Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

CAD re-visited *LINK*

Posts

CAD re-visited *LINK*

#1

CAD re-visited *LINK*

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Too cold to do much else, and the washing machine can work with minimal help from me, so I am re-visiting my CAD issue.

I am seriously now considering TurboCAD v.12. I can get it for a reasonable sum along with training CD's, symbols library, and third party book. v.12 will handle the photo formats I am interested in, and 3D is included.

There is a TurboCAD 14, so the product is being supported with updates. (more ###!!)

Autodesk doesn't really seem to have its heart in AutoSketch. It seems to get minimal support from the parent company. My impression FWIW.

So, any TurboCAD users out there? What are the pluses and minuses? This time I want to get the research right before I pull the trigger.


TurboCAD package

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#2

TurboCad 14 Deluxe is same price.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>I would go with the more current Deluxe 14 version. I'm sure there will be some included 3D tutorial and extensive "help" info included in the package.

What is your application going to be or focus on? I've seen some pretty nice work done with Google's "Sketch-up" free software.

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#3

Re: TurboCad 14 Deluxe is same price.

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Hi Eddie,

SketchUp is not a CAD program. It's thinking protocol is driving nuts! I've tried, but I am throwing in the towel on that one.

Right now I have an application that requires me to import a digital picture, superimpose a drawing on it, draw leaders on the photo for text and dimensioning outside the perimeters of the photo.

v14 by itself is not a bad price, but teh v.12 package with the training videos, symbols library, and touted third party book (usually more user friendly that the owner's manual) makes a more attractive and useful package for me. The upside is that I can later upgrade to v14. Right now the learning curve must be mastered. :)

Haven't pulled the trigger yet. Am now searching for free download trials...

Dang, it is cold out! Gonna keep me glued to the keyboard today! May as well try to accomplish something positive... :)

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#4

Re: TurboCad 14 Deluxe is same price.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Carol,

It's nice weather here today, but we're going to get some rain, or as they say here, "storms", tomorrow.

There are a lot of TurboCad users around and there must be a TurboCad group in Yahoo or MSN so helpful tips and apps. shouldn't be a problem. Of the 30 million free symbols you may end up only using .005% of them.

I hope all is going well with you.

Take care.

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#5

Free TurboCad

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I use a 2D version (1999) I downloaded for free from the IMSI site. I don't know if it or a 3D version is still available.

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#6

more info

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...I have an application that requires me to import a digital

>picture, superimpose a drawing on it, draw leaders on the photo for

>text and dimensioning outside the perimeters of the photo.

Just curious, do you need to make a 3D drawing to match and overlay some object that is in the photo, or do you simply need to place a 2D drawing on the photo, aligning it to fit on some plane or side of an object in the photo?

Also, do you have to create the drawing and figure out dimensions based on the object in the photo, or will you have a dimensioned drawing to start with?

JKJ

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#7

Re: more info

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Right now I need to place a 2D drawing on the photo, aligning it to fit on some plane in the photo. The 3D stuff is for future use. And I will have to create the drawing and figure out dimensions based on the object in the photo, although the other scenario may present itself as well.

I will have hard dimensions from measuring the item photographed, if that is some help.

What are you thinking, John?

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#8

Re: more info

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>What are you thinking, John?

Usually something way off in space..., but I've done variations of this many times in the past for my work (before I retired).

I always used my 3D Studio Max software for such things, both for fitting a 3D models and/or 2D planar things onto a 2D photo of 3D things (confuses even me). I did this mostly to add future buildings and things to existing photographs, but it would work as well for furniture, etc. SketchUp has facilities to do this, although I have not used it for that purpose myself. I read a tutorial recently on creating a 3D model from a photograph. Seems like what you need would be simpler - use the method to find the plane, create or import the drawing, then fit the drawing to the plane. The rest should just be scaling and annotation. I'm certainly no SketchUp expert, but I'd be glad to try to find the tutorial and take a look at the method if it might help.

You can also fit a 2D drawing to an object in a 3D photograph by using Photoshop, even if there is significant perspective. I did the very simple example below (with Dick Parr at my sawmill) by drawing a rectangle (with dimension lines) then using the perspective command to fit it to the photo, anotating afterwards. I'm not sure if this will do what you need, but it was very quick.

JKJ


img

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#9

Re: more info

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Thanks again, John.

I really only want to learn one new program. Truth be told I really don't want to do that. :) But AutoCAD has got to go! And I am hooked on using a CAD program for so darn many things. SketchUp and I are not speaking to one another and it isn't a CAD program. I just can't get my head wrapped around it for some reason.

So it comes down to a new CAD program. Something reasonably priced and hopefully with the features I've outlined in earlier posts.

I don't do PhotoShop either. I am not much of a camera bug and an old version of Paint Shop Pro works for me for the little bit of cropping and resizing I do with it. All my programs are getting long in the tooth. I guess the upside of that is that for the most part I can do what I can do. With the CAD stuff I am being pushed to change something. The computer really gets cranky and locks up when using AutoCAD. Certainly upgrading AutoCAD is out of the question. I don't even PLAY Powerball! :) Let alone win it!

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#10

Re: CAD re-visited

Scott Whiting - Glendale, AZ

>I am certainly not near the power user you are. I have been using TurboCad v9 for a few years now. Mostly for tracing scanned drawings or moulding samples. As such I am working in single layer 2D. The whole moulding knife operation sat for almost 2 years before I finally told myself I am going to learn this. I have gotten to the point I can draw from scratch in Cad faster than with a pencil (and the lines are straight :-) ). I have a customer that is proficient in AutoCad and TurboCad and he is of the opinion he prefers TurboCad unless he is working in an environment that requires the AutoCad interface.

Scott

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#11

Re: CAD re-visited

ScottS

>I use TurboCAD Deluxe. Currently, I'm using V11. Couldn't tell the difference between that and any of the more recent upgrades, so I haven't bothered to purchase them. For 2D drafting, I think it's a pretty good program! I looked at several others before buying. Haven't invested in any of their training materials. I think I just went through the tutorials that were available on-line or that came with the software.

One thing I will say is that despite trying, I could never figure out how to do 3D with TurboCAD. There wasn't a tutorial for 3D. I tried reading the manual, but wasn't able to get anywhere... and I'm a software engineer! If you want to do 3D with TurboCAD, you'll definitely need additional training materials. Or, better yet, a completely different software package. I now use Solidworks for 3D CAD. Luckily, I was taking some classes at a local community college and was able to buy the educational version of Solidworks for less than TurboCAD cost me. I find it easier to use than SketchUp, and it has all of the power you'd ever need from a CAD program. Highly recommended... if you need 3D.

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#12

Re: CAD re-visited

Art Liebeskind

>Scott,

I have access to Solidworks and it looks daunting. Is there any basic info. The videos are fast and seem to assume knowldge in advance. Where are you located? Any suggestions, I am in Baltimore, MD.

Thanks

Art Liebeskind

410-542-3846

Re: CAD re-visited *LINK*

#13

Re: CAD re-visited

ScottS

>Art, I'm out in California which probably doesn't help you too much.

I suppose I should admit that I had some basic knowledge of 2D CAD before I attempted to use Solidworks. I've got the 2006 Student Edition. In my version, I can get to their tutorials by selecting "Online Tutorial" from the "Help" menu. Or on the right side of the window is a tool palette. The top icon looks like a house and has a tool tip that says "Solidworks Resources". Clicking it will open a panel that includes buttons titled "Making My First Part", "Making My First Drawing", and "Online Tutorial". The online tutorial in my version has a "30 Minute Lesson" that I started with. I then went on to do "Lesson 1 - Parts", "Lesson 2 - Assemblies", and "Lesson 3 - Drawings".

If you have some 2D CAD experience, those should be enough to get you started. Once I'd gone through those basics, I started looking at other tutorials that I thought might be useful or interesting. They tend not to be quite a good as the basics, but they're not too bad. Occasionally, it will take some time to find one of the buttons or commands that the tutorial mentions. Some of the more advanced tutorials seem to assume that you've

One thing to understand about Solidworks is that the usage model seems to be targeted toward mechanical engineers. The basic workflow is to create 3D parts. You then combine those parts into an "assembly", which is basically a 3D model of your object. And once you have an assembly, you can create 2D "drawings" that show the object from various different angles along with any necessary dimensions. So, if you wanted to create a table you'd start out by creating parts for a leg, the top, and an apron. Then you'd create an assembly that combined four legs, four aprons, and a top into a finished table.

In addition to the on-line tutorial, I also bought the book that my local community college uses for their introductory SolidWorks class. It's called "Engineering Design with Solidworks 2006" by David C. Planchard and Marie P. Planchard published by Schroff Development Corp. (www.schroff.com). Oh, my, is it TERRIBLE! I think it got pretty good reviews on Amazon, which probably means it's the best you can do. There's actually quite a bit of good content, but the editing and layout is very sloppy at times. They revise the book every year, to match the latest yearly SolidWorks release and it looks like the book is due for an overhaul.