Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Ellis Walentine

>Yes, folks, it's that time again for our bi-monthly plebiscite on topics of interest to the woodworking community. As you veterans are aware, the drill goes like this: I post a pithy question on a hot topic, you hold forth with your inimitable candor and good cheer, and we throw all the answers into our editorial blender and serve them up to Woodworker West magazine, where they miraculously appear as a column called "News & Views from WoodCentral.com." Simple, eh?

Well, try this month's question on for size:

Green Woodworking?


Has the recent talk about global warming and/or other ecological concerns affected your woodworking? Is your consciousness or curiosity heightened? Have you looked into or switched over to environmentally-friendly materials, supplies or methods of work? Do you think small shops can make a difference? What more can we as a woodworking community do for the sake of the planet?

That's it. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#2

Green and Cheap...

Grant Smith

>For several years I have been a green woodworker, mostly in the way I gather lumber for projects. I enjoy the idea of taking locally obtained logs to lumber and then to a completed project. And the process feels very green as well.

I also enjoy taking a cast off piece of furniture in need of repair and breathing new life into it. And, if it is too far gone, I often salvage hardware or lumber from old wood items for use on new projects.

It is remarkable how thinking green also results in low cost projects.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#3

JL

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

JL

>I try to buy wood from "ecologically sustainable" or reasonably responsible vendors. This means I typically go with locally grown and locally harvested woods.

Unfortunately there is no "industry standard" for preserving the environment.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I try to find sources of local or urban lumber. These tend to be small local sawmills that take locally cut trees and mill and dry them. In all honesty, my main reason for seeking these places out is price and convenience. When I need types of wood that aren't available locally, I haven't found that I have much choice. I already have to drive pretty far for any source of this lumber, much less adding any other constraints to the supply. I'm not sure that small hobby woodworkers would really make any difference. I don't really study the details of the global supply chain and the economics of it all. The one thing I do know is that most of my suppliers are scraping by and my local wood supply is always in jeopardy.

Jay

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#5

Just cheap . . .

steve mackay

>While I know my gig ( model & pattern ) isn't mainstream, everyone elses scrap is my " lumber ". Several years ago I discovered the dumpster behind Fort Bliss' " Packing & Crateing " Dept.Any cutoffs not big enough for use in large crates goes in there including 3/4 ply.ALL this goes to the landfill. The cut offs are " lumber " and the ply ( cut up ) makes LOTS of firewood for our three stoves. This got me to think'n. How about those big dumpsters at construction sites ? While waste is closely calculated there is still enough ( after several stops ) to make the effort worth the trouble. Just ask before you dive ! If you do a " survey " of business dumpsters there is a wealth of shipping supplies. From boxes ( expensive )to bubble wrap ( even more expensive ! ) that goes to the landfill. My shipping supplies cost is nil ! This isn't even to mention your chances of a bonus " treasure " every once in a while. While my intention isn't to be a Greenie I figure I'm saving a couple squares in the dump and keeping my overhead next to nothing.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: Define Green?

Dale Lenz

>What I'm reading from most of the post is using recycled lumber or lumber that did not come from the forest, urban trees, etc., which is fine, but don't think that is what the standards are for 'Green' forest products. It is my understanding Green forest products comes from a "Well" managed forest. Well managed forest is defined:....60+ pages of stuff. It is my understanding, tracking of Green products is still an issue and will be for sometime. Is it a good thing? Jury is still out, IMHO. In theory, wood products will cost more due to tracking documents etc. Of course the Big Box places are jumping on the bandwagon; they purchase most of their goods from the large players in the forest industries of which their lumber is cut from their own lands and good forest management is practiced, usually. Every hear of Gate-wood? Logs from private loggers that the larger forest industries purchase. Not sure if there is proof that these logs came from Green forest, other than the logger says so.

With above all said, I personally think Green is the next large move in the forest industries. And to be honest most large forest companies have been practicing Green forest management for decades in large. I know of one large company that had purchased questionable profitable sites in a large timberland acquisition and cut all the merchantable timber off the tract with lower timber growth potential and sold the land, good business($ wise?), but not good forestry.

So I have skirted around Ellis question, but thinking most folks are not calling Green..... Green.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Has the recent talk about global warming and/or other ecological concerns affected your woodworking? No

Is your consciousness YES or curiosity heightened NO, what ever curiosity means?

Have you looked into or switched over to environmentally-friendly materials, supplies or methods of work? NO Do you think small shops can make a difference? NO What more can we as a woodworking community do for the sake of the planet? Pay more for wood so it will be perceived as more valuable and owners will plant more trees and take care of what they have. Make furniture to last so it won't have to be replaced by "disposable" furniture.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Stuart Hough

>If by "green" it is meant to be mindful of the economical use of materials, looking for environmentally low-impact finishes (where possible), and being sensitive to my surroundings (i.e. noise) then yes I am "green". BUT, I don't go out of my way to do this. I am still new to the craft, and still learning, so I use a lot of extra material fixing mistakes, and as for the finishes, I just don't like the smell (or how some make me feel!) of some of the old standby's, and I don't want the neighbors screaming about the sound. So I guess my respnse would be Yes/No.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>"Has the recent talk about global warming and/or other ecological concerns affected your woodworking?"

Yes, VOC regulations causing the reformulation of various finishes that I have used at one time or another in the last 40 years to the point that they do not perform as well or the same as they once did. This is usually rectified by adding, (against the manufacturers instructions) thinners.

"Is your consciousness or curiosity heightened?"

Yes, my curiosity/anxiaety, as in: �What are �they� going to try to take away from me today?

"Have you looked into or switched over to environmentally-friendly materials, supplies or methods of work?"

No.

"Do you think small shops can make a difference?"

No, I don�t think that the scale of small shop/hobby work has much more influence than perhaps preserving the craft.

"What more can we as a woodworking community do for the sake of the planet?"

I don�t know, like anybody else here I have salvaged wood from the side of the road, or resurrected an old piece of wooden furniture, but these sorts of things are just common sense waste-not-want-not behavior.

Do we serve the planet? This type of question invariably causes me to think of the �To Serve Man� episode on the twighlight zone.

To think that man in the 21st century is better equipped to rule over the planet than man in the 17th century is foolishness.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Robert Henderson

>I pretty much ignore the PC, "you owe it to the planet to do it our way" crowd. That having been said, I was raised by parents who lived through the Great Depression and was taught not to waste anything. It is very hard for me to let go of anything that "might be useful sometime" or to turn down anything for free. So in that sense I guess I'm "green".

As far as buying wood is concerned, I let market forces take care of it. We have already seen scarcity drive up the price on a number of species to the point that they are only used as veneer or small inlays. This will encourage someone to figure out how to raise those speices on plantations.

It worked for the paper industry, they've been self-sustaining since the early 1940's with plantation grown pulpwood.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Thomas S Stockton

>I think green woodworking is the wave of the future. When I lived in the bay area it was easy to find FSC certified wood and materials. Since moving north the two places I deal with do not carry any and it makes no sense to drive 250 miles to buy certified wood. If I'm down there on business I will try to get certified lumber it just doesn't make sense to waste that much gas.

I've been concerned about ecological damage to the worlds forests for a while. Years ago I attended a conference put on by WARP (woodworkers alliance for rain-forest protection) a group that is no more, what I came away from the conference with was that it is a very complex issue, it just isn't the clear-cutting of timber in has to do as much with economics, over population and social issues. So there is no one easy answer but there are things that can be done and buying good wood if possible is one.

Currently I live in an area with a lot of timber production and in the 9 years I've lived here it is sad to see the harvest practices go from mostly selective to a more clear-cut based practices. If you talk to the loggers and some of the independent foresters they all feel this is a very short sighted and most the loggers I know well have gotten out of that line of work because they see no future in it.

One of the volunteer things I do is that I'm the chairman of a local health clinic, we are currently in the middle of an expansion and we as a board decided early on to build a LEED certified green building, we just felt it was a good thing to do and worth the extra cost.

Can one person make a difference, YES today is Martin Luther King day look what he did, yes he had a lot of help but he had the guts to keep going and hold it all together.

Tom Stockton

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#12

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Clay Foster

>"Has the recent talk about global warming and/or other ecological concerns affected your woodworking?"

Setting aside the hot button issue of global warming, the availability of our planet's resources has changed some of my woodworking choices. I'm developing more designs that incorporate reclaimed and found wood, and trees that I get from constructions sites and tree services and mill into lumber and air dry it. It's satisfying to me to be a part of giving a second life to a grand tree as a piece of furniture or art instead of being chipped up into mulch. It hasn't been a big leap for me, since my work has been based more on design than material any way.

"Have you looked into or switched over to environmentally-friendly materials, supplies or methods of work?"

The rising cost of petroleum based finishes and the disposal of used solvents has changed my choices in finishes. I've switched from varnishes and polys as much as I can to shellac and tung oil. I can apply ting oil finishes with a folded paper towel, so I don't have to spend $8/gallon for paint thinner to clean a brush, and don't have used thinner to dispose of. Water based finishes are another option, but I haven't taken the time to learn how to use them yet.

"Do you think small shops can make a difference?"

I can make a difference in what it costs to make stuff, and in keeping my little piece of the planet cleaner.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I do not make woodworking, or any other decisions for that matter, based on ecology, global climate, or "green" considerations.

Clint

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY***

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>The simple answer to your question is "Yes". The not so simple answer is to the why and how portions of your question. Both my wife and I are interested in the homesteading ideal, going off the grid and becoming more self reliant. Now, we're not terribly worried about global warming, rising oil prices, energy crunches or other things destroying the world as we know it and forcing people back to an earlier form of living. Instead, we want to make a simpler (not necessarily easier) lifestyle for ourselves. We want to be more in touch with our food, our home and our land.

Those same ideals factor into my woodworking as well. I see a lot of waste in the woodworking world. I don't want to work that way. I try to use wood to it's maximum. I have trees milled for myself and I use wood that some lumber yards and mills wouldn't touch (mainly for mass producing economies of scale). This gives me the ability to make a piece of furniture in which I also knew where the tree grew and maybe how it was treated during it's life. Also, every piece of wood is different and I want that to show up in my work. Many places can already put out mass produced furniture that all looks the same. I want to create something that uses the woods personality in the piece. I think that if we have a close attachment to the natural world we can develop a respect for it and not treat nature quite so poorly.

Some of the things I do to try and work more "green"? Well, as I said, I have lumber milled and air dry it myself. This is lumber that may have ended up in a landfill or fireplace, so it's good use of the materials. I mix hand tool usage into my work (where it makes sense) to reduce my energy usage (i.e. I don't need to power a big circular saw to cut a few pieces of lumber to length, a handsaw works just fine). I try to use my scrap wood in other projects, otherwise it goes into the fireplace as heat for the home - again, good re-use of the materials with limited waste. I'm also working on learning better forms of joinery that require less metal goods and can create pieces that stay together for a very long time - no built in obsolescence in my work.

A little long winded, I apologize. These are some of my ideals and methods. I'm still rather new to this myself and I hope to keep learning better ways to do things while reducing my impact on the world.