story, previous owner was a welder, welded up a hitch with a tire carrier that had to be cut out for a repair). Last I checked, that tire is still under there. With the bed off, I jumped up and down on the plate to test it.

Again, it boils down to time, resources and need. Personally, I wouldn't do any welding with a major structural element of something (building I-beam or vehicle frame), but I will tackle minor repairs and such with some degree of confidence, but that's mainly because I'm a die-hard DIYer. Even if something takes me 2-4 times as long as a pro, I like doing it for the experience and general knowledge.

Jason

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#6

A question Forrest....

John in New Mexico

>"Good corrected color vision is necessary for good welding. If you have uncorrectible vision problems, welding can be a bigger chore than you bargained for."

I'm afraid I don't understand the logic of this statement. Good near vision is certainly important, it'd be a real pain to flip your hood down and have to try to focus through bifocals only to find yourself looking at the inside of your hood. But color? All looks kinda greenish to me through the glass filter.

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: A question Forrest....

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I'm guessing (based again on my limited knowledge of welding and metallurgy), but the good color vision isn't for during the welding, but the assessment of the weld afterwards--the color of the metal around the weld indicates that it got to the correct temperature to bond well.

Jason

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#8

Re: A question Forrest....

Forrest Addy

>I was thinking about color discrimination, seeing the margin of the puddle Vs the protective slag. Welding is a visual skill. There's little tactile or other feedback in the welding. It's all in what the eyes see.

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#9

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>... I came up with a nice idea for a long tool rest

It sounds to me that an inexpensive wire welder will do all you need. I used mine when I build a 14" long tool rest for my small lathe. I ground a saddle and bevel in a 3/4" solid rod then welded a 1/2" steel round rod to the top. As usual, preparing and aligning the metal is 95% of the job, the actual welding takes little effort.

BTW, the concern Forrest expresed about "seeing the margin of the puddle Vs the protective slag" does not apply to wire welders. There is no covering of molten protective slag as you get with stick welding. The heat of the electrical current vaporizes the flux core to make a shield gas as it melts the steel. Unlike using a shield gas like argon to protect the weld, this is sloppy, causing all kinds of splatter around the weld. But when you are done with the pass, there is very little of what you might call slag to remove - mostly spatter and a thin coating of powdery residue that should be removed with a hand-held wire brush. I'm sure you could weld effectively with a wire welder even if totally color blind with one eye closed and the vision in the other a little fuzzy! (although as I mentioned, a closeup lens in the helmet is a great help)

When you look at the specs for wire welders, don't be surprised if it limits the steel thickness to 1/8" or 3/16". You can easily weld thicker steel if you prepare the joint with a proper gap and use several overlapping passes. What you will miss is deeper penetration (the depth to which the base metal is melted) compared to a higher-powered welder with larger wire. However, for most applications around the shop and house, this is not critical. Welding girders for a building or cable brackets for suspended loads would be a different story! I have welded 1/2" plate and many joints of 1/4" thick square tubing with a lowly flux-core wire welder.

I forgot to mention some important accessories:

- I keep good wirecutters handy for clipping the end of the wire

- welding gloves! Wire welding does NOT require the very heavy and awkward welding gloves usually used for stick welding. Being right-handed, I use a traditional thick welding glove on my left hand (for holding onto hot metal!) and a thinner leather glove with a gauntlet sleeve on the right. This makes it far easier to manipulate the gun and work the trigger. The gauntlet sleeve helps keep hot spatter off the wrist.

A word about sunburn: the ultraviolet light from welders will burn your skin just as if you stayed out in the sun too long. Even in the summer, cover all skin. The same light will burn the surface of your cornea if unprotected. I discussed this once with my eye surgeon who said there should be no internal eye damage and the cornea should should heal in a day. Note that some autodarkening helmets are relatively "slow" in switching to the dark state and professional welders have complained about itching eyes (cornea burns) after using one for hours. This should not be a problem for casual use.

I learned this about autodarkening helmets most today are powered by light from the welder. I had one go bad by keeping it in a dark cabinet for months. I revived it with exposure to the sun. I keep two helmets now and I store both under a fluorescent light that stays on all the time.

One other thing about wire welders. A new one typically comes with a small spool of flux-core wire, but it will take a larger spool. (You might have to buy a cheap plastic hub adapter or make one) Save the small spool for when you run out on a Saturday evening. Buy a larger (10 lb, I think) spool and you will save yourself the hassle of running out of wire and rethreading the machine as often.

JKJ

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#10

If no community college class will work......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....then try calling the local union hall for some names of guys that are in the ironworker shops....they may personally know someone who regularly teaches on the side for $$$.

Also, call or look into steel fabrication shops or even larger plumbers in your area, they may have someone who would teach for extra beer money.

Ive often wanted to learn myself and these actual field professionals will get my call when the time comes.

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#11

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

ScottS

>Lots of good advice already, but I'll throw in my two cents anyway.

I've been a woodworker on and off for about either years. I learned to weld a couple of years ago. I started off with MIG welding (also called "wire feed", "GMAW", or "Gas Metal Arc Welding") and then learned TIG (a.k.a. "GTAW" or "Gas Tungsten Arc Welding") welding.

If you can use a hot glue gun, you can learn to MIG weld! I took a two-day class at a local industrial arts school. It had about two hours of instructional content and the rest of the class was practicing and working on projects of our choice. If you go to a full-service welding shop and want to buy a MIG welder, they'd probably be happy to spend a half-hour showing you the ropes. Which is really about all you'll need to get started. MIG is a great process if the only thing you'll need to weld is steel. It's possible to weld aluminum, but you'd generally want a higher-end machine to which you could attach a "spool gun". One downside to MIG welding, especially for a woodworker, is that it throws sparks EVERYWHERE! Not ideal in a shop which might contain flammable wood, dust, solvents, or finishes!

TIG welding, for me, was much more difficult to learn than MIG welding. I took a class that met four hours/week for 8 weeks. By the end of the class, I was a pretty lousy welder. It wasn't until I bought my own TIG welder (to the tune of $1500 used) that I really became proficient at it. I took another 16-hour class to learn how to TIG weld aluminum. I find that if I don't TIG weld regularly that I quickly lose the hand-eye coordination necessary to produce good-looking welds. They're still solid enough, they just look ugly. TIG welding is nice in that it doesn't (normally) produce any sparks, nor toxic fumes.

These days, I do almost all of my welding with the TIG welder. It gives MUCH more flexibility than MIG. Plus, the results end up looking a lot better. At least to my eye. Because TIG is a fairly slow process, I keep the MIG welder around for cases where I have a bunch of welds that I need to do quickly and I don't care how pretty they look.

My one other piece of advice is to invest in a GOOD auto-darkening welding helmet as soon as you decide that you'll be welding on a regular basis. I started out with a $50 auto-darkening helmet from Harbor Freight. It certainly isn't a bad helmet, but it's nowhere close to the Miller Elite helmet I now use. The Miller is MUCH easier to see through and triggers more reliably than the HF helmet. I wish I'd bought one earlier...

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#12

The helmet is where its at.

Ed Snow

>Mig and stick are a piece of cake even blind, but god help you if you can't see to tig. I second the auto darkening helmet, it was one of the best big purchases I have made in a long time. Either way your life will be much easier if you get an auto darkening helmet, cheap or nearly as much as a the cheap welder.

I would also hedge your bet towards quality by spending more than 300 on a little flux core wire feed. The extra couple hundred will get you into shielding gas which is a much cleaner weld. However, if you are going to be welding out of doors it wont do you much good you will still have to use flux core.

The other option is to rent if you have a few small jobs you can pile into one day, it makes sense.

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#13

Videos *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I found these very helpful.


http://www.weldingvideos.com/

Re: OT: Learning to weld...

#14

It's not rocket science

Rob Sandow

>Any wire feed welder will get you nice results on mild steel with a little practice. Best bet is to buy some scraps, remove all paint/grease/dirt with a wire brush, and then practice. Just make a bunch of welds with some scrap steel and you will get the hang of it. My puny wire feed welder came with a video that helped a lot.

Rob